Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Genesis And Evolution


Recommended Posts

Evangetholic
Posted

We should be careful with mitochondrial Eve and Y-chromosomal Adam. These ancestors are not in all likelihood the Biblical Adam and Eve. They lived at different times. (Our ultimate traceable male line ancestor and female line ancestress)

Posted

We should be careful with mitochondrial Eve and Y-chromosomal Adam. These ancestors are not in all likelihood the Biblical Adam and Eve. They lived at different times. (Our ultimate traceable male line ancestor and female line ancestress)

 

Y-chomosomal Adam should be called Noah rather than Adam

Evangetholic
Posted

Y-chomosomal Adam should be called Noah rather than Adam

 


This is true. I'd never considered this. But it would actually explain the greater diversity in mitochondrial DNA than Y-chromosomes.

CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

Pope Emeritus, Benedict XVI, has spoken on the topic of faith and evolution several times. 

 

Currently, I see in Germany, but also in the United States, a somewhat fierce debate raging between so-called "creationism" and evolutionism, presented as though they were mutually exclusive alternatives: those who believe in the Creator would not be able to conceive of evolution, and those who instead support evolution would have to exclude God. This antithesis is absurd because, on the one hand, there are so many scientific proofs in favour of evolution which appears to be a reality we can see and which enriches our knowledge of life and being as such. But on the other, the doctrine of evolution does not answer every query, especially the great philosophical question: where does everything come from? And how did everything start which ultimately led to man? I believe this is of the utmost importance.

http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/benedict_xvi/speeches/2007/july/documents/hf_ben-xvi_spe_20070724_clero-cadore_en.html

 

You're thought, HCF, seems to fit within Church understanding/teaching. Many theologians fall within the Intelligent Design theory, which is not to be confused with "creationism" (No evolution, earth is 6,000 years old). The ID theory is simply that there is evolution, but God remains the driving and directing force. 

 

 

Interestingly enough, Benedict actually spoke at a conference on this topic. It has been made into a book entitled "Creation and Evolution: A Conference with Pope Benedict XVI in Castel Gandolfo."

 

Edited by CatholicCid
EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

It should be noted that any literal interpretation of Genesis has to deal with chapter 4. Cain complains about being a wanderer in danger of being killed, and also becomes the founder of a city. Could Adam and Eve have populated the earth in one generation? When we get into it, Genesis 2-3 tells us less about the details than I think is often presumed. There could have been other people contributing to our lineage genetically, but with the previous mentioned "theological Adam and Eve" as our common ancestral couple (hence the descent of original sin).

 

It seems like trying to date the Fall is a futile exercise, as we would have multiple common ancestral points in our genealogy. It's safe to say that by Abraham's time at the latest, everyone on the earth had inherited original sin. That's the important thing here, and trying to determine anything more is a wild goose chase.

 

And in the spirit of St. Thomas, I'm open to correction here ;-)

Evangetholic
Posted

I think you're right.

Posted

It should be noted that any literal interpretation of Genesis has to deal with chapter 4. Cain complains about being a wanderer in danger of being killed, and also becomes the founder of a city. Could Adam and Eve have populated the earth in one generation? When we get into it, Genesis 2-3 tells us less about the details than I think is often presumed. There could have been other people contributing to our lineage genetically, but with the previous mentioned "theological Adam and Eve" as our common ancestral couple (hence the descent of original sin).

 

It seems like trying to date the Fall is a futile exercise, as we would have multiple common ancestral points in our genealogy. It's safe to say that by Abraham's time at the latest, everyone on the earth had inherited original sin. That's the important thing here, and trying to determine anything more is a wild goose chase.

 

And in the spirit of St. Thomas, I'm open to correction here ;-)

 

The further back we go the murkier it gets but if we lean towards a literal reading of Genesis, Adam and Eve are perhaps some 300,000 years from our time and Noah some 50,000 years

Posted (edited)


We should be careful with mitochondrial Eve and Y-chromosomal Adam. These ancestors are not in all likelihood the Biblical Adam and Eve. They lived at different times. (Our ultimate traceable male line ancestor and female line ancestress)

Interesting...What exactly do you mean ? Not attacking I think I may agree...Are you taliking perhaps different earth ages ? Can everything become almost like the old show the twilight zone ? Can things happen that haven't happened? And perhaps things that haven't happened actually happen ? The Lamb was slain before the foundation of this world...What does that actually mean ? Not trying to get real weird here but at the same time it seems as if things could be deeper then we comprehend..............Yes I'm drinking....I love you all.... Edited by Guest
Nihil Obstat
Posted

Interesting...What exactly do you mean ? Not attacking I think I may agree...Are you taliking perhaps different earth ages ? Can everything become almost like the old show the twilight zone ? Can things happen that haven't happened? And perhaps things that haven't happened actually happen ? The Lamb was slain before the foundation of this world...What does that actually mean ? Not trying to get real weird here but at the same time it seems as if things could be deeper then we comprehend..............Yes I'm drinking....I love you all....

Way simpler than that, dude.

Genetically speaking, there is one man from whom every person currently on earth descended, and there is one woman from whom every person on earth descended. But those two people did not live in the same time period. I think they were separated by something like 200 000 years, or close to it. It means that the human population went through a bottleneck at those two particular points.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

For what it's worth, the Catholic Church does hold that we can believe in a "literal" interpretation of Genesis, or that God used something that resembles the scientific theory of evolution.  As long as you hold to the truths that God is the Creator, creation is good, humans are special, God wants to have a relationship with humanity, and the Bible isn't a lie...you're pretty much good.  

 

Personally I'm in the camp that the scientists who study the theory of evolution (and all that goes with it) know what they're talking about, and that Genesis is speaking about deeper truths than "God made a human out of literal dust and literally created every single organism as it is today." Whether or not Noah got a pair of every single animal onto an Ark made of gopherwood without all the animals killing each other during a flood that covered the entire globe isn't important to me.  What's important to me is that God made a covenant with Noah, that creation is good but we can royally screw things up.  

 

Plus there are two creation stories in the Bible.  In one, humans are created last.  In the other, humans are created first.  That alone shows me that they aren't meant to be purely historical or scientific accounts.  Genesis doesn't have to be a literal, infallible history book for it to be true. 

Posted

Here is what I think––

 

The earth is millions of years old as scientists say. This can be reconciled with the fact that with God 1 days like 1 million years. So far so good. What about evolution? Remember those spots on Sesame Street with the camera progression? Flowers, plants, and nature unfolding instantaneously? Well, it seems to me that from God's perspective, outside of time, everything happens instantaneously like camera progression. But from our perspective everything unfolds slowly--very slowly. When God created animals, he created them instantaneously--but if we were to see this, it would unfold slowly over time.

 

I think that evolution can be understood and reconciled with our faith in ways such as the above.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...