dUSt Posted March 22, 2013 Posted March 22, 2013 I still do not see some immoral issues with homosexuals in Boy Scouts or being on TV for dancing with the stars. I believe it is immoral for active homosexuals to be in the Boy Scouts. That would be a position of teaching and leadership. Condoning homosexual behavior in one's private life is a sin that affects themselves, but when one condone's homosexual behavior in their public life--especially to children--that is sinning against others, and is definitely immoral. Even more immoral ihmo because you are putting other people's souls in danger, and not just your own.
Winchester Posted March 22, 2013 Posted March 22, 2013 It's perfectly legitimate to not admit people to your private club for whatever reason.
Socrates Posted March 22, 2013 Posted March 22, 2013 While the Catholic church is opposed to homosexual marriage, I dont think we should lose sight of the fact that homosexuals are STILL people who deserve love and respect. I do not know how any of the things you are upset about the bishop supporting are in any way bad other than the fact the public display may lead people to think he also suppose homosexual marriage. But even if that IS the case, I still do not see some immoral issues with homosexuals in Boy Scouts or being on TV for dancing with the stars. One of the parts of the Boy Scout oath is to keep oneself "morally straight." Cultivating morality in boys has always been one of the stated goals of the Scouts, and for this reason, practicing homosexuals have been banned from being scoutmasters, as scoutmasters are supposed to be models of male morality to the boys. There is no reason Catholics should oppose such standards of morality in private organizations. And, while I think "Dancing with the Stars" is itself pretty gay, having homosexual couples dancing on the air would be yet another example of promoting public acceptance of an immoral lifestyle as a positive, normal thing. You can argue that this particular issue is pretty trivial, given the already widespread promotion of homosexuality and other sexual immorality in our culture, but Catholics (especially Catholic clergy) should oppose the widespread immorality in our culture, not actively support it. Please read the relevant Vatican document cited by Apotheoun on this thread. A priest should definitely not be publicly lobbying to support acceptance of immorality of any kind. If what St. Michael reports is correct, this priest is absolutely wrong to support all of the things listed, and is committing a sin of grave scandal, and acting contrary to his duties as a priest of Christ. (Unfortunately, I have no reason to doubt him given what I've heard about the deplorable state of the Church in California - this is in Mahoney's ex-diocese after all.) St. Michael, you should contact the bishop about this problem, and pray, hard.
CrossCuT Posted March 24, 2013 Posted March 24, 2013 Well... if it is a practicing gay (they don't question you "are you a homosexual?" on the registration form), then I can see all sorts of concerns in that I don't really want someone who is openly and actively attracted to other boys taking showers with my son or sleeping in the same tent as him. It would be the same concern I would have if a group outing included both boys and girls - I wouldn't want co-ed showers or girls and boys sleeping in the same tent. Are you implying that no homosexual have self control? Girls and boys are put together in tons of youth camps and there isnt rampant sexual exchange happening...least not that I am aware of. I understand your concern but I wouldnt phrase it in a way that condemns a person of a crime they havent committed yet. I also think it is wrong to assume homosexuals have the intentions of doing immoral things to other young children, that is a terrible and sick thing to think. I believe it is immoral for active homosexuals to be in the Boy Scouts. That would be a position of teaching and leadership. Condoning homosexual behavior in one's private life is a sin that affects themselves, but when one condone's homosexual behavior in their public life--especially to children--that is sinning against others, and is definitely immoral. Even more immoral ihmo because you are putting other people's souls in danger, and not just your own. If I am not mistaken (please correct me if I am wrong) it is not immoral to have homosexual attractions it is only immoral to act on them. Would it be permissible to allow a homosexual who resists their desires into Boy Scouts? But I understand the point. Would there be a way for a homosexual to participate in Boy Scouts if they signed something saying they wouldnt to speak of it to the others? One of the parts of the Boy Scout oath is to keep oneself "morally straight." Cultivating morality in boys has always been one of the stated goals of the Scouts, and for this reason, practicing homosexuals have been banned from being scoutmasters, as scoutmasters are supposed to be models of male morality to the boys. There is no reason Catholics should oppose such standards of morality in private organizations. And, while I think "Dancing with the Stars" is itself pretty gay, having homosexual couples dancing on the air would be yet another example of promoting public acceptance of an immoral lifestyle as a positive, normal thing. You can argue that this particular issue is pretty trivial, given the already widespread promotion of homosexuality and other sexual immorality in our culture, but Catholics (especially Catholic clergy) should oppose the widespread immorality in our culture, not actively support it. Please read the relevant Vatican document cited by Apotheoun on this thread. A priest should definitely not be publicly lobbying to support acceptance of immorality of any kind. If what St. Michael reports is correct, this priest is absolutely wrong to support all of the things listed, and is committing a sin of grave scandal, and acting contrary to his duties as a priest of Christ. (Unfortunately, I have no reason to doubt him given what I've heard about the deplorable state of the Church in California - this is in Mahoney's ex-diocese after all.) St. Michael, you should contact the bishop about this problem, and pray, hard. I am 100% in agreement that the priest should NOT condone homosexual activity publicly or privately, but I do believe homosexuals deserve love and dignity like anyone else. And I am very happy to hear about the boy scouts oath! I honestly didnt know that before and I think its awesome!!!! I will have to buy more stuff from them like their yummy popcorn!!! But anyways, all Im trying to say is that it is possible to have a homosexual who doesnt bring immoral doom on all around them and I think we ought to be there to support, pray for, and love them like anyone else! While it is important to resist any moral downfall associated with homosexual activity I also think that we ought to love the people! Separate the act from the person.
StMichael Posted March 24, 2013 Author Posted March 24, 2013 (edited) It is apparent you are an advocate for homosexuals, but I would very much appreciate if you didn't high jack my thread, which was not started to debate what the Bible already states is a grave sin. Please feel free to start another thread. Thank you. Are you implying that no homosexual have self control? Girls and boys are put together in tons of youth camps and there isnt rampant sexual exchange happening...least not that I am aware of. I understand your concern but I wouldnt phrase it in a way that condemns a person of a crime they havent committed yet. I also think it is wrong to assume homosexuals have the intentions of doing immoral things to other young children, that is a terrible and sick thing to think. If I am not mistaken (please correct me if I am wrong) it is not immoral to have homosexual attractions it is only immoral to act on them. Would it be permissible to allow a homosexual who resists their desires into Boy Scouts? But I understand the point. Would there be a way for a homosexual to participate in Boy Scouts if they signed something saying they wouldnt to speak of it to the others? I am 100% in agreement that the priest should NOT condone homosexual activity publicly or privately, but I do believe homosexuals deserve love and dignity like anyone else. And I am very happy to hear about the boy scouts oath! I honestly didnt know that before and I think its amesome!!!! I will have to buy more stuff from them like their yummy popcorn!!! But anyways, all Im trying to say is that it is possible to have a homosexual who doesnt bring immoral doom on all around them and I think we ought to be there to support, pray for, and love them like anyone else! While it is important to resist any moral downfall associated with homosexual activity I also think that we ought to love the people! Separate the act from the person. Edited March 24, 2013 by StMichael
Nihil Obstat Posted March 24, 2013 Posted March 24, 2013 It is apparent you are an advocate for homosexuals, Subtlety is not really your thing, is it? :rolleyes:
StMichael Posted March 24, 2013 Author Posted March 24, 2013 Nihil, what's that? Have a Happy Palm Sunday. Subtlety is not really your thing, is it? :rolleyes:
Nihil Obstat Posted March 24, 2013 Posted March 24, 2013 (edited) Nihil, what's that? Have a Happy Palm Sunday. Here you go. And a blessed Palm Sunday to you as well. Edited March 24, 2013 by Nihil Obstat
Socrates Posted March 24, 2013 Posted March 24, 2013 (edited) f I am not mistaken (please correct me if I am wrong) it is not immoral to have homosexual attractions it is only immoral to act on them. Would it be permissible to allow a homosexual who resists their desires into Boy Scouts? But I understand the point. Would there be a way for a homosexual to participate in Boy Scouts if they signed something saying they wouldnt to speak of it to the others? I am 100% in agreement that the priest should NOT condone homosexual activity publicly or privately, but I do believe homosexuals deserve love and dignity like anyone else. And I am very happy to hear about the boy scouts oath! I honestly didnt know that before and I think its amesome!!!! I will have to buy more stuff from them like their yummy popcorn!!! But anyways, all Im trying to say is that it is possible to have a homosexual who doesnt bring immoral doom on all around them and I think we ought to be there to support, pray for, and love them like anyone else! While it is important to resist any moral downfall associated with homosexual activity I also think that we ought to love the people! Separate the act from the person. I don't think giving people love and dignity was really the issue here. There is no intrinsic right to be a scoutmaster or dance with a same-sex partner on DWTS that everybody is entitled to. The fact that this priest is also petitioning for homosexual "marriage" and in support of PP shows that he has serious issues and is opposed to Church moral teaching. As for the Boy Scouts, I don't know exactly how the process works, but I am sure the issue is with men who are publicly open homosexuals, not people with private desires that are not acted on. The position of scoutmaster would fall under the category listed in the Church document that was cited earlier: "There are areas in which it is not unjust discrimination to take sexual orientation into account, for example, in the placement of children for adoption or foster care, in employment of teachers or athletic coaches, and in military recruitment." That priest needs to either drop the "social left" activism, or else leave the active priestly ministry. Let's pray his bishop straightens him out. Edited March 24, 2013 by Socrates
CrossCuT Posted March 25, 2013 Posted March 25, 2013 It is apparent you are an advocate for homosexuals, but I would very much appreciate if you didn't high jack my thread, which was not started to debate what the Bible already states is a grave sin. Please feel free to start another thread. Thank you. Apparent? Did you read my posts? :hehe2: But anyway, to clarify, I do not support or condone the homosexual act in any sense and I did not feel that I was hijacking your thread. I apologize if my comments have upset you and I promise that my intentions were simply to participate in the forum topic.
StMichael Posted March 25, 2013 Author Posted March 25, 2013 (edited) The sole reason for this thread was not to debate whether grave sins should be promoted, accepted, etc. Its primary purpose was to inquire as what to do regarding a shepherd who might or might not be adhering to Church Doctrine. This has been a very painful time dealing with this and thankfully the Archdiocese was quick to respond to me. Apparent? Did you read my posts? :hehe2: But anyway, to clarify, I do not support or condone the homosexual act in any sense and I did not feel that I was hijacking your thread. I apologize if my comments have upset you and I promise that my intentions were simply to participate in the forum topic. Edited March 25, 2013 by StMichael
CrossCuT Posted March 25, 2013 Posted March 25, 2013 The sole reason for this thread was not to debate whether grave sins should be promoted, accepted, etc. Its primary purpose was to inquire as what to do regarding a shepherd who might or might not be adhering to Church Doctrine. This has been a very painful time dealing with this and thankfully the Archdiocese was quick to respond to me. Who is promoting it??
CatholicCid Posted March 25, 2013 Posted March 25, 2013 (edited) Who is promoting it?? I think it is a linguistic issue. The use of "homosexual" in the phorums would, I believe, be taken to mean not only someone struggling with same-sex attraction (SSA), but someone who has identified, embraced, and supports such a lifestyle. Therefore, homosexual = a person actively living out this life style contrary to the understanding of the Church. The phorum would instead use the phrase "person struggling with SSA." This indicates that the person is not actively living out of pursing a homosexual lifestyle. Instead, they are living chastely (hence, struggling) in accord with the teachings of the Church. Therefore, such a statement as "A homosexual should be allowed to be a Boy Scout Leader", that is translated as "A person who is an active homosexual should be allowed to be a Boy Scout Leader." This, of course, goes against the code of the Boy Scouts to keep oneself morally straight as such a person is not only deviating from the moral path, but is willingly doing so. Now, if you asked if a person who is struggling with SSA should be allowed to be a Boy Scout Leader, there might be a livelier discussion. Though the matter of prudence can be discussed, it cannot be doubt that such a person is attempting to keep himself morally straight. Edited March 25, 2013 by CatholicCid
CrossCuT Posted March 25, 2013 Posted March 25, 2013 That is very well! I should be using that instead! Im sorry that I lead people to assume the worst of me :) But yes, if you can just insert that for everything Ive been saying maybe that makes more sense. Someone who is an active, proud, homosexual bent on converting us all to their ways...I would NOT want them in the positions stated in this thread. I hope that helps quell any fears. Thank you for the clarification! I am not the most eloquent person haha! Honestly that is the distinction I have been trying to get to this whole time! Im just terrible at explaining.
StMichael Posted March 25, 2013 Author Posted March 25, 2013 (edited) You are. By questioning why a homosexual cannot be a scout leader, you are therefore comfortable with a person, who has identified their sexual preference, in some cases openly, to be exposed to young men who are focused on moral character. Giving them an example that one can pick and choose what morality to follow. That this lifestyle is an option. This is promotion of a depraved lifestyle, as per the Catechism. Same would be for same sex couples to compete, be exposed to a large viewing audience as equal to male/ female couples. This causes confusion and is meant to provide normalization of a grave sin. So we are to pray for those inflicted with this preference that they are chaste and embrace God fully. Not empower them and their sin. And there would be no way to know if one was a homosexual unless they state they are, seek acceptance as such. Does that mean your straw man query to their being denied employment, access to shopping, etc. should even be replied to? Our country, assuming you are in the US, has far more problems than to be distracted by such groups seeking the federal government to grant them rights that do not exist. Now you, as an individual, can take up your banner, go march in some pseudo rights march to allow whatever cause you feel must be "equal" but a person who is looked to to uphold HIS word cannot function in the opposite, at the very least publicly. Who is promoting it?? Edited March 25, 2013 by StMichael
CrossCuT Posted March 25, 2013 Posted March 25, 2013 I really dont think you read the comments in this thread. :crazy: I have not even uttered a single word about empowering homosexual behavior. Honestly, before you start throwing accusations around about taking up my "banner" as you call it go read the things I have actually said because you seem to have completely misunderstood me and used it as your anger fuel. You a VERY quick too judge my friend.
Fidei Defensor Posted March 25, 2013 Posted March 25, 2013 (edited) I'm gay and I don't do anything different in my life from what an average straight person does. The only difference is that I am attracted to males instead of females. I'm living the "gay lifestyle." :rolleyes: Edited March 25, 2013 by tardis ad astra
StMichael Posted March 26, 2013 Author Posted March 26, 2013 Why do I need to know this? I don't. Furthermore, how exactly can you claim that you don't do anything different from the norm? You just did. How often does one go onto a message board and declare their sexual attraction as the main identifier as to who they are? I'm gay and I don't do anything different in my life from what an average straight person does. The only difference is that I am attracted to males instead of females. I'm living the "gay lifestyle." :rolleyes:
DiscerningCatholic Posted March 26, 2013 Posted March 26, 2013 OK, my head is going to explode! A priest at a local parish in Los Angeles, seems to be an advocate for many things that are against the teachings and is extremely active on a site called Change.org. Using his real name he is signing petitions (over the course of years) that support boycotts of the Boy Scouts unless they allow gays, petitioning shows (Dancing With The Stars) to allow same sex couples as well as some little boy who wants to dress like a girl to be accepted at their school. Dozens of signings for same sex marriage, LGBT support, etc. Even signing petitions to protect Planned Parenthood and those seeking to stop "personhood laws." What does one do with this information? How can such a person be so brazen? Is this something one should make the Diocese aware of? The Pastor? Write a letter to the bishop and find a new parish.
homeschoolmom Posted March 26, 2013 Posted March 26, 2013 Why do I need to know this? I don't. Furthermore, how exactly can you claim that you don't do anything different from the norm? You just did. How often does one go onto a message board and declare their sexual attraction as the main identifier as to who they are? I don't think he does do that as a regular practice. It has relevancy in this thread, though, in the way he stated it.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now