Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I thought IM2 was bad.

Havent seen IM3 yet though

GeorgiiMichael
Posted

Probably not. I'm going to venture a guess that's the very reason we haven't seen him in his own movie...

 

Except he had 2. The most recent one, with Ed Norton was supposed to be the pre-Avengers movie for the Hulk (and I think technically it is), but Ed Norton is a finicky actor and didn't want to reprise his role as Bruce Banner so we got Mark Ruffalo in The Avengers. 

Posted

It was the worst superhero movie I've seen in a long time. Not only was the story absolute nonsense (don't talk to me about the difference between "movie canon" and "comic canon"...the Extremis story in the comics was awesome, while the version of it here was moronic and missed the entire purpose of the serum), but the entire tone of the movie was off. The preceding movies were great because they balanced the action and the suspense with the humor. With this movie, they just went full-blown comedy, complete with pelvic thrusts, a Jack Sparrow impression, and a nauseating mid movie storyline involving Tony in a trucker hat. I mean, did we REALLY need 25 minutes of Tony jive-talking with a precocious 10 year old?

It was like they took the stuff people liked about the first and second movies, along with The Avengers, and turned up the volume to please the happy meal crowd. Why explore the true emotional horrors of PTSD when you can have a scene of Tony having a nightmare, and then spend the rest of the movie putting his panic attacks into contexts involving humor? Why delve deep into the way governments and non-government agencies use fear of "terrorists" to advance their goals and acquire more power, when you can just have someone be a funny Limey drinking Budweiser with some bikini-clad coeds?

Stupid. All of the cool stuff was almost immediately subverted by an attitude that screamed "we don't take this seriously." Which is fine, if you're honest about what you're doing before you do it. But go and look at the first 2 trailers that they released for this movie. Do they look, or feel, at all like the movie you just saw?

(This is to say nothing of the fact that the "Iron Patriot" fired NOT ONE bullet, or how easy it was for Tony to "cure" Pepper at the end, or how dreadfully trite RDJ's shucking and jiving was, or how it makes Tony look non-essential when villains, Pepper Potts and others can operate the Iron Man--and Iron Patriot--suits at will, thereby nullifying the entire prototype montage from the first movie)

xTrishaxLynnx
Posted

Except he had 2. The most recent one, with Ed Norton was supposed to be the pre-Avengers movie for the Hulk (and I think technically it is), but Ed Norton is a finicky actor and didn't want to reprise his role as Bruce Banner so we got Mark Ruffalo in The Avengers. 

Well I meant Mark Ruffalo, like you were saying before. I don't like him very much as The Hulk.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I am in the minority who preferred the second. :sweat: I thought it was great. Have not seen the third yet. Probably will not in the theatre. I would rather see Star Trek.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I am in the minority who preferred the second. :sweat: I thought it was great. Have not seen the third yet. Probably will not in the theatre. I would rather see Star Trek.

Posted

Also, bullocks to people talking about character development. What about Tony has changed from the end of the 1st movie? He's still wildly arrogant, incredibly childish, and totally self involved. Except for his love for Pepper, which hasn't changed or "evolved" in any way.

He didn't develop, grow up or improve as a person. He's just got more suits, and developed technology that makes it possible for him not to have the arc reactor in his chest to power the suits.

Posted

Also, bullocks to people talking about character development. What about Tony has changed from the end of the 1st movie? He's still wildly arrogant, incredibly childish, and totally self involved. Except for his love for Pepper, which hasn't changed or "evolved" in any way.

He didn't develop, grow up or improve as a person. He's just got more suits, and developed technology that makes it possible for him not to have the arc reactor in his chest to power the suits.

Posted

It was a Roger Moore Bond film. Or Jurassic Park 3.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Also, bullocks to people talking about character development. What about Tony has changed from the end of the 1st movie? He's still wildly arrogant, incredibly childish, and totally self involved. Except for his love for Pepper, which hasn't changed or "evolved" in any way.

He didn't develop, grow up or improve as a person. He's just got more suits, and developed technology that makes it possible for him not to have the arc reactor in his chest to power the suits.

 

From what I've seen, he has become more caring for other people and their welfare than before. He also seems to be less of a narcissistic sociopath.

Posted

From what I've seen, he has become more caring for other people and their welfare than before. He also seems to be less of a narcissistic sociopath.


Justify that.

Examples please.
PhuturePriest
Posted

Justify that.

Examples please.

 

I'm not really going to debate this, because I'm not a superhero nerd and you can run circles around me in this area. But from having watched (Somewhat forcibly by Michael) Iron Man one and two, as well as The Avengers, it seems his character has grown and that he isn't as self-involved.

GeorgiiMichael
Posted

Calm down Kujo. You clearly have strong opinions, but you're getting argumentative and that's not cool. You're not going to convince people who liked the movie that it was bad, and we're not going to convince you that it was good, so cut it out and move on.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Calm down Kujo. You clearly have strong opinions, but you're getting argumentative and that's not cool. You're not going to convince people who liked the movie that it was bad, and we're not going to convince you that it was good, so cut it out and move on.

 

It's almost as if it's just a stupid movie.

Nihil Obstat
Posted (edited)

.

Edited by Nihil Obstat
GeorgiiMichael
Posted

It's almost as if it's just a stupid movie.

 

It's certainly just a movie.

 

Making judgment calls about what is and is not stupid is not the place of someone who hasn't seen it and has admitted to not liking the genre.

PhuturePriest
Posted

It's certainly just a movie.

 

Making judgment calls about what is and is not stupid is not the place of someone who hasn't seen it and has admitted to not liking the genre.

 

I didn't mean "stupid" to down-play it. If this were a debate about The Lord of the Rings, I would have said "It's just a stupid movie/book", despite the fact that I'm a huge fan of The Lord of the Rings.

Posted

On your second "didn't like" point, I get where you're coming from, but all of those suits represent a time in Tony's life that he's trying to move beyond. Like he said at the end, he's still Iron Man, and so he'll still suit up. But those particular suits represent the dark places he was during his PTSD, and like the name of the protocol indicates, he needed a clean slate. 

 

Ah okay, I missed where he'll still suit up.  The way you explain it makes it way better, thanks!

Posted

Calm down Kujo. You clearly have strong opinions, but you're getting argumentative and that's not cool. You're not going to convince people who liked the movie that it was bad, and we're not going to convince you that it was good, so cut it out and move on.


I'm sorry, princess. Here I was thinking that this was an exchange of opinions between people that could handle a difference of them, when in fact I was dealing with delicate ears who weren't capable (or willing) to dialogue.

Duly noted. Thanks for giving me permission to "move on."
GeorgiiMichael
Posted

I'm sorry, princess. Here I was thinking that this was an exchange of opinions between people that could handle a difference of them, when in fact I was dealing with delicate ears who weren't capable (or willing) to dialogue.

Duly noted. Thanks for giving me permission to "move on."

 

You not only managed to be completely sexist, but you've also missed the point. Good job bro, that takes some record level asshattery.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...