Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

No idea what the above quote means but sounds like what I alluded to... becoming Catholic is not necessary...or am I missing something?

Posted

Some Anglican ecumenical dialogue led to the restoration of the Anglicans in the Church.

The basic idea behind ecumenism is that the state of Christianity today is not what Christ intended and is wrong. We bear responsibility for it if we do nothing to repair it, so ecumenism is one part of that.

I apologize for this sentence. I just reread what I've written. I should not write "it...it...that."

Posted

No idea what the above quote means but sounds like what I alluded to... becoming Catholic is not necessary...or am I missing something?

Melkites are perfectly acceptable Catholics.

 

I might be misreading Apo, but I think that was part of his point.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted (edited)

No idea what the above quote means but sounds like what I alluded to... becoming Catholic is not necessary...or am I missing something?

I believe he was referring to the diverse theological and liturgical expression of the Eastern Churches in communion with Rome, as well as the Anglican Ordinariate. Unity need not mean uniformity.

Edited by thedude
Posted

Cardinal Kasper, the former prefect for the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, said the following:

 

"In its ecumenical approach, Vatican II took a standpoint centered on Christ. This was a new and decisive step. Until then the standpoint was centered on the Church. The accepted view was that ecumenism meant a 'return' to the Catholic Church. The formula was: 'The Catholic Church is the true Church of Jesus Christ, therefore unity is only possible if the others return to the Roman Catholic Church.' But Vatican II gave up this view."

Posted

I believe he was referring to the diverse theological and liturgical expression of the Eastern Churches in communion with Rome, as well as the Anglican Ordinariate. Unity need not mean uniformity.

Yes, there is already a diversity of views among the Catholic Churches in particular when looking at the Eastern Catholic Churches, and to a lesser extent the Anglican Ordinariate, and this diversity according to Pope Benedict and Cardinal Kasper is good and should grow.

Posted

Melkites are perfectly acceptable Catholics.

Agreed.

 

I think that Pope Benedict is speaking about unity in diversity not only as it is presently lived, but as it could exist with the reestablishment of communion between the Roman and Eastern Catholic Churches and the Eastern Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox Churches. He may also mean to include the Protestant ecclesial communities, but the comment quoted in my earlier post does not make that completely clear.

Posted

Did Christ pray for unity? 

Posted

Cardinal Levada, the former prefect for the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, said the following:

 

"Visible union with the Catholic Church does not mean absorption into a monolith, with the absorbed body being lost in the greater whole, the way a teaspoon of sugar would be lost if dissolved in a gallon of coffee."

 

 

Source: Vatican

Posted

Agreed.

 

I think that Pope Benedict is speaking about unity in diversity not only as it is presently lived, but as it could exist with the reestablishment of communion between the Roman and Eastern Catholic Churches and the Eastern Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox Churches. He may also mean to include the Protestant ecclesial communities, but the comment quoted in my earlier post does not make that completely clear.

 

Yes, this is what I was referring to. I'm not sure who the Holy Father was referring to and what he meant by "faith history." If it's to the Orthodox that's one thing but if it's to Protestants and even Jews and Muslims, then I'm totally lost. Also there was mention of not seeking uniformity in theological matters although I thought this was the one area where uniformity was actually sought?

 

Sigh, why is everything so ambiguous these days? :unsure:

Posted

Cardinal Kasper, the former prefect for the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, said the following:

 

"In its ecumenical approach, Vatican II took a standpoint centered on Christ. This was a new and decisive step. Until then the standpoint was centered on the Church. The accepted view was that ecumenism meant a 'return' to the Catholic Church. The formula was: 'The Catholic Church is the true Church of Jesus Christ, therefore unity is only possible if the others return to the Roman Catholic Church.' But Vatican II gave up this view."

 

I guess I must be holding on to an antiquated doctrine :)   Who does not have the Church as mother does not have God as Father, as the old saying goes! But I'm curious Apo, how do our Eastern brothers view these things? Do they agree its about centering not on the Church but on Christ? Do they invision "unity" the way some contemporary Catholics do?

Posted

I guess I must be holding on to an antiquated doctrine :)   Who does not have the Church as mother does not have God as Father, as the old saying goes! But I'm curious Apo, how do our Eastern brothers view these things? Do they agree its about centering not on the Church but on Christ? Do they invision "unity" the way some contemporary Catholics do?

Large numbers of Eastern Catholics (especially hierarchs) would agree with the quotations I have provided. Eastern Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox would probably be completely indifferent to the quotations.

Posted

Yes, this is what I was referring to. I'm not sure who the Holy Father was referring to and what he meant by "faith history." If it's to the Orthodox that's one thing but if it's to Protestants and even Jews and Muslims, then I'm totally lost. Also there was mention of not seeking uniformity in theological matters although I thought this was the one area where uniformity was actually sought?

 

Sigh, why is everything so ambiguous these days? :unsure:

From the context of the speech I think Pope Benedict is referring to Christians in general.

Anastasia13
Posted

What is meant by "faith history" in that context?

Posted

What is meant by "faith history" in that context?

It appears to me that the pope - at least based upon the context of his speech - is talking about the history of the separated communities. In other words, Pope Benedict does not see the restoration of communion as a form of absorption of one community by another community.

Anastasia13
Posted

It appears to me that the pope - at least based upon the context of his speech - is talking about the history of the separated communities. In other words, Pope Benedict does not see the restoration of communion as a form of absorption of one community by another community.

 


Baptist Rite Catholics???

Posted


Baptist Rite Catholics???

It's hard to say how this type of unity would be applied. I refuse to speculate!  :smile3:

Anastasia13
Posted

It's hard to say how this type of unity would be applied. I refuse to speculate!  :smile3:

 


Would such a hypothetical thing still be a Mass and why or why not? What would make it or break it as a Mass?

Posted

I really do not know what the pope means exactly, and I do not know what limits he would place upon the application of this theory.

Anastasia13
Posted

I really do not know what the pope means exactly, and I do not know what limits he would place upon the application of this theory.

 


Yeah, but seriously, what makes a Mass a Mass? I mean there are different liturgies/rites, Tridentine, Latin,  whatever, but what in them makes them all Mass?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...