Not The Philosopher Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 So - some family friends have invited my household to a Passover seder on Saturday (which is...not when Passover falls this year, but I guess they're trying to avoid doing it on a weekday). They're Jewish, my dad's Jewish, I'm (obviously?) a Catholic. Random answers on the internet range from "sure go for it", to "it's a mortal sin even if you do it understanding that the old law has been retired", but I can't seem to find anything official on it.
Nihil Obstat Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 In ny opinion, prudence and the first commandment discourage attendance.
IcePrincessKRS Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 In ny opinion, prudence and the first commandment discourage attendance. New York is very opinionated.
Tony Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 "it's a mortal sin even if you do it understanding that the old law has been retired".. isn't that self-contradictary?
Lilllabettt Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 if they know you are Catholic they probably have a good grasp of where you stand on the Jesus thing.
Apotheoun Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 "it's a mortal sin even if you do it understanding that the old law has been retired".. isn't that self-contradictary? The statement is not really self-contradictory; instead, it is just poorly worded.
morostheos Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 My Catholic parish used to hold a seder meal, so I always thought it was ok. It's a celebration of heritage. On the other hand, I'm sure there were many other iffy practices my parish used to do. :idontknow:
Apotheoun Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 My Catholic parish used to hold a seder meal, so I always thought it was ok. It's a celebration of heritage. On the other hand, I'm sure there were many other iffy practices my parish used to do. :idontknow: A Catholic parish should not celebrate the seder meal, because that involves the Church herself returning to the shadows of the Old Testament. The seder has been fulfilled and completed in the Eucharist.
Apotheoun Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 So - some family friends have invited my household to a Passover seder on Saturday (which is...not when Passover falls this year, but I guess they're trying to avoid doing it on a weekday). They're Jewish, my dad's Jewish, I'm (obviously?) a Catholic. Random answers on the internet range from "sure go for it", to "it's a mortal sin even if you do it understanding that the old law has been retired", but I can't seem to find anything official on it. As long as you don't do anything that compromises your Catholic faith, and are just attending as a guest, I don't really see a problem with going. Perhaps you should speak to your parish priest and get his advice on the matter.
KnightofChrist Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 Hmm? You spelt "my" wrong and apparently you may be very opinionated. Anyway doesn't matter.
Anastasia13 Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 (edited) Be careful about praying there with Jews. Their faith is different, and if you go, you need to be careful to respect that. Most of what they say will be not in contradiction to your faith, but how they explain what they say too might be different. I would go and enjoy it, but be careful to remember that. BTW, Dayenu was actually not such a worshipful song, but rather a we had a burden and you gave us more and that would have been enough, but you gave us more kind of song, at least the way it was explained to me by a Messianic. I would be careful about joining that song just because I don't feel it is the most respectful way to sing to God. This is a popular Passover song. Edited March 20, 2013 by Light and Truth
IcePrincessKRS Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 You spelt "my" wrong and apparently you may be very opinionated. Anyway doesn't matter. Hmm? It was a joke. I'm sorry you guys are slow on the uptake.
KnightofChrist Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 It was a joke. I'm sorry you guys are slow on the uptake. Durrrr
Nihil Obstat Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 Oh, I see. I am on my phone. It does funny things.
cmotherofpirl Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 I think Seders for non-Jews are generally a bad idea. For them, it is required yearly ritual correct? For us its just an experiment, and doesn't hold the same religious meaning. How would we feel if they decided to hold a pretend Mass as a learning experience?
Evangetholic Posted March 20, 2013 Posted March 20, 2013 So - some family friends have invited my household to a Passover seder on Saturday (which is...not when Passover falls this year, but I guess they're trying to avoid doing it on a weekday). They're Jewish, my dad's Jewish, I'm (obviously?) a Catholic. Random answers on the internet range from "sure go for it", to "it's a mortal sin even if you do it understanding that the old law has been retired", but I can't seem to find anything official on it. I'm a quarter Jewish (my mother's father). I feel Jewish (ethnically). I do not participate in non-Catholic religious rituals (weddings and funerals excepted)--especially non-Christian ones.
Not The Philosopher Posted March 20, 2013 Author Posted March 20, 2013 Welp, I'm leaning more toward not going right now. Partly because I'll be working a long shift that starts first thing in the morning, and don't want to sleepwalk through Palm Sunday. But I just don't feel too comfortable with the idea - even though the seder still has some nostalgic value for me (my family did it when I was growing up, although my family was secular in pretty much every other respect).
LadyOfSorrows Posted March 21, 2013 Posted March 21, 2013 Being a convert from Judaism, I see it as a learning experience. I will still go to one if invited, and I have seen them very much enrich the faith of other Catholic Christians. It doesn't contradict the faith at all. :) I'll actually be having my own seder.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now