Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Jewish Understanding Of Christ


Recommended Posts

HisChildForever
Posted

What exactly does Judaism teach about Christ? That He was a moral teacher, His being Messiah embellished by His followers? that He never existed? that He was an impostor? From my understanding, Islamic faiths recognize that Christ did walk the earth, but as a prophet, not God-Man. But I never really considered what Judaism teaches.

HisChildForever
Posted

Thanks for the links, very helpful. Does anyone know if their overall understanding of Jesus (say, as a person/teacher) is positive or negative?

HisChildForever
Posted

Interesting that it seems they accept what Jesus said (that He was the Son of God) - just that He was wrong - as opposed to being of the opinion that His followers "added" to Christ's persona.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

Thanks for the links, very helpful. Does anyone know if their overall understanding of Jesus (say, as a person/teacher) is positive or negative?

I'm not very versed in it, so it would be speculation, but I think that the modern understanding is mostly neutral-positive simply because Jesus wasn't a bad person. I would venture to guess that theologically, it may be more negative under the whole "false messiah" thing.

Posted

I can't repeat what the Talmud says about our Lord but I wonder if it has anything to do with some Europeans burning it en masse.

Posted

Thanks for the links, very helpful. Does anyone know if their overall understanding of Jesus (say, as a person/teacher) is positive or negative?

 

I was an Orthodox Jew before I became Catholic. Among traditional Jews, it's very negative. The Talmud acknowledges that His name was Jesus by its wordplay on his name:

 

(ישוע(ה means "salvation" and is the word "Jesus" ("Yeshua").

 

The Talmud refers to Jesus as:

 

ישו ("Yeshu") which is an acronym for "יימחק שמו וזכרונו" ("May his name and memory be erased").

 

Orthodox Jews use the same acronym anytime they have to mention the name of Hitler.

 

I think that about says it all.

Posted

As an aside: The moment I began to consider the flaws in Judaism's arguments about Christ was the moment at which I realized that Chabadniks (a type of Chasidic Jew) believe their Rebbe (great rabbi) was the Messiah. The Rebbe, at the time, was dead. There was a fairly large group of Chabadniks making arguments from the Talmud and Torah that the messiah could rise from the dead—something Judaism has always had a hard time accepting. But because they wanted to believe so badly that the Rebbe was the messiah, they found ways to justify it with their holy books.

 

As soon as I saw that it could be justified (when Jews want it to be), I started wondering.

HisChildForever
Posted

I was an Orthodox Jew before I became Catholic. Among traditional Jews, it's very negative. The Talmud acknowledges that His name was Jesus by its wordplay on his name:

 

(ישוע(ה means "salvation" and is the word "Jesus" ("Yeshua").

 

The Talmud refers to Jesus as:

 

ישו ("Yeshu") which is an acronym for "יימחק שמו וזכרונו" ("May his name and memory be erased").

 

Orthodox Jews use the same acronym anytime they have to mention the name of Hitler.

 

I think that about says it all.

 

:|

Posted

:|

 

Well, if it's any consolation, among liberal Jews (i.e., not-very-religious ones), you can find some who will say, "I think Jesus was a good man, a good teacher." But it depends on how secure they are in their own Jewishness. If they're super-insecure (as most American Jews are), they'll not say that in order to better distinguish themselves from Christians, since that helps them to feel more Jewish. If they're secure in their Jewishness (or just really intellectually honest), they'll go ahead and acknowledge that He was a good man and teacher, but just not accept Him as Messiah.

 

It just depends.

 

What's funny is how many modern Israelis actually espouse a morality very similar to the one that Jesus espoused, and will actually acknowledge He was a good man and teacher (because Israelis generally are much more secure in their Jewishness than American Jews), but they won't consider for a second that Jesus was the Messiah.

 

Inoculation against Jesus-as-Savior in Jewish circles is pretty thorough. I had to accept Mary first and then wait a LONG time before I could accept her Son.

Chestertonian
Posted (edited)

Well, if it's any consolation, among liberal Jews (i.e., not-very-religious ones), you can find some who will say, "I think Jesus was a good man, a good teacher." But it depends on how secure they are in their own Jewishness. If they're super-insecure (as most American Jews are), they'll not say that in order to better distinguish themselves from Christians, since that helps them to feel more Jewish. If they're secure in their Jewishness (or just really intellectually honest), they'll go ahead and acknowledge that He was a good man and teacher, but just not accept Him as Messiah.

 

It just depends.

 

What's funny is how many modern Israelis actually espouse a morality very similar to the one that Jesus espoused, and will actually acknowledge He was a good man and teacher (because Israelis generally are much more secure in their Jewishness than American Jews), but they won't consider for a second that Jesus was the Messiah.

 

Inoculation against Jesus-as-Savior in Jewish circles is pretty thorough. I had to accept Mary first and then wait a LONG time before I could accept her Son.

 

Are you ethnically Jewish? I've always been curious as to how "gentile converts"  (for lack of a better term) to Judaism are treated.


 

Edited by Chestertonian
Posted

I was an Orthodox Jew before I became Catholic. Among traditional Jews, it's very negative. The Talmud acknowledges that His name was Jesus by its wordplay on his name:

 

(ישוע(ה means "salvation" and is the word "Jesus" ("Yeshua").

 

The Talmud refers to Jesus as:

 

ישו ("Yeshu") which is an acronym for "יימחק שמו וזכרונו" ("May his name and memory be erased").

 

Orthodox Jews use the same acronym anytime they have to mention the name of Hitler.

 

I think that about says it all.

 


Well that's depressing. :|

Posted


Well that's depressing. :|

 

Sorry. That post seems to have upset a few people. I was just trying to answer the question. :-(

Posted

To be fair, almost all the orthodox Jews I have met (including a few rabbis) have been far more respectful than that. Perhaps it's just the particular circles I was moving in, as any orthodox Jew happy to talk theology with a Catholic is probably going to be polite and thoughtful about others' religious beliefs.

 

What's funny is how many modern Israelis actually espouse a morality very similar to the one that Jesus espoused, and will actually acknowledge He was a good man and teacher (because Israelis generally are much more secure in their Jewishness than American Jews), but they won't consider for a second that Jesus was the Messiah.

 

This has not been my experience in Israel. In fact, I quickly learnt to tone down how I talk about my faith, because more religiously observant people seemed to take the mere mention of Jesus as a sign that I was trying to convert them (even if they were the ones who initiated the religious conversation in the first place). Proselytising being illegal there, I felt that I was treading on eggshells, as I didn't want to get into any trouble if people perceived me as a missionary. Secular people obviously couldn't care less, but they seemed to have a complete apathy to all religion.

Posted

Are you ethnically Jewish? I've always been curious as to how "gentile converts"  (for lack of a better term) to Judaism are treated.

 

No, I was not born Jewish. I converted. Converts are treated... in complicated fashion. It depends on the sect of Judaism, mostly. Overall, I'd say that, despite the Torah commands to treat the convert exactly the same as the native, and the Talmudic commands never to mention a convert's "past" to him (i.e., the fact that he is a convert), there is a great deal of suspicion and ethnic superiority among born Jews vis a vis converts. It's incredibly annoying, especially when the convert is a mitzah-observing, God-fearing Jew and the Yiddisher-than-thou native is a pork-fressing, Sabbath-desecrating atheist. But that's what conflating religion, ethnicity, and land-ownership gets you, I guess.

 

That being said, there were some who were welcoming and kind, who were typically very curious at first (i.e., "why in the world would you become a Jew?!"), but who, once their curiosity was satisfied, treated me just like any other Jew. This, however, was exceedingly rare. Pretty much anytime you stand out as different, it's going to be attributed to your having been (or even "being") a goy.

 

In this matter, secular Israelis are much more open and welcoming than the Orthodox, who tend to constantly question the kashrut of one's conversion, thus perpetually casting doubt on one's status as a Jew. For this reason, most Orthodox converts (and I dare say all ultra-Orthodox converts) never disclose to their communities that they're converts. Doing so could damage one's marriage prospects and cast doubt not just on one's own status as a Jew but that of one's children (and grandchildren, and great-grandchildren...) as well.

Posted

Sorry. That post seems to have upset a few people. I was just trying to answer the question. :-(

 


Oh don't be sorry, it was really informative! Your thoughtful responses throughout the thread have been informative and interesting.

Posted

To be fair, almost all the orthodox Jews I have met (including a few rabbis) have been far more respectful than that. Perhaps it's just the particular circles I was moving in, as any orthodox Jew happy to talk theology with a Catholic is probably going to be polite and thoughtful about others' religious beliefs.

 

 

This has not been my experience in Israel. In fact, I quickly learnt to tone down how I talk about my faith, because more religiously observant people seemed to take the mere mention of Jesus as a sign that I was trying to convert them (even if they were the ones who initiated the religious conversation in the first place). Proselytising being illegal there, I felt that I was treading on eggshells, as I didn't want to get into any trouble if people perceived me as a missionary. Secular people obviously couldn't care less, but they seemed to have a complete apathy to all religion.

 

I'd say that there are certainly Orthodox Jews who are respectful of others' beliefs in an ecumenical sense. And certainly there are those who would never bash anyone's religion or God even behind closed doors. I did not move in "ecumenical" circles. The ultra-Orthodox Jews I consorted with did not hang out with non-Jews, and most worked in 100% Jewish environments. You're probably hanging with "modern Orthodox" Jews, rather than ultra-Orthodox Jews. At least that's what it sounds like. An ultra-Orthodox Jew would immediately extricate himself from any conversation the second the name of Jesus was mentioned.

 

It's a common misconception that proselytization is illegal in Israel. It is only illegal to proselytize minors (people under 18). In fact, when I left Israel, the Messianic Jews there had just started a rather aggressive proselytization campaign in the streets of Tel Aviv. They were everywhere. And they got quite a bit of backlash over it. I don't know if they're still doing it, but knowing the leader of that particular group, I kinda' doubt they'd give up so easily. There have been multiple "specials" on Israeli tv about Messianic Jewish Israelis in the last five years or so. They totally baffle the average Israeli, who see them as absolute freakshows. 

 

When I mentioned that modern Israelis espouse a morality very similar to that taught by Jesus, I was referring to secular Israelis, not religious ones. Those totally apathetic to religion, believe it or not, will tell you they believe in "just being a good person". When you ask them what that means, it sounds an awful lot like Christianity!

Posted

Most of them are modern Orthodox, yes, but two are charedi. Not typical charedim, though.

 

When you say you were consorting with ultra-Orthodox Jews - who do you mean by that? Did you convert charedi? I'm curious, as that must have been a pretty lengthy process. Do they know you're Catholic now?

 

If you could point me to any legal stuff that says proselytism is legal I'd be grateful, as I hear all the time from certain Israeli friends that it's not. I'd like to be able to show them something definitive. I live in Bethlehem, where we often get international missionaries, and they are sometimes unsure about what they are and aren't allowed to do under Israeli law as well.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...