Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

A documentary on one of the most controverial figures in modern Catholic history.

 

 

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=nSY4FqZBVZU[/media]

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I am looking forward to watching this when it comes out.

eagle_eye222001
Posted

Looks really interesting.

Posted

I agree it looks very interesting. What's noteworthy is that Archbishop Lefebvres work in African seemed to serve as a protective incubation period. In those times it took weeks to get to Africa by boat and so he was very isolated from the "goings on" of the modern world. He commented that when he returned to Europe for the Second Vatican Council he noted significant changes in thought among his fellow bishops, it was as if a new spirit had swept through the Western world that Lefebvre had been impervious to.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I agree it looks very interesting. What's noteworthy is that Archbishop Lefebvres work in African seemed to serve as a protective incubation period. In those times it took weeks to get to Africa by boat and so he was very isolated from the "goings on" of the modern world. He commented that when he returned to Europe for the Second Vatican Council he noted significant changes in thought among his fellow bishops, it was as if a new spirit had swept through the Western world that Lefebvre had been impervious to.

It is true, the world changed while he was in Dakar. For a while he was very much in favour with Pius XII, but things changed rather quickly when John XXIII came into power, causing him to give up his role as Apostolic Delegate to French Africa.

He was quite close to Pope Pius XII. For some reason, not quite so much with John XXIII.

Posted

It is true, the world changed while he was in Dakar. For a while he was very much in favour with Pius XII, but things changed rather quickly when John XXIII came into power, causing him to give up his role as Apostolic Delegate to French Africa.

He was quite close to Pope Pius XII. For some reason, not quite so much with John XXIII.

 

That is interesting Nihil, a lot of history to be read into

Nihil Obstat
Posted

That is interesting Nihil, a lot of history to be read into

Have you read his biography, written by Bishop Tissier de Mallerais? Excellent book. I loved every page of it. Obviously you would not expect it to be 'perfectly objective', but it is an extremely valuable perspective, and contains a lot of information you will not find anywhere else. I would highly recommend it to anybody with any interest whatsoever in the subject.

Posted

Have you read his biography, written by Bishop Tissier de Mallerais? Excellent book. I loved every page of it. Obviously you would not expect it to be 'perfectly objective', but it is an extremely valuable perspective, and contains a lot of information you will not find anywhere else. I would highly recommend it to anybody with any interest whatsoever in the subject.

 

No I have not, my "to-read" list is very long but this is an area I'd really like to delve into. I did listen to his Econe sermon on youtube years ago, his "state of emergency" argument was very thought provoking. Ultimately the changes we have seen are still in their infancy relative to history, time will tell the truth of these matters.

Posted (edited)

Are there going to be any computer generated special effects in this movie? It will not make a lot of money if it does not contain a lot of cgi.

 

:bounce:

Edited by Apotheoun
Nihil Obstat
Posted

No I have not, my "to-read" list is very long but this is an area I'd really like to delve into. I did listen to his Econe sermon on youtube years ago, his "state of emergency" argument was very thought provoking. Ultimately the changes we have seen are still in their infancy relative to history, time will tell the truth of these matters.

A lot of aspects of his life and mission kind of get lost in the shuffle. There is this caricature of him that exists in popular sources, which really does not always correspond to the real man. The real Archbishop was much more than that.

Posted

Are there going to be any computer generated special effects in this movie? It will not make a lot of money if it does not contain a lot of cgi.

 

:bounce:

Or they could try casting Lefebvre as some sort of Kung Fu master, and have him roundhouse kick Pope John XXIII.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Or they could try casting Lefebvre as some sort of Kung Fu master, and have him roundhouse kick Pope John XXIII.

Pope Paul would make more sense.

Posted

Pope Paul would make more sense.

Roundhouse kick both of them.  At once.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Roundhouse kick both of them.  At once.

I guess historical accuracy can take a backseat. Artistic license and whatnot. Have to get the kids interested somehow.

Posted

I guess historical accuracy can take a backseat. Artistic license and whatnot. Have to get the kids interested somehow.

Who needs "historical accuracy" when you could be a...

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oRl9ezYFwD0

Posted

:pinch:

Nice avatar. Glad to see you came around  :like2: 

Posted

Papist,

I was never against the Pope, just some concerns over the liturgy :)

Posted

Btw, in light of my other thread being closed im surprised this one wasnt!

Evangetholic
Posted

Will this be in English? I'm curious, because I think the Society is more strident in French than English. I'm not good enough with either language to be more specific.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...