Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

American Catholics say that their church and bishops are out of touch, but they feel far more warmly toward their local priests and nuns.

 

I say American Catholics are out of touch with the Church. Except all of us of course :)

Posted

"Do you think it’s possible to disagree with the pope on issues like birth control, abortion or divorce and still be a good Catholic?"

 

83% answered possible.

 

83% of "Catholics" polled are phishy.

Posted

I say The New York Times is of touch with the Catholic's. Them surveys are Skewed

Posted

The poll reveals the terrible state of catechesis in the Church in the United States.

Posted

I say The New York Times is of touch with the Catholic's. Them surveys are Skewed

I think the poll is probably pretty accurate in registering the views of those who self-identify as Catholic. Of course those who self-identify as Catholic may not be active in the Church.

Autumn Dusk
Posted

Going to a bible study, I'd say that's about accurate.  If someone stands for the truth others just leave.  Half the time the priest is liberal anyway...the one at my church daily mourns that we "still haven't" allowed women priests

Posted

When you change the poll results to show only those who attend mass every week the results improve, although, not to where they should.

 

It is also interesting to note that despite the campaign to make anything pro-life appear to be "anti-woman", more men believe that abortion should be legal than women do.

ToJesusMyHeart
Posted

My increasingly liberally-minded school trashpaper (newspaper), has a front page article today about the conclave, but it mostly uses that as a reason to bash the Church.  :getaclue:

 

One line of dozens that irk me, "You name almost any issue and there's going to be a divergence from what the Church ordains and the opinions of its people. The ordination of women, or the use of birth control or contraceptives, and gay marriage for example. You take any issue where there is a papal statement or a condemnation from the hierarchy of the church (wtf is up with the lower-case c all thru the article??), and then you look at the practices and political perspectives and the social perspectives of practicing Roman Catholics, and you're going to find tremendous divergence on many issues."

 

If you aren't following the Church's teachings, you're not a practicing Roman Catholic. 

 

Student newspapers are the worst.   :x

Posted

The poll reveals the terrible state of catechesis in the Church in the United States.

 

I agree with that sadly enough. I am an unfortunate victim of that. Even with the help of my dear parents I still did not get the proper catechesis. I do blame the part of the multiple moves my family went though and each diocese is different. But there should be some sort of cohesivness and transprancy to a point with all diocese espically when it comes to catechesis. I ended up teaching myself alot of times on stuff like this. I feel like the only programs that got the best catechesis some times are the RCIA/RCIC and I sometime doubt that as well. However, I do know alot more about the catholic faith though what I have learned on my own. Without it, I think I would of been scerwed and been one of those catholics. I did use the Vatican website and Catholic Answers/ Catholic Encylopedia for help.

Autumn Dusk
Posted

My increasingly liberally-minded school trashpaper (newspaper), has a front page article today about the conclave, but it mostly uses that as a reason to bash the Church.  :getaclue:

 

One line of dozens that irk me, "You name almost any issue and there's going to be a divergence from what the Church ordains and the opinions of its people. The ordination of women, or the use of birth control or contraceptives, and gay marriage for example. You take any issue where there is a papal statement or a condemnation from the hierarchy of the church (what tha' fa fa fa fa fonze? is up with the lower-case c all thru the article??), and then you look at the practices and political perspectives and the social perspectives of practicing Roman Catholics, and you're going to find tremendous divergence on many issues."

 

If you aren't following the Church's teachings, you're not a practicing Roman Catholic. 

 

Student newspapers are the worst.   :x

 

But this is just an innane posting of the obvious, not some kind of liberal curve.

ToJesusMyHeart
Posted

It's a liberal curve when the whole article just rails on the Church and names error after error, and every few sentences bringing up the sex scandals again, just in case we forgot a few sentences back. 

 

That was one of the mild paragraphs. 

Posted

It's a liberal curve when the whole article just rails on the Church and names error after error, and every few sentences bringing up the sex scandals again, just in case we forgot a few sentences back. 

 

That was one of the mild paragraphs. 

 

Well the sex abuse scandal stuff doesn't bother me. We deserve everything we get on that score. Sure it's annoying when they bring it up over and over. But if it's brought up over and over, maybe people will get it in their heads that there truly was deep systemic corruption and failure in the heart of the church (the sacred priesthood of Jesus Christ).


I routinely fail to follow the Church's teachings on purity (being married doesn't mean the problems in that department are over), kindness (duh) and care for the environment (I usually am too lazy to recycle). That doesn't mean I'm not a practicing Catholic, it means I'm a practicing Catholic - I'm working on it.

 

Most of these people aren't actually committing the sins (having abortions or gay marriages or getting themselves ordained if they are women). Contraception, ok most of them are. But in most cases it's a matter of wrong belief not wrong action.

 

and regardless, the reason these people are lost is because the devout have let their lights be hidden. The human heart is not attracted to sourness. Nobody turns toward Calvary hoping to be scolded by the scowling, cross, and unhappy Christians one encounters everywhere. If the worldly look at the Church and don't see transforming joy, they only see rigidness and sterility, whose fault is that? Not the Lord's. And not theirs. They can only see what we put in front of them.

 

There's so much dysfunction in the Church today. The people who are confused about sex are only 50% of it. Truly this institution must be of divine origin to have survived her members.

Posted

"Even observant Catholics are not following the bishops’ lead on issues that the Church has recently been fighting – artificial birth control and gay marriage."

 

Uh... says who?

Posted

Most of these people aren't actually committing the sins (having abortions or gay marriages or getting themselves ordained if they are women). Contraception, ok most of them are. But in most cases it's a matter of wrong belief not wrong action.

 

How do you know this? Do you work for the NYT or CBS?

Posted

How do you know this? Do you work for the NYT or CBS?

 


No just statistically speaking, most people who support gay marriage are not gay themselves, and most people who are pro-abortion rights have not had an abortion themselves ,and every few years there's a half dozen women who go out in a boat and pretend to be ordained as Catholic priestesses. But that's nothing compared to the millions of casual Catholics who would answer, also very casually, "sure, women priests, pro-choice, gay rights, love it" if asked. The majority aren't activists by any means but they are certainly children of their time.

Posted

I say it's not possible to be a good Catholic.

Posted


No just statistically speaking, most people who support gay marriage are not gay themselves, and most people who are pro-abortion rights have not had an abortion themselves ,and every few years there's a half dozen women who go out in a boat and pretend to be ordained as Catholic priestesses. But that's nothing compared to the millions of casual Catholics who would answer, also very casually, "sure, women priests, pro-choice, gay rights, love it" if asked. The majority aren't activists by any means but they are certainly children of their time.

 

What about the contraception question, and the "following your conscience over the Pope" question?

Posted

What about the contraception question, and the "following your conscience over the Pope" question?

 


well as I said on contraception, that's one they're all doing. On "on difficult moral questions, which are you more likely to follow - the teachings of the Pope, or your conscience?" in fact the Church teaches very clearly in the catechism that no one should ever act contrary to their conscience. I hope 100% of Catholics including the Pope would say "my conscience." The key is to have a well-formed conscience which the vast majority of people do not have in the catechetical wasteland.

Evangetholic
Posted

I've noticed an odd tendency of Catholics to turn docile and accept Church Teaching when the reasoning behind it is presented. The strongest resistance I've seen is in response to women's ordination and GLBT issues--but it seems that if there's some way to communicate that the Church does not consider women imbeciles or (despite opinions to the contrary from some laymen) gay people as prophets of the doom of Western Civilization, then that resistance usually disappears or at least turns into "the assent of faith."

 

And I'm not certain whether or not Winchester is serious, but he's quite correct. I think the line between "good" Catholics and "bad" ones is more permeable than many of us would like. If people are preserving a Catholic identity, but not quite succeeding in preserving faith then it's the duty of those of us who believe as the Church believes to expose them to the richness of Catholic spirituality, history, and thought.

 

Even before I came back to the Church (including during a period of time when I thought the Church was Christian, but somehow managed to obfuscate the Gospel), I couldn't help loving Her. I felt an internal desire to believe as She believed, but no one made a cogent case for me.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...