Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Byzantine
Posted

Wanted a quick answer, so here goes:

 

Let's say Country A has a legitimate reason for declaring war on Country B. However, there is no serious chance of success unless Country C joins in on A's side. Is C allowed to join A?

Posted

yes

PhuturePriest
Posted

Why wouldn't it? As long as every action to maintain peace and further peace has been tried, there is no reason not to. England declared war on Germany even though Germany invaded Poland. Poland needed England's help, and Germany was in the wrong. England was justified in declaring war on Germany (From my understanding).

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I would say only if it is otherwise just for C to be involved in the war. If C has no legitimate moral reason to go to war, then I think Just War doctrine would forbid it.
However, I will admit that I am having a tough time coming up with a plausible scenario in which war between A and B is just, but not between C and B. I am not sure whether or not it is a theoretically workable situation, but it does strike me as within the realm of possibility.

Byzantine
Posted

I would say only if it is otherwise just for C to be involved in the war. If C has no legitimate moral reason to go to war, then I think Just War doctrine would forbid it.
However, I will admit that I am having a tough time coming up with a plausible scenario in which war between A and B is just, but not between C and B. I am not sure whether or not it is a theoretically workable situation, but it does strike me as within the realm of possibility.

 

Would a defensive alliance or old friendship between the countries justify C going to A's aid?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Would a defensive alliance or old friendship between the countries justify C going to A's aid?


In and of itself... Honestly, I want to argue no, but I am just not sure. A purely defensive alliance, probably. Old friendship...? I am slightly stumped.
Posted

You just gotta be all, 'HEY HEY HEY!'

Posted

C should conquer both A and B.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

1st rule of Just War Theory:
 

There is NEVER a quick answer. :)

Byzantine
Posted

What if it was certain that if A fell, B would attack C right after, and that only a combined effort by C and A had any chance?

Posted

Why does everyone always have to pick on B? Anyone with a brain and some guts knows that A started it. Not debatable. 

Byzantine
Posted

Why does everyone always have to pick on B? Anyone with a brain and some guts knows that A started it. Not debatable. 

 

What if B were orcs and A and C were men and elves?

PhuturePriest
Posted

What if B were orcs and A and C were men and elves?

Then A and C should fight them continuously for thousands of years, until nine people sweep in and destroy them all in three years.

Winchester
Posted

Is this a thread where we only talk about war?

Posted

War didn't end any of those things.  None of them have ended.  Some wars have ended some instances of some of those things for some periods of time.  

Nihil Obstat
Posted

War didn't end any of those things.  None of them have ended.  Some wars have ended some instances of some of those things for some periods of time.  

Sometimes you are all right, for a socialistic atheist. :|

Nihil Obstat
Posted

What if it was certain that if A fell, B would attack C right after, and that only a combined effort by C and A had any chance?

Sorry, I somehow missed this before.

 

I think if B were a legitimate aggressor, and if the specific 'methods of war' employed were proportionate and moral, then it would be justified for C to join in declaring war on B.

 

I am really vacillating (in case you could not tell :rolleyes: ). I was looking at this thread again earlier today, and started typing up a post that ended up being very much in favour of it being moral for C to declare war against B in general, assuming by just war theory B is a legitimate aggressor, and A and C are legitimately innocent parties.

Byzantine
Posted (edited)

So to take a real life example, what if the US had joined WWII on the side of the Allies before being attacked?

Edited by Byzantine
Nihil Obstat
Posted

So to take a real life example, what if the US had joined WWII on the side of the Allies before being attacked?

I would rather avoid commenting on real life examples. :sweat:

WWII is complicated by the fact that it seriously failed the just war doctrine based on immoral means used to fight.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...