Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Confiteor Makes Me Upset


Recommended Posts

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Dear fellow human beings,
Confiteor makes me upset. I know I am supposed to say that I'm sorry for my evilness. The thing is, when Gid does something dumb eg not helping me He always gets away with it. I think God should tell me sorry for being rude to me. How do you even nanage to say the Confiteor?

 

 

Well...to be fair to our liturgy, the confiteor is supposed to make us feel a bit upset.  It's a very, very ancient part of our liturgy, and it's a good thing. When we come together at mass, one of the first things we do is own up to all the sins we've committed.  Did you know that when we say the confiteor together at mass, our venial sins are forgiven?  It's part of making sure we're good with God and good with our fellow Catholics before we celebrate the Mass together. In a way we're further strengthening the Body of Christ; so in that sense, it's similar to the Sign of Peace. 

 

One of the hardest things we have to learn is that God does not operate on the same wavelength that we do.  We aren't in charge - God is, and God gets to decide how He's going to answer our prayers. It's part of the whole, "Not my will, but your will be done" thing.  

ithinkjesusiscool
Posted

Well...to be fair to our liturgy, the confiteor is supposed to make us feel a bit upset. 

Well, when I am upset I just want to take the monstrance with the bread in it a throw it on the floor and scream F-you.  I don't think being upset helps us at all.  so what exactly do you mean?

Autumn Dusk
Posted

Well, when I am upset I just want to take the monstrance with the bread in it a throw it on the floor and scream F-you.  I don't think being upset helps us at all.  so what exactly do you mean?

 

I'm not sure if you're just really immature, ignorant or a troll.

 

You seem to display a great amount of anger, much of it displaced on God becuase He wants you to be sorry that you did something wrong.  The confiteor appeals to not only God but everyone else.

 

I confess to almighty God and to you, my brothers and sisters,

 

(so you're speaking to God and to your fellow humans)

that I have greatly sinned in my thoughts and in my words, in what I have done, and in what I have failed to do;

 

(you know, that grumpy looking old guy that you didn't hold the door open for, the person you failed to love, the mean things you said)

through my fault, through my fault, through my most grievous fault;

 

(this is a reparation for the 3 sins of Peter denying Jesus.  3 is considered a "perfect" number.  You are letting it be known that you ask for PERFECT forgiveness)

therefore I ask blessed Mary ever-Virgin, all the Angels and Saints, and you, my brothers and sisters, to pray for me to the Lord our God.

 

I again, see NO issue with this.  We ask eachother for prayer all the time.

 

 

So you're mad at God?  Join the club.  There's loads of people mad at God.  People who have lost homes, or children, people who have suffered from grievous diseases their whole lives.   People who were abandoned or abused.  But guess what?  God didn't cause the bad, He wants to bring us to good.  And many people who have lost everything who were abused or abandoned or are addicted find comfort in God and His mercy.  They help others out of the great conundrum that is sin.

 

We hurt others all the time both purposefully and by accident. Have you ever cut someone off because you were in a hurry?  Have you ever ranted at a sales clerk?  Have you ever forgotten a friend's birthday or decided to buy yourself an expensive dinner when you could of treated your classmate to burgers?  Sin is selfishness.  It is good to seek forgiveness for the little things we do wrong so they don't become big things.  You don't think you ever do anything wrong?  Allllrighty.  

Posted

Any sins that we commit ARE our fault. Not Satan's; he tempts you, but YOU are the one who chooses to do wrong even though you are capable of doing the right thing. Not God's; if He took away our free will, we would be no different than every other animal (apart from the fact that we have  immortal souls). We'd be puppets on strings instead of rational, thinking, freely choosing creatures.

 

If you think the right religion is the one that says that your sins are all God's fault...

 

 

tumblr_mfe56qsiAd1rdjhaeo1_400.gif

 

 

And yes, if you're looking for a religion that says, "No, honey, your sins are okay; we know you tried your best...just forget about them and life will be all sunshine and flowers...it's all that nasty God's fault for giving you free will," Catholicism is NOT for you. Christianity in general is not for you.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I'm still hoping you're being sarcastic. :| 

 

 

All I have to say is....Blimeycow :3

DiscerningCatholic
Posted

:proud:

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Well, when I am upset I just want to take the monstrance with the bread in it a throw it on the floor and scream F-you.  I don't think being upset helps us at all.  so what exactly do you mean?

 

Sorry, thought you were serious. 

 

Finish reading the rest of my post. :)

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Well, when I am upset I just want to take the monstrance with the bread in it a throw it on the floor and scream F-you.  I don't think being upset helps us at all.  so what exactly do you mean?

Do you have any emotional issues, or are you just an angry person?

Posted

I have so many reasons to hate God, but God is not the source of my suffering. You know what is? Either me abusing my free will or others doing the same. After a while of blaming God for everything, I had to face the fact that God isn't the big, bearded man watching us suffer. (God really isn't a man either, but that is a different topic) God loves us so much that he have us this gift of free will. We either embrace the gift, or stomp on it and slap God in the face with it. God doesn't impose sin upon us. God doesn't force feed us love. God doesn't need us. God wants us.

/endrant

Posted

(Oh and because God wants us, he wants what is best for us. The confiteor should make us feel bad because we crucified God. EACH TIME WE SIN WE MURDER GOD. Digest that.)

Posted

Well, when I am upset I just want to take the monstrance with the bread in it a throw it on the floor and scream F-you.  I don't think being upset helps us at all.  so what exactly do you mean?

 


I hope you're not being serious.  Even as a Baptist, when I didn't believe in the Real Presence, the thought of this would be anathema to me.  You have my prayers either way though.

inunionwithrome
Posted

I wish at our parish we would pray it more often. It is a beautiful prayer asking God for forgivness and reminded us that we are a sinful people. Yet, in that very same liturgy, we get to celebrate the Eucharist. What more could you want?

KnightofChrist
Posted

Well, when I am upset I just want to take the monstrance with the bread in it a throw it on the floor and scream F-you. I don't think being upset helps us at all. so what exactly do you mean?


You must take control of your passions, bitter anger is a grave and harmful poison for your heart, both spiritually and biologically. It can be like alcohol to a alcoholic. Only it is a cup that never runs dry, so long as you drink from it. And the more you drink from it the more you give yourself over to the bondage of the devil.
MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Dear fellow human beings,
Confiteor makes me upset. I know I am supposed to say that I'm sorry for my evilness. The thing is, when Gid does something dumb eg not helping me He always gets away with it. I think God should tell me sorry for being rude to me. How do you even nanage to say the Confiteor?

 

hmm try to look at it this way...

 

God created us out of nothing. He created us simply to give us happiness and to love Him, to be with Him. He gave us free will so we can FREELY love Him, and He respects our free will. Instead of being thankful and loving Him, we hurt Him, and hurt others, and our souls too, because every mortal sin results in spiritual death...

 

and still after all this, God becomes a Man (think of His humility here...) and let's His creation kill Him, to save these same people (us) from sin.

 

He didn't stop there but made the Sacraments to give us His Body and Blood, literally, not symbolically present.

 

He also washes away all our sins in Confession. Even if we keep falling and struggling, despite good intentions. Even people who had bad intentions, but then repented later on, He accepts them all if they want to come back. He suffers when souls are lost, when sinners don't want to turn to Him, He longs for us all to be with Him, not just to know Him but to be one with Him, forever...

 

After all this... how can we blame God, for OUR sins? We chose them... we have free will. Rather, we could use our free will to repent of past sins, and try to love God now and always from now on :)

 

God is not the one who insulted us. We insulted Him. We are rude to Him. We nailed Him to the Cross, when He was praying for the Father to forgive, when He loved.

 

Furthermore, God DOES offer us grace to say no to temptation, however do we accept it? do we rely on Him? If we prayed in moments of temptation, we would have more strenght to say no... the reason we sin is because WE choose to. It's actually completely our fault, because we can say no, and earn merit by saying no to sin. We have free will. God understands our weakness... He forgives weakness. It's sin that's intended, - that's more serious. We need to confess all our mortal sins, that is sins that we did wilfully and knowingly, that are against the Commandments.

 

Hope this helps you my friend :) God bless.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

people always say it's my fault. It's never God's fault. Maybe Catholicism isn't really my religion :cry:

 

I only drink tea. :cool:

 

A dictator always want it his way....but if God is no dictator then this sounds a bit strange....ok look, yes I am very angry with God. Me and John Lennon are the angry ones...

 

How can God be a "dictator" when He's trying to save us from an eternity of spiritual death? If a child wants to jump off a bridge and his father is trying to stop him, and the child is screaming "dictator!!!! let me jump off the bridge!!!" - this is like that...

Well, when I am upset I just want to take the monstrance with the bread in it a throw it on the floor and scream F-you.  I don't think being upset helps us at all.  so what exactly do you mean?

 

:( Why would you want to hurt Jesus, because you are upset? Why would you say that to someone who loves you more than His life?

Posted

When God does something dumb to me I'm like, "It's cool bro... I don't want no trouble. You're awesome. I'm lame."

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...