Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm single and a candidate with a secular institute. Most institutes are for women, but there are some for men too. Perhaps this is an avenue that you could explore. However, you should know right from the outset that simply feeling as though marriage isn't for you would not be considered a sign of having such a vocation - you need to have some kind of positive attraction to this life, not feel as though it's your only option.

HisChildForever
Posted


The disordered nature of my affective desires means that marriage is an undesirable end. It's a state incompatible with my own happiness that could only result in unhappiness and feelings of inadequacy for the other party--not an especially upsetting realization to reach, but I'm not certain as to where to go from here (vis-a-vis living a life of use to God that protects my sanity and holiness without multiplying anyone else's burdens). I've made enough posts before this one for people to able to piece together the exact situation, but my understandings of modesty, politeness, and privacy have sufficiently changed that I'll not be more explicit about "why" than this statement.

 

I could've sworn I saw a post of yours mentioning a girlfriend...

Debra Little
Posted

Well Evangetholic, I can tell you right now, people are probably reluctant to touch this topic, at least around here. Mostly because there are a number of very outspoken people who think that being single is not a proper vocational state except for people who somehow can't possibly make marriage or religious life work. I think that's an awful narrow view of vocation myself.


I tried religious life and had to leave because of my health. I was married for 12 years and he died. I am not interested in going that route again. I enjoy single life and feel this is my calling now.
Posted


I think marriage is predicated at least in part on a kind of preoccupation, very strong physical attraction, and desire that I do not think I could ever have with a woman--honestly I think I'd eventually start to feel the relationship to be a cross, and that she would be missing her opportunity to be loved as she ought.

 

That's just an incorrect understanding of marriage. Attraction and physical desire are definitely a plus, but they are not a requirement of either the vocation or the sacrament.

HisChildForever
Posted

That's just an incorrect understanding of marriage. Attraction and physical desire are definitely a plus, but they are not a requirement of either the vocation or the sacrament.

 

I would think that spouses are attracted to each other - and whether or not they're considered physically attractive to outside eyes wouldn't concern them.

Posted

Another possibility is singleness devoted to a life of service. There are several Catholic agencies in the USA that accept people for short and long term volunteering in various areas. A lot of it is service to the urban poor in various respects in major cities such as NYC, LA, Chicago and the like, but not necessarily.It might not be a life that gets any sort of canonical recognition, but it might b something to look into

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I would think that spouses are attracted to each other - and whether or not they're considered physically attractive to outside eyes wouldn't concern them.

Ideally yes, but even if there is zero attraction between them they can still live out the vocation to married life flawlessly.

HisChildForever
Posted

Ideally yes, but even if there is zero attraction between them they can still live out the vocation to married life flawlessly.

 

I totally get that, but I can't believe that spouses don't find at least one thing physically appealing about the other. One's love for one's spouse, plus the spouse's inner beauty and personality, would make it (to me) impossible not to find some physically attractive trait.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I totally get that, but I can't believe that spouses don't find at least one thing physically appealing about the other. One's love for one's spouse, plus the spouse's inner beauty and personality, would make it (to me) impossible not to find some physically attractive trait.

I would hope so. I cannot imagine spending my life with someone to whom I was not pretty strongly attracted.

Posted

With physical attraction I think the way you feel about a person can make them more physically attractive to you. I always thought my boyfriend was good-looking, but the more I love him the more attractive I think he is. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

I don't know anything about love or relationships, but in my small experience in this stuff, I have been quite surprised with how attraction works. I always thought my "type" was a blond with long flat hair who was slightly shorter than me. Boy was I surprised when Emily, a curly brown haired girl with long-ish hair, knocked my socks off. I didn't even notice she wasn't a blond or didn't fit my type because I was too busy being infatuated with her. This is how it has always worked since then. Not once have I ever really liked a blond girl. Every single girl of the three girls I have really liked has always had brown hair, and never would have passed as attractive in my old standards of what my "type" consisted of. I've thought all three were amazingly beautiful and have learned there is no such thing as a type. The more I get to know them as friends, the more attractive they are to me. The less contact I have had with one, the less strongly I have felt about her and the less I have found her attractive (Though I still think she is). I can only imagine how much stronger attraction grows when you are actually in a relationship with someone.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I don't know anything about love or relationships, but in my small experience in this stuff, I have been quite surprised with how attraction works. I always thought my "type" was a blond with long flat hair who was slightly shorter than me. Boy was I surprised when Emily, a curly brown haired girl with long-ish hair, knocked my socks off. I didn't even notice she wasn't a blond or didn't fit my type because I was too busy being infatuated with her. This is how it has always worked since then. Not once have I ever really liked a blond girl. Every single girl of the three girls I have really liked has always had brown hair, and never would have passed as attractive in my old standards of what my "type" consisted of. I've thought all three were amazingly beautiful and have learned there is no such thing as a type. The more I get to know them as friends, the more attractive they are to me. The less contact I have had with one, the less strongly I have felt about her and the less I have found her attractive (Though I still think she is). I can only imagine how much stronger attraction grows when you are actually in a relationship with someone.

I am relatively sure that almost nobody actually knows who their type is.

HisChildForever
Posted

I don't know anything about love or relationships, but in my small experience in this stuff, I have been quite surprised with how attraction works. I always thought my "type" was a blond with long flat hair who was slightly shorter than me. Boy was I surprised when Emily, a curly brown haired girl with long-ish hair, knocked my socks off. I didn't even notice she wasn't a blond or didn't fit my type because I was too busy being infatuated with her. This is how it has always worked since then. Not once have I ever really liked a blond girl. Every single girl of the three girls I have really liked has always had brown hair, and never would have passed as attractive in my old standards of what my "type" consisted of. I've thought all three were amazingly beautiful and have learned there is no such thing as a type. The more I get to know them as friends, the more attractive they are to me. The less contact I have had with one, the less strongly I have felt about her and the less I have found her attractive (Though I still think she is). I can only imagine how much stronger attraction grows when you are actually in a relationship with someone.

 

That's because you realized that beauty - well, physical beauty - goes behind a person's hair color. That's why I've always rolled my eyes at the old "men love blondes more than anything" because, well, if she has brittle hair and scaly dry skin her hair color really doesn't matter lol. I like instead to consider what a particular "look" means to a person. For example, maybe you equated blonde hair to daintiness or a rare jewel. But then when you actually met those rare jewels you realized that there's more to it than one physical characteristic. As for myself, the actors I crush on tend to have very dark brown eyes. Maybe it's just coincidence, I don't know. My boyfriend has green eyes though and I think he's the most gorgeous man on the planet. So you're definitely right - there's just something in another person that either pulls us in or strikes us as magnificent. I mean, your future wife might have dark brown hair, but how many women with dark brown hair have you *not* noticed - until you see her and you think wow, she has the most amazing, most beautiful hair I've ever seen.

PhuturePriest
Posted

That's because you realized that beauty - well, physical beauty - goes behind a person's hair color. That's why I've always rolled my eyes at the old "men love blondes more than anything" because, well, if she has brittle hair and scaly dry skin her hair color really doesn't matter lol. I like instead to consider what a particular "look" means to a person. For example, maybe you equated blonde hair to daintiness or a rare jewel. But then when you actually met those rare jewels you realized that there's more to it than one physical characteristic. As for myself, the actors I crush on tend to have very dark brown eyes. Maybe it's just coincidence, I don't know. My boyfriend has green eyes though and I think he's the most gorgeous man on the planet. So you're definitely right - there's just something in another person that either pulls us in or strikes us as magnificent. I mean, your future wife might have dark brown hair, but how many women with dark brown hair have you *not* noticed - until you see her and you think wow, she has the most amazing, most beautiful hair I've ever seen.

 

Exactly. Honestly, the only reason I was biased towards blonds was because when I was younger I read a book series and one of the main characters was a beautiful girl with blond hair. I guess I equated her attractive personality with her hair or something, so I then liked blondes. Either way, it doesn't matter because a physical type really doesn't exist. If you square the type of girl you like into a little box like I did you will miss out on amazing girls that you would have liked. What matters is what is attractive in someone's personality, rather than in their physical appearance. I've never liked a girl I didn't think was really attractive. But I don't know if that's because I liked them or because they really were objectively attractive or not. My sister didn't ever think Emily was that much of a looker. I thought she was the most beautiful girl I had ever seen. The most beautiful model couldn't compare with her, in my opinion. I guess that's why I think interior attraction is what really attracts you to someone, and not physical attraction. Through interior attraction you will reach physical attraction. Or that's been my experience, anyway. It's probably not a 100% foolproof ideology.
 

Posted (edited)

I am relatively sure that almost nobody actually knows who their type is.

 

I know exactly who my type is. It's the person whose name is on my marriage license :|.

 

If it's not, then I'm in awfully big trouble when I get home tonight!

Edited by Slappo
Not The Philosopher
Posted

I'm at something of a similar crossroads in that I don't know what I'm doing with myself. I'm having difficulty seeing how my current single life could become a form of service (especially since I feel comfortable with it more because I am a lone wolf kind of guy than anything else). I don't want to deny the possibility of religious or married life on account of them being too hard, but realistically speaking getting from A to B in either of those cases seems like a bit of a stretch at this point in time.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I know exactly who my type is. It's the person whose name is on my marriage license :|.

 

If it's not, then I'm in awfully big trouble when I get home tonight!

Addendum:

I am relatively sure that nobody actually knows who their type is until they marry them. And even then sometimes not.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Addendum:

I am relatively sure that nobody actually knows who their type is until they marry them. And even then sometimes not.

 

I'm almost certain my type will be my wife when I marry her. I can't imagine still not knowing at that point.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I'm almost certain my type will be my wife when I marry her. I can't imagine still not knowing at that point.

The current divorce rate implies that many people are pretty clueless, going into marriage.

Posted

The way I've understood it,   the single vocation isn't a "Vocation" with a Capital V  but it could be a "vocation" (lower case v). We are all called to  a vocation but we aren't all nesicairly called to a "Vocation" I've felt called to stay single  for quite a while now, and was  lead to a tailspin of confusion until recently.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...