Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Any Psychological Theories To This?


Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted

So, as most of you know, I have a stutter. 95% of the time, it poses no problem at all and I speak as if I didn't have one. But there are times when I go through a rough patch and can't speak very well. I've been having one for a few weeks, but here's what gets me: I generally speak fine to complete strangers and to friends, but not to my family. Any theories on this? I could talk to Kate all day, but something as simply saying "Hey dad, can I go to the store?" takes me a few hesitations to say.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Repressed homosexuality?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Second theory: an abnormally benign (or perhaps just incompetent) demon.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Repressed homosexuality?

 

I'm sorry, I believe you posted in the wrong thread. The thread you were looking for is my Anne of Green Gables thread.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Third theory: Ebola.

GeorgiiMichael
Posted

Listen to music and start shouting profanities.

 

It's what I learned from The King's Speech.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Listen to music and start shouting profanities.

 

It's what I learned from The King's Speech.

 


A glorious movie for all stutterers. There's no stutter a silent F bomb can't fix.

ithinkjesusiscool
Posted

a visit to the shrink, perhaps?

Posted

Perhaps you fear talking to your father. My father had a knack for inducing anxiety in people when I was a young'n. 

Posted

Depends what triggers your stutter I guess. Maybe there's an anxiety attached to talking to certain people that makes it bad?

Posted

I'm sorry, I believe you posted in the wrong thread. The thread you were looking for is my Anne of Green Gables thread.

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bq1f3Hr03fQ[/media]

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

So, as most of you know, I have a stutter. 95% of the time, it poses no problem at all and I speak as if I didn't have one. But there are times when I go through a rough patch and can't speak very well. I've been having one for a few weeks, but here's what gets me: I generally speak fine to complete strangers and to friends, but not to my family. Any theories on this? I could talk to Kate all day, but something as simply saying "Hey dad, can I go to the store?" takes me a few hesitations to say.

 

I knew a guy in college who had the same sort of issue with stuttering. I don't know of anything in particular to help make it better, but you're not alone in this. I think it could definitely have to do with stress.

Posted

I've found, with me, that I would stutter/stammer more in stressful situations.

 

Part of it is because my mind was going a mile a minute (because of the stress).  Part of it would be because I wanted to do well and not stutter, (like a speech or a presentation).

 

But this was mostly stress during events...not a person, per se.  However, when I was first going out with Shea, I would stammer a little bit around her.  Again, stress I think..but that did revolve around a person. 

 

I am unsure if it is psychological other than stress.  But perhaps it is psychological as it refers to how you handle stress with your Dad vs. others? Perhaps learn about some stress relieving exercises as see how that works for you?

 

 

Posted

Mel Tillis was a famous stutterer. He didn't stutter when singing, so try that. When your family makes you that nervous, sing your responses to them.

Posted (edited)

Sounds like you just need to move out the house and find your own identity. I think the over-control of adults is a cause of many problems like youth delinquence, etc. Families mean well, but some day you're going to die, and families have a hard time accepting that and letting young people go out and experience the world. What can young people do in such a situation? I think they respond in different ways...dropping out of life and just going through the home routine, getting involved in a gang...maybe stuttering? IDK, you asked for a psychological suggestion. I'm not a believer in the romantic idea of family...family is good, but it is not the end goal of life. "That is why a man leaves his father and mother and is united to his wife, and they become one flesh." (Genesis 2:24)

Edited by Era Might
PhuturePriest
Posted

I've found, with me, that I would stutter/stammer more in stressful situations.

 

Part of it is because my mind was going a mile a minute (because of the stress).  Part of it would be because I wanted to do well and not stutter, (like a speech or a presentation).

 

But this was mostly stress during events...not a person, per se.  However, when I was first going out with Shea, I would stammer a little bit around her.  Again, stress I think..but that did revolve around a person. 

 

I am unsure if it is psychological other than stress.  But perhaps it is psychological as it refers to how you handle stress with your Dad vs. others? Perhaps learn about some stress relieving exercises as see how that works for you?

 

I've been talking to IcePrincess privately, and I think we have a pretty solid theory going. My speaking is always fine if I'm not around my family. Last month when all of the craziness was going on, I suddenly had problems speaking. When I went to stay at Michael and Kenzie's house for two weeks immediately after, I didn't have any problems anymore, but they came back when I came home. When I went to visit Seminary in November, my speaking was flawless. Not one person there knows I have a stutter, and if you told them they wouldn't believe you. I just don't feel anxiety when speaking to other people (Unless my family is there). Tomorrow I'm going to call Kate, and if history means anything that could last up to three hours, but I have absolutely no anxiety about that. But I do at the thought of talking to my family. It's just weird.

PhuturePriest
Posted

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bq1f3Hr03fQ[/media]

 

Don't tell me what I already know, fool.

Archaeology cat
Posted

Not weird given all that happened, IMO.

Blackthorne
Posted

1. Stop talking to my wife privately.

 

2. It doesn't matter why you stutter. What you need is the cure. Put a ruck on your back, walk until pass out. Once you regain consciousness, get to your feet, continuing walking until you pass out again. Do this for a week straight and I promise you'll never stutter again.

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

Since I just woke up and I'm really lazy, i'll just copy and paste information from studies I just skimmed through.
 

 "Phonological and cognitive processing of AWS (adults who stutter) is more vulnerable to disruptions caused by increased amounts of cognitive load in concurrent attention-demanding tasks." (Lowe et al, 2012)

"Adults who stutter may neglect positive social cues within social situations that could serve to disconfirm negative beliefs and fears." [this is due to avoidance of eye contact... if this applies to you] This relates to the whole anxiety thing. 

(Robyn et al, 2012)

I know very little about stuttering but if what I'm about to say is at all true, this might help. If you find that you have to exert yourself to speak at times, it might get harder to do because your ego is depleted. Self-control is a depletable resource. One way to replenish your ego (self control) is to ingest glucose (or gargle sugar water, that works too). It might sound crazy but whatevs. Take it or leave itz. 

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...