Laudate_Dominum Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 This made me think of you. http://the-american-catholic.com/2010/09/07/thomas-woods-and-his-critics-the-austrian-vs-distributist-debate-among-catholics/
Nihil Obstat Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Really unfortunate about how Dr. Woods and Mr. Ferrara had such a major falling-out over Austrianism vs. distributism. I guess things just got too personal.
NonNovi Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 1) Why are the priest's vestments different in the EF and NO? 2) Why are the calendars different? 3) Has anyone else had problems remembering what's different when switching between rites? Or am I the only one who's started in Latin only to realize that she's at an NO Mass that is most assuredly not in Latin? (Okay, that's just to laugh at myself and have a little fun.) 1. They aren't. The vestments are the same (except that in NOM the maniple isn't used anymore, but still allowed), it's the style that is different. Even church fashion changes through the ages. In the 1970's they just started to use a very ugly style of vestments, wich can be worn at an EF Mass too. There is no obligated style for EF Mass. On the other hand, EF people and priests usually want to have beauty at the liturgy, so in most cases they choose fiddlebacks or nicely decorated gotic chasubles. 2. Because they just decided to change the calendar, I don't know exactly why. Can be very confusing, because they also count different. When you have at EF the Mass of the 5th sunday after Easter, that will be the 6th sunday of Easter at OF. I like the old calendar better, it has much more variety and stresses important feasts more. 3. I attend both forms kind of equally and actually never have problems switching. If they do NOM right, the difference isn't that big. At the monastery where I now live half of the time, they celebrate NOM ad orientem, and everything is as much as possible and allowed like the EF. Then you really see the continuity and that a lot of NOM's are just abuses of the liturgy, that certain people want(ed) to create a rupture. On the other hand it can be confusing too. I once served Mass and I only realised it was NOM when I saw the missal was on the "wrong" side and the priest just walked up to the altar instead of saying the prayers at the foot.
Nihil Obstat Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 I once served Mass and I only realised it was NOM when I saw the missal was on the "wrong" side and the priest just walked up to the altar instead of saying the prayers at the foot. To be entirely fair, that was about as early as you possibly could have figured it out. :| It is not like you did not realize until he got to the Te Igitur or something. :smile3:
NonNovi Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 To be entirely fair, that was about as early as you possibly could have figured it out. :| It is not like you did not realize until he got to the Te Igitur or something. :smile3: True, but I was assuming all morning it would be EF, and I seriously didn't realise it until we were in front of the altar.
Nihil Obstat Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 They certainly can look similar, going simply by outward appearances.
NonNovi Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 They certainly can look similar, going simply by outward appearances. Yeah, I'm with you on the Propers thing :) EF made me understand OF a lot better, because OF just seems to be a watered down form of EF. But still, EF is sooo much richer when it comes to prayers for specific occasions. OF can be very shallow and general when it comes to that.
brianthephysicist Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 1. They aren't. The vestments are the same (except that in NOM the maniple isn't used anymore, but still allowed), it's the style that is different. Even church fashion changes through the ages. In the 1970's they just started to use a very ugly style of vestments, wich can be worn at an EF Mass too. There is no obligated style for EF Mass. On the other hand, EF people and priests usually want to have beauty at the liturgy, so in most cases they choose fiddlebacks or nicely decorated gotic chasubles. 2. Because they just decided to change the calendar, I don't know exactly why. Can be very confusing, because they also count different. When you have at EF the Mass of the 5th sunday after Easter, that will be the 6th sunday of Easter at OF. I like the old calendar better, it has much more variety and stresses important feasts more. 3. I attend both forms kind of equally and actually never have problems switching. If they do NOM right, the difference isn't that big. At the monastery where I now live half of the time, they celebrate NOM ad orientem, and everything is as much as possible and allowed like the EF. Then you really see the continuity and that a lot of NOM's are just abuses of the liturgy, that certain people want(ed) to create a rupture. On the other hand it can be confusing too. I once served Mass and I only realised it was NOM when I saw the missal was on the "wrong" side and the priest just walked up to the altar instead of saying the prayers at the foot. What was different that made it stress important feasts more?
Nihil Obstat Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Yeah, I'm with you on the Propers thing :) EF made me understand OF a lot better, because OF just seems to be a watered down form of EF. But still, EF is sooo much richer when it comes to prayers for specific occasions. OF can be very shallow and general when it comes to that. It is very unfortunate that most of the propers were stripped of their original form.
Nihil Obstat Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 What was different that made it stress important feasts more? It is not the 'technical reason', but it sort of feels like they carried out the Holy Week renovations, which consisted of tinkering with most of the rubrics and ceremonials, and they just had so much fun that they wanted to do it with everything else too. :P Part of it was a desire to simplify the classes of feasts, so they moved from the somewhat complicated older system to the current (perhaps not quite flexible enough) system of feria-memorial-feast-solemnity. As they changed the ranking system, they also began to move things around and also suppress some things and add others.
BigJon16 Posted May 14, 2013 Posted May 14, 2013 Also conical. Conical is super cool, but easy to screw up really badly. Good: Very appropriately named: How to properly or improperly wear a conical chasuble. Now that is cool! I'd like one of them, some day.. (God willing) Ordination gift? :P
ChristinaTherese Posted May 14, 2013 Author Posted May 14, 2013 Thanks for the answers, and info on types of chasubles! Another vestment-type (not particularly rite-related) question: Why do I see stoles worn over the chasuble sometimes and under it other times (most of the time)?
Nihil Obstat Posted May 14, 2013 Posted May 14, 2013 Thanks for the answers, and info on types of chasubles! Another vestment-type (not particularly rite-related) question: Why do I see stoles worn over the chasuble sometimes and under it other times (most of the time)? That one is simple. :) Wearing the stole over the chasuble is wrong. Some priests do it (and I believe it was somewhat more common in the last few decades) because presumably they think it looks better. But they are wrong, and they should not be doing it.
NonNovi Posted May 14, 2013 Posted May 14, 2013 Now that is cool! I'd like one of them, some day.. (God willing) Ordination gift? :P I would like one like Saint Ignatius of Loyola. You can see here how the gothic chasuble eventually became a fiddleback by cutting away more and more fabric around the arms. And wearing a stole over the chasuble is just wrong. I have even seen chasubles with stoles fixed on them on the outside! White ones, on a chasuble of a different colour!!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now