Amppax Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 Here's the link. http://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/german-bishops-morning-after-pill-decision-causes-concern/ It would seems that there's a lot more here than what it seems on the surface, it seems a lot like the outcry about Pope Benedict's statements about condoms a few year ago. It seems there's a nuanced moral theology issue at play here. But I admit, I was pretty disturbed when I first saw this.
Nihil Obstat Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 The key here, as I see it, is whether or not they can truly guarantee that this pill will not prevent implantation of a zygote. If they can guarantee that beyond any reasonable doubt, then we can discuss a few more of the secondary issues, but if that cannot be guaranteed, then it is indefensible.
KnightofChrist Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 "If there is a pill that prevents that there be a conception in cases of rape, then it is licit to prevent it." [However,] "We have no knowledge of a morning-after pill without abortifacient effects. If it does exist, it may be used, with the doctrine we have." "If it does exist, we will be sure to know it .... all morning-after pills have this possible abortive effect. Therefore, its use is illicit. If it does exist in Germany, we are not aware of it. It is not known to us that this technical possibility exists." - Bishop Juan Antonio MartÃnez Camino (Source: http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2013/02/the-spaniards-get-it-right-and-dangers.html)
Nihil Obstat Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 "If there is a pill that prevents that there be a conception in cases of rape, then it is licit to prevent it." [However,] "We have no knowledge of a morning-after pill without abortifacient effects. If it does exist, it may be used, with the doctrine we have." "If it does exist, we will be sure to know it .... all morning-after pills have this possible abortive effect. Therefore, its use is illicit. If it does exist in Germany, we are not aware of it. It is not known to us that this technical possibility exists." - Bishop Juan Antonio MartÃnez Camino (Source: http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2013/02/the-spaniards-get-it-right-and-dangers.html) The doctors I have heard quoted, including in the article in the OP, seem to agree that the existence of a truly non-abortifacient morning after pill is sketchy at best.
Amppax Posted March 5, 2013 Author Posted March 5, 2013 The key here, as I see it, is whether or not they can truly guarantee that this pill will not prevent implantation of a zygote. If they can guarantee that beyond any reasonable doubt, then we can discuss a few more of the secondary issues, but if that cannot be guaranteed, then it is indefensible. I guess I'm just confused as to why it's allowed. Maybe I'm being dense, but why is it okay to allow contraception here? I mean, it's a terrible situation, and I don't mean to be offensive, because it's truly a terrible situation. But I'd always thought that contraception wasn't ever allowed. Someone I talked to earlier was saying that this wasn't the case, that was referring to marriage. I guess I'm just a little confused. I understand the distinction between the drug preventing implantation vs. being an abortifacient; I'm wondering why the first is okay.
KnightofChrist Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 The doctors I have heard quoted, including in the article in the OP, seem to agree that the existence of a truly non-abortifacient morning after pill is sketchy at best. It just goes back to negligence and imprudence on part of the German Bishops, like that of imploding a residential building without knowing whether or not it is occupied by human beings.
Nihil Obstat Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 I guess I'm just confused as to why it's allowed. Maybe I'm being dense, but why is it okay to allow contraception here? I mean, it's a terrible situation, and I don't mean to be offensive, because it's truly a terrible situation. But I'd always thought that contraception wasn't ever allowed. Someone I talked to earlier was saying that this wasn't the case, that was referring to marriage. I guess I'm just a little confused. I understand the distinction between the drug preventing implantation vs. being an abortifacient; I'm wondering why the first is okay. I would quickly be getting out of my depth in this subject, but this is how I understand the situation as-is. The prohibition against contraception applies specifically to consensual sexual intercourse, which of course is only licit in marriage. The primary reason contraception is wrong is that it undermines the twofold purpose of intercourse, which is that it be procreative and unitive. It undermines both aspects, first because one actively rejects the procreative obligation, and second because one holds a vital piece of themselves back from their partner. The argument is that our objections to contraception do not apply in the case of rape, because the act itself is already such a violation that its unitive aspect is utterly annihilated. Like I said, I am getting very quickly out of my depth, so I do not want to say more than this. And I will also be clear that this represents the status of the question as I understand it, rather than my personal views on the matter. It just goes back to negligence and imprudence on part of the German Bishops, like that of imploding a residential building without knowing whether or not it is occupied by human beings. If I am remembering correctly, this is the same bishops' conference that was found to own a publishing company that published erotic novels. What exactly is going on in Germany these days? :blink:
4588686 Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 If I am remembering correctly, this is the same bishops' conference that was found to own a publishing company that published erotic novels. What exactly is going on in Germany these days? :blink: The erotic universe of the German people is famously something that that you should avoid poking too deeply into.
Gabriela Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 The erotic universe of the German people is famously something that that you should avoid poking too deeply into. Amen. Largest porn industry in the world. The annual "Love" Parade... I asked this question in another thread on this topic and never got an answer: What if a woman is raped by her husband? Assuming that such a non-abortifacent morning-after pill were procurable, could she take it?
Evangetholic Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 Are the erotic novels Church approved? *is hopeful*
4588686 Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 Amen. Largest porn industry in the world. The annual "Love" Parade... I asked this question in another thread on this topic and never got an answer: What if a woman is raped by her husband? Assuming that such a non-abortifacent morning-after pill were procurable, could she take it? Well, for most of European history, at least in the anglophone world, the idea of marital rape was not a coherent concept. Until the later half of the 20th century is was impossible for a husband to rape his wife. Once given, consent could not be withdrawn. I wonder if that history was codified at all in Church doctrine (genuinely don't know)
Evangetholic Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 Husband and wife are neither to force, nor refuse one another. Refusing the act can only be done for grave reasons. Forcing may never be done.
Gabriela Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 Well, for most of European history, at least in the anglophone world, the idea of marital rape was not a coherent concept. Until the later half of the 20th century is was impossible for a husband to rape his wife. Once given, consent could not be withdrawn. I wonder if that history was codified at all in Church doctrine (genuinely don't know) I know. That's why I'm asking!
Gabriela Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 Husband and wife are neither to force, nor refuse one another. Refusing the act can only be done for grave reasons. Forcing may never be done. Right. It "may" never be done in society at large, either, and yet it happens all the time. So... The question is: Would the Church recognize such a rape as forced and permit the woman to take the pill, or would the Church argue that there is no such thing as marital rape and so forbid her to take the pill? That's the whole point I'm trying to get at here.
Gabriela Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 Really Germany?! Who knew, eh? Nasty porn, too... Way worse than the American stuff.
the171 Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 Who knew, eh? Nasty porn, too... Way worse than the American stuff. No, I already knew that. I'm talking about the dang bishops.
PhuturePriest Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 I think the real issue at hand is that Hasan is impersonating himself as me. Or a Benedictine Priest from the wedding. Either way, identity theft is a crime, Mr. Hasan.
Evangetholic Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 Right. It "may" never be done in society at large, either, and yet it happens all the time. So... The question is: Would the Church recognize such a rape as forced and permit the woman to take the pill, or would the Church argue that there is no such thing as marital rape and so forbid her to take the pill? That's the whole point I'm trying to get at here. I think the issue of "contraception" gets way more complicated when explicitly connected with marriage (I could say more about this, but I will not).
Slappo Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 I would quickly be getting out of my depth in this subject, but this is how I understand the situation as-is. The prohibition against contraception applies specifically to consensual sexual intercourse, which of course is only licit in marriage. The primary reason contraception is wrong is that it undermines the twofold purpose of intercourse, which is that it be procreative and unitive. It undermines both aspects, first because one actively rejects the procreative obligation, and second because one holds a vital piece of themselves back from their partner. The argument is that our objections to contraception do not apply in the case of rape, because the act itself is already such a violation that its unitive aspect is utterly annihilated. Like I said, I am getting very quickly out of my depth, so I do not want to say more than this. And I will also be clear that this represents the status of the question as I understand it, rather than my personal views on the matter. If I am remembering correctly, this is the same bishops' conference that was found to own a publishing company that published erotic novels. What exactly is going on in Germany these days? :blink: Crap I just had soemthign written up to add to this but don't have time to rewrite it all. The sperm is an aggressor in the scenario of rape. Until the sperm and egg are conjoined where a zygote is formed and a human soul is created, the woman can protect herself and her fertility from the aggressor through any means available (spermicide, a non-abortificient medication, etc). Hypothetically if the victim had the option of whether or not a condom was used in a case of rape, the victim could opt to have a condom used and would not be guilty of the sin of contraception. This only applies to non-consensual intercourse. I won't touch the question of contraceptives in a case of rape within a marriage with a 10 foot pole... :)
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now