Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Aethists Redeemed? Pope Francis


Recommended Posts

thessalonian
Posted

This maybe should go in debate but we will start it off here.  I have thought of this before, if anyone could be invincibly ignorant as an atheist.  I go back and forth but mostly back.  I have a hard time seeing it.  But it certainly is more difficult for an atheist today I think, because there are so many atheists who have written long windage, justifying themselves, that has influenced others.  I guess I would rather the Pope hadn't said this as it will be twisted and turned and used in ways that it was not intended.  Thoughts?

 

http://religion.blogs.cnn.com/2013/05/23/heaven-for-atheists-pope-sparks-debate/?iref=allsearch

 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I think we must understand this as meaning "atheists are redeemed by Christ's sacrifice, as are all men, but they, like anyone else, must accept Jesus Christ and His Church."

Posted

"For God has consigned all men to disobedience, that he may have mercy upon all." --Romans 11:32

KnightofChrist
Posted

I think we must understand this as meaning "atheists are redeemed by Christ's sacrifice, as are all men, but they, like anyone else, must accept Jesus Christ and His Church."

 

"It is an absurd dichotomy to think of living with Jesus but without the Church, of following Jesus outside of the Church, of loving Jesus without loving the Church" - Pope Francis

 

 

Posted

Since when do we stop speaking the truth just because people will twist it? If we did that we wouldn't say anything at all. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Since when do we stop speaking the truth just because people will twist it? If we did that we wouldn't say anything at all.

In a world as messed up as ours, sometimes extra effort is prudent in order to ensure as much as possible that we are not misunderstood. It does not help that we do not even get the entirety of his remarks and all the context therein.
Fr. Z wrote a good little follow-up yesterday.


Pope Francis on the possibility of salvation for atheists
Posted on 23 May 2013 by Fr. John Zuhlsdorf
People are sending me notes about Pope Francis’ fervorino from Mass yesterday. News outlets (and panicky emails I am getting) are suggesting that the Pope said that atheists go to heaven.

Alas, we never get what the Pope actually said in its entirety. We are only getting bits and pieces as determined by someone working for either Vatican Radio or L’Osservatore Romano or… well… it’s hard to know! This is a problem. Did the newsie doing the reporting making the right selection of quotes? Is the newsie doing the reporting a theologian? We should either get everything Francis says or nothing. Moreover, the Italian accounts and the English accounts of what Francis said differ somewhat. And who knows how what Francis says in these sermonettes will ultimately be related to the Ordinary Magisterium of the Roman Pontiff? We are told that it is doesn’t form part of his magisterial teaching, but… really? They sure are being played up by the Holy See’s news agencies, aren’t they!

Back to the Pope’s sermon from 22 May.

If you go through his comments as reported, and I did, there is nothing in Pope Francis’s remarks about the possibility of atheists being saved that is not in keeping with the document Dominus Iesus.

In a nutshell, Francis was not talking about non-Catholics or non-Christians. He was not talking about those who profess another religion with their own mediators. He was not talking about those who pray to other gods. He was talking about atheists.

Moreover, Francis was clear that whatever graces are offered to atheists (such that they may be saved) are from Christ. He was clear that salvation is only through Christ’s Sacrifice. In other words, he is not suggesting – and I think some are taking it this way – that you can be saved, get to heaven, without Christ.

So, have a care with these sermons. It is great to get pithy lines from the Holy Father about something that is crystal clear such as, say, the Devil. It is another when the pithy quip veers into something that is more difficult to untangle. It is best not to jump to negative conclusions based on the incomplete reports about fervorini of ambiguous magisterial authority.

Posted

In a world as messed up as ours, sometimes extra effort is prudent in order to ensure as much as possible that we are not misunderstood. It does not help that we do not even get the entirety of his remarks and all the context therein.
Fr. Z wrote a good little follow-up yesterday.


Pope Francis on the possibility of salvation for atheists
Posted on 23 May 2013 by Fr. John Zuhlsdorf
People are sending me notes about Pope Francis’ fervorino from Mass yesterday. News outlets (and panicky emails I am getting) are suggesting that the Pope said that atheists go to heaven.

Alas, we never get what the Pope actually said in its entirety. We are only getting bits and pieces as determined by someone working for either Vatican Radio or L’Osservatore Romano or… well… it’s hard to know! This is a problem. Did the newsie doing the reporting making the right selection of quotes? Is the newsie doing the reporting a theologian? We should either get everything Francis says or nothing. Moreover, the Italian accounts and the English accounts of what Francis said differ somewhat. And who knows how what Francis says in these sermonettes will ultimately be related to the Ordinary Magisterium of the Roman Pontiff? We are told that it is doesn’t form part of his magisterial teaching, but… really? They sure are being played up by the Holy See’s news agencies, aren’t they!

Back to the Pope’s sermon from 22 May.

If you go through his comments as reported, and I did, there is nothing in Pope Francis’s remarks about the possibility of atheists being saved that is not in keeping with the document Dominus Iesus.

In a nutshell, Francis was not talking about non-Catholics or non-Christians. He was not talking about those who profess another religion with their own mediators. He was not talking about those who pray to other gods. He was talking about atheists.

Moreover, Francis was clear that whatever graces are offered to atheists (such that they may be saved) are from Christ. He was clear that salvation is only through Christ’s Sacrifice. In other words, he is not suggesting – and I think some are taking it this way – that you can be saved, get to heaven, without Christ.

So, have a care with these sermons. It is great to get pithy lines from the Holy Father about something that is crystal clear such as, say, the Devil. It is another when the pithy quip veers into something that is more difficult to untangle. It is best not to jump to negative conclusions based on the incomplete reports about fervorini of ambiguous magisterial authority.

I have actually already read that. :) 

I agree the lack of context is never helpful. And while it is important to be prudent, there is no amount of prudence that will stop some people from twisting what is said. 

 

Posted (edited)

Catholics need to step out of the Counter-Reformation. Seriously. It's 2013 already!

Edited by Era Might
Posted

Jesus died for all. Having been crucified for our salvation, Christ has set the grace of repentance before the whole world.

 

jazzytakara
Posted

I found it a bit condescending, but those are good quotes that we would all do well to keep in mind.

 

I didn't like the tone of the article either, I just thought the quotes were interesting in the context of the controversy going on. Helps place things in a bit more context and not assume that our Pope is going against Church Teaching. 

Posted

Yeah, it looks to me like this article is another example of the secular media desperate to find controversy within the Church. It seems that many in the media are eager for anything they can present as a "The Pope changes Church Teaching on X!"  I doubt the quotes are being given in their full context, and it is clear the Pope was not issuing any kind of dogmatic statement, much less "changing" Church teaching on the need for Christ for salvation.

 

Last Sunday, our priest gave a homily on the doctrine of Ex Ecclesia Nulla Salus, in which he explained the teaching of Baptism of Desire, and made the point that invincible ignorance in itself does not give salvation.  "Ignorance is not a sacrament."  Those who have not had the Gospel preached to them may be saved through Baptism of Desire by a sincere and strong desire to live by the moral truth and always do what is right and avoid what is evil.  He also pointed out how such persons usually accept the Faith and Baptism when it is presented to them.  (He gave the example of Chief Peter Walking Bear, who was baptized in old age, and said throughout his life he never knowingly did evil, and always changed when it was made known to him that something he did was wrong).

 

I would seriously doubt that many modern Western atheists would qualify as truly invincibly ignorant, but is is not my place to judge individual souls.

I think we Catholics should spend less time speculating and bickering over what non-Catholics possibly might or might not be saved, and more time trying to being all men to Christ and His Church as Christ commanded

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

Wait... What would qualify as an Atheist being "invincibly ignorant"? Correct me if I'm wrong but this statement makes it appear as if most Atheists deep down know there's a God but choose to reject him. 

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

In Eastern Christian theology all men have been redeemed, because they have been given everlasting existence through the incarnation and the paschal mystery of Christ, but whether that eternal existence is blissful or painful is left to the free will choices of each man.

Posted

This was an interesting blog post I read yesterday about the Popes remarks. It's from an Orthodox perspective and it was interesting.

 

http://orthodoxyandheterodoxy.org/2013/05/23/did-pope-francis-say-everyone-will-be-saved-by-doing-good/

This is what I was getting at in my post, but Fr. Andrew said it better:

 

"Well, first, this is not universalism. It might appear to be so if you don’t know that there is a difference in traditional Christian theology between being saved and being redeemed. The redemption that Christ accomplished through the incarnation, cross and resurrection was for all of human nature, and so it is quite correct to say “The Lord has redeemed all of us, all of us, with the Blood of Christ.” Redemption is something that happens for human nature, which is why all will be resurrected in the end and why all are capable of doing good.

 
But that is not the same thing as saying that all will be saved, and it certainly isn’t saying that everyone will be saved by doing good. It’s not even saying that everyone will be redeemed by doing good. Salvation, in distinction from redemption, is centered on the individual person, not on the whole of human nature. Salvation is what the individual person does with the redemption that Christ has given to all, and it involves much more than simply doing good."
Posted

From Scott Hahn, via Facebook: 

 

Lots of people are criticizing Pope Francis' message earlier this week, as if he's deviating from the Church's teaching on the need to proclaim the good news... Contrary to what you may read in the media, please notice, nowhere does he even suggest - much less teach - that avowed atheists are saved. Instead, what he actually says is so obviously true and open to a perfectly fair and benign reading: 

 
1. We shouldn't be so critical of outsiders that we don't allow ourselves to see or acknowledge whatever good they do, or truth they affirm (even atheists).
 
2. Christ didn't die to save only catholics/christians, but everybody (even atheists). 
 
3. Since all are redeemed by Christ - potentially, at least - we should be looking for ways to build bridges with them in order to actualize that redemptive potential, by showing them that whatever truth and goodness they embrace comes from - and leads to - Christ.

 

 

dominicansoul
Posted

Pope Francis just reiterated what I've always believed.  Every person living on this earth shares in the Redemption of Jesus Christ, whether they know it or not.  It is they, not God, who denies them redemption when they do not accept it.

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

Pope Francis just reiterated what I've always believed.  Every person living on this earth shares in the Redemption of Jesus Christ, whether they know it or not.  It is they, not God, who denies them redemption when they do not accept it.

 

Still confused. The idea that someone could embrace ignorance while secretly knowing they'd be going to hell for it seems improbable in least 75% of the cases. Is Catholicism really SOOO obviously true that merely reading about Catholicism is enough to convince anyone about its validity? Is this the view we're taking? 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...