Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Mary-like Modesty Rules  

21 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Because we can go over and over this again but it's the same thing.  Someone comes in and says "I think we should dress this way" and it drags on and on.  Google "modesty" on Phatmass and you will find ENDLESS threads.

 

the standards were brought up by the website, already... I just gave a tip on how they can be adapted to modern type of clothing. :)

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

And how does one find a "cami" that does not reach more than "2 fingers breadth below the pit of the throat"?? 

 

I would think at that point you would only be able to wear a full t-shirt underneath - and unless you live in Utah, that generally looks odd.

 

I wear my cami backwards lol :P it works if the tag is not sewn on (but printed).

Posted

Yeah, I'm not wearing my cami backwards. I'm perfectly fine with people seeing my chest. (Obviously not low as heck, but I have boobs. Shocker! It's hard to hide them.)

Posted

Pictures of cats do not work on me

IMG_2074.jpg
Better?
Posted

Let's also mention how these rules are much easier for smaller girls. I have a lots more curves than the average gal which makes shirts and skirts more prone to tightness (I'm fine with it). It's either that or Frump City. These "standards" are also stupid because they just focus on one body type.

HisChildForever
Posted

Let's also mention how these rules are much easier for smaller girls. I have a lots more curves than the average gal which makes shirts and skirts more prone to tightness (I'm fine with it). It's either that or Frump City. These "standards" are also stupid because they just focus on one body type.

 

You raise an excellent point. Although - these rules aren't that fabulous for thin girls either. If I don't wear form-fitted clothing I look like a 12-year old boy. The clothing swallows me whole.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Let's also mention how these rules are much easier for smaller girls. I have a lots more curves than the average gal which makes shirts and skirts more prone to tightness (I'm fine with it). It's either that or Frump City. These "standards" are also stupid because they just focus on one body type.

 

The main issue I find with standards such as these is that they always have the wrong focus: stopping your brothers from sinning. This is not what modesty is about. Modesty is about showing your self-worth as a human being, not about covering your body up with a completely unflattering trash bag so us men won't sin.

Posted

The main issue I find with standards such as these is that they always have the wrong focus: stopping your brothers from sinning. This is not what modesty is about. Modesty is about showing your self-worth as a human being, not about covering your body up with a completely unflattering trash bag so us men won't sin.


:love:
PhuturePriest
Posted

:love:

 

I knew you'd come around. :love:

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

The main issue I find with standards such as these is that they always have the wrong focus: stopping your brothers from sinning. This is not what modesty is about. Modesty is about showing your self-worth as a human being, not about covering your body up with a completely unflattering trash bag so us men won't sin.

 

Don't want to get into a debate about modesty again and at what point it "protects the dignity of the individual" - but regarding the second point; I didn't see a trash bag mentioned :P  I also don't think that covering shoulders and wearing mid calf skirts = trashbag.  I think this type of clothing is more flattering than short/tight clothing.

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
MissScripture
Posted

If I wore my cami backwards, the milk access would be in the back, and my baby would be furious. :hehe2:

PhuturePriest
Posted

Don't want to get into a debate about modesty again and at what point it "protects the dignity of the individual" - but regarding the second point; I didn't see a trash bag mentioned :P  I also don't think that covering shoulders and wearing mid calf skirts = trashbag.  I think this type of clothing is more flattering than short/tight clothing.

 

I never said you or anyone else said these things, and I never said covering the shoulders and mid-calf was akin to a trash bag. It was a tongue-in-cheek remark on how ridiculous people can sometimes be. For what it's worth, I don't think your methods are overboard. I would never impose them on my wife or daughters, but that doesn't mean I think they are overboard.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

(to Missscripture) True about that :) with me, my shoulders are smaller than most girls it seems, because any top I try on becomes more low cut than on other people. Camis are typically very low cut on me, so I put mine on backwards. Another alternative maybe would be to make one.

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
Posted

The main issue I find with standards such as these is that they always have the wrong focus: stopping your brothers from sinning. This is not what modesty is about. Modesty is about showing your self-worth as a human being, not about covering your body up with a completely unflattering trash bag so us men won't sin.


That's highly inconsiderate to those with an unflattering trash bag fettish. :|
PhuturePriest
Posted

That's highly inconsiderate to those with an unflattering trash bag fettish. :|

 

Don't mention the Irish in my presence.

Posted

Don't mention the Irish in my presence.


My bad. How about Germans?
MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

I never said you or anyone else said these things, and I never said covering the shoulders and mid-calf was akin to a trash bag. It was a tongue-in-cheek remark on how ridiculous people can sometimes be. For what it's worth, I don't think your methods are overboard. I would never impose them on my wife or daughters, but that doesn't mean I think they are overboard.

okay :) good to know. I've never heard anyone argue ridiculous points though.. people just tend to bring up the same standards as described on the website. I try to follow them too... it doens't seem as extreme as it does at first glance. I mean, if you (not you though :P lol) wear a mid calf or a maxi skirt, a shirt with a bit longer sleeves, and a high cut top, - that is basically the website's description. I was trying to describe, how in my opinion this looks more flattering on many people than shorter/tighter clothing (such as skirts above the knee), so when people say that this type of clothing is unflattering, I differ... maybe sometimes it's not as "fashionable" but I think it has an innocence and beauty to it that some modern fashions have lost (ie: beautiful vs "hot").

 

agh it's hard to talk online sometimes  :(

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
PhuturePriest
Posted

My bad. How about Germans?

 

I'm both Irish and German, so you can pretty much say all the mean things you want about either and I won't be offended. :P

 

okay :) good to know. I've never heard anyone argue pro-trashbag before though.. people just tend to bring up the same standards as described on the website. I try to follow them too... it doens't seem as extreme as it does at first glance. I mean, if you (not you though :P lol) wear a mid calf or a maxi skirt, a shirt with a bit longer sleeves, and a high cut top, - that is basically the website's description. I was trying to describe, how in my opinion this looks more flattering on many people than shorter/tighter clothing, so when people say that this type of clothing is unflattering, I differ...

 

agh it's hard to talk online sometimes  :(

 

Well, some people go overboard with the standards, either making them worse, or telling every woman who fails them either slightly or majorly that they are a scandalous tramp bent on tempting every man that saw them to sin. Every woman deserves to be respected and loved. This is the point of modesty in itself. It is not to save men from sin, but it is to respect yourself as a human being. When the intent is turned into not tempting men (Which it is a majority of the time) then it will be met with opposition, and it is received as condescending. Women want men to respect them. That is why they (Normally) wear such scandalous clothing: they think it will gain them respect and love, because this is what society has told them. This is a crucial point to it all that a lot of people miss or forget.

 

As for clothing, I really have no opinion on it as of yet, but please be assured what I was saying wasn't directed at you at all. I didn't even read your posts.

Posted

I dress like I'm straight out of the trailer-park. Kinda like people of wal-mart but with less hanging out in the open.

 

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...