Fidei Defensor Posted March 30, 2013 Posted March 30, 2013 The very last thing he said before he died?
IcePrincessKRS Posted March 30, 2013 Posted March 30, 2013 (edited) I'm pretty sure it's "Father, into your hands I commend my spirit." Either that or "it is finished." I need to double check my Bible... I can't believe I can't remember this. We juuuust read it in Church this afternoon. :blush: Edited March 30, 2013 by IcePrincessKRS
IcePrincessKRS Posted March 30, 2013 Posted March 30, 2013 I'm pretty sure it's "Father, into your hands I commend my spirit." Either that or "it is finished." I need to double check my Bible... I can't believe I can't remember this. We juuuust read it in Church this afternoon. :blush: I was right the first time. The gospel of Luke 23:46 "Then Jesus, crying with a loud voice, said, 'Father, into thy hands I commit my spirit!' And having said this he breathed his last."
Fidei Defensor Posted March 30, 2013 Author Posted March 30, 2013 I was right the first time. The gospel of Luke 23:46 "Then Jesus, crying with a loud voice, said, 'Father, into thy hands I commit my spirit!' And having said this he breathed his last." John 19:30 "When Jesus therefore had received the vinegar, he said, It is finished: and he bowed his head, and gave up the spirit."
IcePrincessKRS Posted March 30, 2013 Posted March 30, 2013 John 19:30 "When Jesus therefore had received the vinegar, he said, It is finished: and he bowed his head, and gave up the spirit." I was just reading that, too, refreshing my memory. The other two gospels say he cried out in a loud voice. I figure Jesus said both. Different writers will have different perspectives, doesn't mean either of them is false.
Fidei Defensor Posted March 30, 2013 Author Posted March 30, 2013 I was just reading that, too, refreshing my memory. The other two gospels say he cried out in a loud voice. I figure Jesus said both. Different writers will have different perspectives, doesn't mean either of them is false. I just always found it curious that if they believed their Lord and Savior was dying in front of them, that they wouldn't have the exact words etched into their memory forever.
Gabriela Posted March 30, 2013 Posted March 30, 2013 I just always found it curious that if they believed their Lord and Savior was dying in front of them, that they wouldn't have the exact words etched into their memory forever. Much of the Bible was written decades or even hundreds of years after it happened. Some of it therefore looks more like transcribed oral history than the diary entries you write at the end of every night.
Fidei Defensor Posted March 30, 2013 Author Posted March 30, 2013 Much of the Bible was written decades or even hundreds of years after it happened. Some of it therefore looks more like transcribed oral history than the diary entries you write at the end of every night. True. I just still find it interesting. If someone I loved very much was dying, I would certainly make a strong attempt to recall their very last words. I can only imagine it to be even more important if you believe the person dying is your Lord.
Gabriela Posted March 30, 2013 Posted March 30, 2013 True. I just still find it interesting. If someone I loved very much was dying, I would certainly make a strong attempt to recall their very last words. I can only imagine it to be even more important if you believe the person dying is your Lord. Most of the apostles were not present at the crucifixion. In fact, only one was: "the disciple whom Jesus loved" (believed to be John). Thus, the accounts in the other Gospels are second-hand. They could have come from any of the Marys who were there, or from passers-by, from soldiers, etc. So the sources were not necessarily Christians (though they probably were). The point is: We have no idea who they were. If your purpose in starting this thread is to point out the hackneyed claim that "the Bible contradicts itself, thus it can't all be true, thus none of it is true," you're not going to have much luck. I don't think anyone around here will deny that the Bible "contradicts itself" on the propositional level. On the spiritual level, however, it does not, and that is what matters to the faithful. If you're only looking at the Bible as you would a police report, then you're looking at it with "eyes of flesh"—and missing most of its point. Someone more wisely Catholic than me please correct me if I'm wrong.
Pax_et bonum Posted March 30, 2013 Posted March 30, 2013 I just always found it curious that if they believed their Lord and Savior was dying in front of them, that they wouldn't have the exact words etched into their memory forever. Matthew, Mark, and Luke weren't at the crucifixion; John was, but his gospel was written last. Mark was a source for Matthew and Luke which is why those three are similar. The point of the Gospels is not to give an historical account of the life of Jesus. The Gospels are about who Jesus is as Risen Lord and alive today using events from His earthly life--it's about who He IS not was.
Fidei Defensor Posted March 30, 2013 Author Posted March 30, 2013 (edited) Most of the apostles were not present at the crucifixion. In fact, only one was: "the disciple whom Jesus loved" (believed to be John). Thus, the accounts in the other Gospels are second-hand. They could have come from any of the Marys who were there, or from passers-by, from soldiers, etc. So the sources were not necessarily Christians (though they probably were). The point is: We have no idea who they were. If your purpose in starting this thread is to point out the hackneyed claim that "the Bible contradicts itself, thus it can't all be true, thus none of it is true," you're not going to have much luck. I don't think anyone around here will deny that the Bible "contradicts itself" on the propositional level. On the spiritual level, however, it does not, and that is what matters to the faithful. If you're only looking at the Bible as you would a police report, then you're looking at it with "eyes of flesh"—and missing most of its point. Someone more wisely Catholic than me please correct me if I'm wrong. Matthew, Mark, and Luke weren't at the crucifixion; John was, but his gospel was written last. Mark was a source for Matthew and Luke which is why those three are similar. The point of the Gospels is not to give an historical account of the life of Jesus. The Gospels are about who Jesus is as Risen Lord and alive today using events from His earthly life--it's about who He IS not was. I didn't say anything about that issue... But since we're on it, why wouldn't God, in the interest of clarity, reveal his Word in a less…jumbled way? Edited March 30, 2013 by tardis ad astra
Gabriela Posted March 30, 2013 Posted March 30, 2013 I didn't say anything about that issue... But since we're on it, why wouldn't God, in the interest of clarity, reveal his Word in a less…jumbled way? Well, if He wanted to usurp the free will He so graciously gave us in order that we might love Him uncoerced and meaningfully choose to cooperate with Him in the act of sustaining His creation, then He could do that. But given that He did give us free will and He never usurps that entirely, we are not perfect conduits of the Divine. God did not dictate the entire Bible to a machine-like human secretary. He inspired dozens of people, all of whom wrote what they "heard" or "felt" or whatever, depending upon how they received the inspiration (I don't think we know how they did, at least in most cases). If you have ever made a phone call on a phone that was broken, then you know exactly what this is like. The message is perfect. The medium is not. That being said, we do believe that the Bible is "perfect" in the sense that we have precisely the book that God wants us to have. So, when there are contradictions between propositions in the Bible, my answer to your question would be: They're not a jumble. They're not unclear. They are a stumbling block to those who would refuse to believe. To those who do believe, the Bible is a beautiful spiritual work of art that requires community and tradition (i.e., other people) to interpret, understand, and appreciate, and faith (i.e., a gift of God) to accept. Perhaps those who see the Bible as "unclear" and "jumbled" simply do not yet have the necessary "eyes of faith" with which to see its spiritual perfection.
Fidei Defensor Posted March 30, 2013 Author Posted March 30, 2013 Well, if He wanted to usurp the free will He so graciously gave us in order that we might love Him uncoerced and meaningfully choose to cooperate with Him in the act of sustaining His creation, then He could do that. But given that He did give us free will and He never usurps that entirely, we are not perfect conduits of the Divine. God did not dictate the entire Bible to a machine-like human secretary. He inspired dozens of people, all of whom wrote what they "heard" or "felt" or whatever, depending upon how they received the inspiration (I don't think we know how they did, at least in most cases). If you have ever made a phone call on a phone that was broken, then you know exactly what this is like. The message is perfect. The medium is not. That being said, we do believe that the Bible is "perfect" in the sense that we have precisely the book that God wants us to have. So, when there are contradictions between propositions in the Bible, my answer to your question would be: They're not a jumble. They're not unclear. They are a stumbling block to those who would refuse to believe. To those who do believe, the Bible is a beautiful spiritual work of art that requires community and tradition (i.e., other people) to interpret, understand, and appreciate, and faith (i.e., a gift of God) to accept. Perhaps those who see the Bible as "unclear" and "jumbled" simply do not yet have the necessary "eyes of faith" with which to see its spiritual perfection. So you're saying that the only way free will can be exercised is if the messages from God don't come down clearly, and you have to use your imagination and faith to believe in him, even if it seems nonsensical?
HisChildForever Posted March 30, 2013 Posted March 30, 2013 I just always found it curious that if they believed their Lord and Savior was dying in front of them, that they wouldn't have the exact words etched into their memory forever. I personally believe that He said all that the Gospels recorded. He could have easily said "Father, into thy hands I commit my spirit! It is finished" and for whatever reason Luke left out the last sentence and John decided to only use the last sentence. Also, like Ice said, each writer approached the account differently - for a reason. Matthew, for example, wrote with a Jewish audience in mind. This is probably the reason why he included Psalm 22 ("My God, my God, why have You forsaken Me?") - Matthew frequently pointed his audience to the Old Testament. We also see that from the start of John Christ is the Word. John made it plain that Christ was (is) the Second Person of the Trinity, whereas Matthew sort of eases his audience into Christ's divinity. We also see that John made it a point to include the Blessed Virgin at the foot of the cross. Again, this is my personal belief, I like to think that since John's Gospel is especially spiritual (for lack of a better word), he wanted to emphasize Mary as our universal or Heavenly Mother (John 19:26-27). As an aside, John did not include the consecration of bread and wine, but he did include a lengthy discourse that's absent from the other Gospels. I think this is to again support his overall theme or message - like others said, John was written after the other Gospels, so he probably figured it would be okay to instead focus on the discourse and what that reveals about Jesus, since by that point everyone was pretty clear on the transubstantiation.
Fidei Defensor Posted March 30, 2013 Author Posted March 30, 2013 I personally believe that He said all that the Gospels recorded. He could have easily said "Father, into thy hands I commit my spirit! It is finished" and for whatever reason Luke left out the last sentence and John decided to only use the last sentence. Also, like Ice said, each writer approached the account differently - for a reason. Matthew, for example, wrote with a Jewish audience in mind. This is probably the reason why he included Psalm 22 ("My God, my God, why have You forsaken Me?") - Matthew frequently pointed his audience to the Old Testament. We also see that from the start of John Christ is the Word. John made it plain that Christ was (is) the Second Person of the Trinity, whereas Matthew sort of eases his audience into Christ's divinity. We also see that John made it a point to include the Blessed Virgin at the foot of the cross. Again, this is my personal belief, I like to think that since John's Gospel is especially spiritual (for lack of a better word), he wanted to emphasize Mary as our universal or Heavenly Mother (John 19:26-27). As an aside, John did not include the consecration of bread and wine, but he did include a lengthy discourse that's absent from the other Gospels. I think this is to again support his overall theme or message - like others said, John was written after the other Gospels, so he probably figured it would be okay to instead focus on the discourse and what that reveals about Jesus, since by that point everyone was pretty clear on the transubstantiation. This is a good answer.
HisChildForever Posted March 30, 2013 Posted March 30, 2013 I have something extra to add - please correct me if I'm wrong, but Luke wrote with a focus on the message of repentance and forgiveness, which is why he included the conversation between Christ and the two criminals, and thus the one criminal's repentance and Christ's promising him salvation. Luke also includes the parable of the prodigal son (I forget if the other Gospels do) which again highlights our repentance and God's subsequent forgiveness. And the parable of the lost sheep...etc.
HisChildForever Posted March 30, 2013 Posted March 30, 2013 Tardis, I learned about each Gospel writer's unique "theme" in an Intro to the Bible course I took my second semester undergrad. Catholic university, but the course was not so much theological as it was scholarly.
HisChildForever Posted March 30, 2013 Posted March 30, 2013 I still have the text book, it's just buried away in a trunk with other college texts, but it's in my room. If you're interested I can dig for it.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now