Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Bible Shopping Is A Pain....


Recommended Posts

Kayte Postle
Posted

So I've been on the hunt for a new bible recently since my other 3 (yes that's right 3) paperback NAB's are in really rough shape. I'm having trouble finding something I like. I would preferably like to purchase a NAB/NABRE, leather/simulated leather/similar binding, a reasonably sized font ( 9+), and thicker (not the thin see-through) pages because I like to highlight verses and write in notes/thoughts.

 

Here's my problem, the two stores in my area don't have ones that match up with what I'm looking for, and I'm hesitant to buy something online without being able to see how thick the pages are. 

 

I did find this one, which looks awesome, but I don't want to purchase without knowing the page thickness. Does anyone own this bible?

 

If you PM researchers could help me out that would be avvesome! Thanks!

Beati Pacifici
Posted

Does your parish ever do book sales?

Kayte Postle
Posted

Does your parish ever do book sales?

 


Unfortunately no. :cry:

Beati Pacifici
Posted (edited)

Oh drats! :( Our parish does one every year and all the bibles are free. If you don't have one by then (usually May), I'll check and see what I can do :)

 

May not be anything fancy though.

Edited by Beati Pacifici
Brother Adam
Posted

So I've been on the hunt for a new bible recently since my other 3 (yes that's right 3) paperback NAB's are in really rough shape. I'm having trouble finding something I like. I would preferably like to purchase a NAB/NABRE, leather/simulated leather/similar binding, a reasonably sized font ( 9+), and thicker (not the thin see-through) pages because I like to highlight verses and write in notes/thoughts.

 

Here's my problem, the two stores in my area don't have ones that match up with what I'm looking for, and I'm hesitant to buy something online without being able to see how thick the pages are. 

 

I did find this one, which looks amesome, but I don't want to purchase without knowing the page thickness. Does anyone own this bible?

 

If you PM researchers could help me out that would be avvesome! Thanks!

 


The Fireside leatherette Bible would probably fit your needs. Actually the one I have is pretty much new and I don't have use for it anymore. I would be willing to arrange sending it to you.

 

http://www.amazon.com/Fireside-Study-Edition-Burgundy-Nab/dp/1556654200/ref=sr_1_4?ie=UTF8&qid=1363580159&sr=8-4&keywords=fireside+nab+bible

Brother Adam
Posted

Except that she is looking for an NAB. The leather Ignatius has pretty thick pages and room to take notes in the margins though.

Kayte Postle
Posted

Except that she is looking for an NAB. The leather Ignatius has pretty thick pages and room to take notes in the margins though.

 

Quick question then, what is the difference between the NAB and Ignatius? I've only ever used a NAB, and found it easy to read/understand. I would be open to looking into a different translation though.
 

Kayte Postle
Posted (edited)

double post. gr

 

Edited by Kayte Postle
PhuturePriest
Posted

Douay-Rheims or Knox Bible. Don't go for anything with the word "New" on it. The "New" Jerusalem Bible, for instance, is an absolute disgrace. The Jerusalem Bible, however, is not.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

Quick question then, what is the difference between the NAB and Ignatius? I've only ever used a NAB, and found it easy to read/understand. I would be open to looking into a different translation though.
 

 

The NAB is more free with wording (And thus in more danger to misunderstandings, taking away incredibly important wording for the sake of readability) and the Ignatius Bible is readable, but more exact in its translating.

Edited by FuturePriest387
GeorgiiMichael
Posted

The New American Bible: Revised Edition is the official translation of the American Church and is what you hear at Mass on Sunday, so you can go ahead and ignore FP.

PhuturePriest
Posted

The New American Bible: Revised Edition is the official translation of the American Church and is what you hear at Mass on Sunday, so you can go ahead and ignore FP.

 

That doesn't make it free of errors. Many Biblical scholars take great offense at some of the important wording it throws out the window in the name of "readability". Perhaps I'm incredibly smart, but I read the Douay-Rheims and find it easier to understand than the NAB.

Posted

FYI the Douay-Rheims is a translation of a translation. Although for general reading I do enjoy it, and the Latin Vulgate that it was translated from was declared to be without error by one of the St. Pope's but I don't recall which one (a Pius?).

 

The RSV-CE is what my biblical studies professors required (both Dr. Hahn and Dr. Bergsma).

 

The NAB, regardless of if it is the "American Standard" or not, is not an excellent translation. Obviously it isn't littered with heretical interpretations, but it still isn't the bees knees.

eagle_eye222001
Posted

Ignatius. Always recommend Ignatius. Yes, thin pages, but I highlight the croutons out of it. Best bible I have ever owned.

 

 

http://www.catholiccompany.com/ignatius-bible-rsv-second-catholic-edition-p1011249/?sku=1011249&AID=178&utm_source=google&utm_medium=products&utm_campaign=The+Ignatius+Bible+-+RSV+Second+Catholic+Edition&gclid=CM7v_e21hbYCFVCRPAod4XQAVQ

 

BEST BIBLE EVER! :woot:  Although it's only the NT....but they are coming out with OT someday! :drool:

 

Quick question then, what is the difference between the NAB and Ignatius? I've only ever used a NAB, and found it easy to read/understand. I would be open to looking into a different translation though.
 

 

NAB is easy to read and is great for getting the jist of a story....but that's about it.  The RSV-CE offers easy to read translation with much better word translation and footnotes that completely outclass the NAB in every aspect.

 

The New American Bible: Revised Edition is the official translation of the American Church and is what you hear at Mass on Sunday, so you can go ahead and ignore FP.

 

I've found some of the footnotes to be borderline heretical.....and they weren't corrected in the RE.  When the footnotes tell you St. Paul isn't talking about purgatory.....but he is........  :mad3:  .  Seriously, the NAB footnotes water Catholic doctrine down to the max while offering a very shoddy translation.

 

Yes it is the official translation.......it still  :cuss: ..

 

Google "NAB translation problems" and you'll get a good idea of what I mean.

GeorgiiMichael
Posted

It's still a legitimate translation, not only that but it's the translation that our bishops use, and if that's what Kayte Postle is looking for, then help her find a good copy. 

 

Goodness gracious.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

It's still a legitimate translation, not only that but it's the translation that our bishops use, and if that's what Kayte Postle is looking for, then help her find a good copy. 

 

Goodness gracious.

 

It's the one we use because the USCCB decided on it years ago. Many things have changed since then, and I honestly wish they would switch it to the RSV or something. The NAB has terrible problems in it. For instance, my favorite verse is Acts 20:28. Here is that verse from the NAB with the key words being in bold:

 

Keep watch over yourselves and over the whole flock of which the holy Spirit has appointed you overseers,* in which you tend the church of God that he acquired with his own blood.

 

Seems reasonable, right? Well, here's that verse in the Douay-Rheims:

 

Take heed to yourselves, and to the whole flock, wherein the Holy Ghost hath placed you bishops, to rule the church of God, which he hath purchased with his own blood.

 

See the incredible importance of those words which are terribly watered down in the NAB? There is a very fine line between "tending" something and "ruling" something. Just the same, there is a fine line between an "overseer" and clearly stating that it is referring to bishops. It's clear and to the point. This verse from the Douay-Rheims distills the argument Protestants have that there is no established hierarchy in the Bible that has any significance other than leading in prayer. In the NAB, it makes no clear point of what it is talking about.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Kayte Postle
Posted (edited)

Oh my heavens, I certainly didn't intend to start a translation debate......... :blush:

 

Well I've been looking at the Ignatius over the past 2ish hours, and I think it'd be a solid choice. The leather bound has all the other options I'm looking for, the translation seems to have a lot of merit to it, and from many of the reviews (and at y'all suggestion), it seems like it would be readable for me. Also I'd still have my trusty worn out NAB's to reference along side it, just in case.

Edited by Kayte Postle
GeorgiiMichael
Posted

It's the one we use because the USCCB decided on it years ago. Many things have changed since then, and I honestly wish they would switch it to the RSV or something. The NAB has terrible problems in it. For instance, my favorite verse is Acts 20:28. Here is that verse from the NAB with the key words being in bold:

 

Keep watch over yourselves and over the whole flock of which the holy Spirit has appointed you overseers,* in which you tend the church of God that he acquired with his own blood.

 

Seems reasonable, right? Well, here's that verse in the Douay-Rheims:

 

Take heed to yourselves, and to the whole flock, wherein the Holy Ghost hath placed you bishops, to rule the church of God, which he hath purchased with his own blood.

 

See the incredible importance of those words which are terribly watered down in the NAB? There is a very fine line between "tending" something and "ruling" something. Just the same, there is a fine line between an "overseer" and clearly stating that it is referring to bishops. It's clear and to the point. This verse from the Douay-Rheims distills the argument Protestants have that there is no established hierarchy in the Bible that has any significance other than leading in prayer. In the NAB, it makes no clear point of what it is talking about.

 

This isn't the best verse to argue your point.

 

Overseer is a term that is unquestionable in it's authority. Overseers, in every other context, aren't questioned by their underlings, and there's no reason why the biblical context would change that. Also, overseer is a more literal translation from the Greek, so, it sounds to me like bishop is more watered down than overseer.

 

Also, in the context of a flock (which, duh, is the context) to tend and to rule means LITERALLY THE SAME THING.

 

So, try harder.

Posted (edited)

Actually the word "bishop" is a transliteration of the Greek á¼Ï€Î¹ÏƒÎºÏŒÏ€Î¿Ï…Ï‚ through the Old Saxon language into English, and it has the added benefit of being the traditional English word used in both the Catholic and Orthodox Churches to indicate the office mentioned in Acts 20:28. That said, when I teach high school classes that reference the text in question I end up having to explain the origin of the word used in the Greek New Testament in order to make clear to the students that the office of bishop is being referenced. Needless to say, a proper translation of the Greek word with the traditional English equivalent would negate the necessity of having to explain to the students that a bishop is an overseer in the Church. Alas many of my students often ask, "Why didn't the text just use the world bishop in the first place?" My normal response to that question is that there are people in the Catholic Church who - for some reason - like to obscure the connection between the Catholic tradition (e.g., concerning Holy Orders) and sacred scripture. 

Edited by Apotheoun

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...