Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

i don't have that book, but i have several of his other books, and am always impressed by the breadth & quality of his writing. :) 

Posted

i don't have that book, but i have several of his other books, and am always impressed by the breadth & quality of his writing. :)

 

I want to read Witness to Hope one of these days.  

Posted

In Theology of the Church we were offered extra credit if we did a review of it (the prof hadn't read it and wanted opinions). I got partway through the book before I got distracted by other things. It wasn't bad, though,

Posted

In Theology of the Church we were offered extra credit if we did a review of it (the prof hadn't read it and wanted opinions). I got partway through the book before I got distracted by other things. It wasn't bad, though,

 

Who did you take? Turko? 

Posted (edited)

Who did you take? Turko? 

Yes. How'd you know?

 

 

 

 

Wait, you weren't in that class, were you?

Edited by Byzantine
Posted

No, I had Sirilla.  I just figured that since it couldn't have been Sirilla or Hildebrand (the only other teachers that I know taught the class) it had to be Turko.  It also sounds like something he would do.  

Posted

http://www.amazon.com/Evangelical-Catholicism-Reform-21st-Century-Church/dp/0465027687

 

 

Has anyone read this book, and if so what are your thoughts? I've met Mr. Weigel briefly, and really wasn't impressed. However, I've heard interesting and good things about this book from some people, so I'm looking for more imput.  Thoughts? 

 

 

 

I've read only one of his books, Letters to a Young Catholic and it was pretty awesome. Full of awesomeness stuff that I am constantly referring back to. Other than that, I haven't read anything else. If been thinking about picking up a copy of Evangelical Catholicism. 

Basilisa Marie
Posted (edited)

Oooh oooh I <3 Evangelical Catholicism.  And not just because I love shoving this essay in peoples faces. :|  It's written by one of my favorite professors like ten years ago before Evangelical Catholicism was cool.  

 

http://communio-icr.com/articles/PDF/portier31-1.pdf

 

 

Go read it. :)

 

In other news I haven't read the Weigel book. 

Edited by Basilisa Marie
Posted

Oooh oooh I <3 Evangelical Catholicism.  And not just because I love shoving this essay in peoples faces. :|  It's written by one of my favorite professors like ten years ago before Evangelical Catholicism was cool.  

 

http://communio-icr.com/articles/PDF/portier31-1.pdf

 

 

Go read it. :)

 

In other news I haven't read the Weigel book. 

 

Looks like a cool article thanks saving to Instapaper to read later.

Posted

No, I had Sirilla.  I just figured that since it couldn't have been Sirilla or Hildebrand (the only other teachers that I know taught the class) it had to be Turko.  It also sounds like something he would do.  

 

Ah. Okay. I've got Turko again for PBS I and really looking forward to it.

morostheos
Posted

I think I might have read that book a while ago, but I can't recall. Everything I've read that George Weigel has written has been very good though. 

Posted

I think I might have read that book a while ago, but I can't recall. Everything I've read that George Weigel has written has been very good though. 

I think if you had, you'd probably remember; it just came out this year.

Posted

Ah. Okay. I've got Turko again for PBS I and really looking forward to it.


I had him. Easy, and a pretty decent class. Hahn or Bergsma would be much better though.
Posted

Oooh oooh I <3 Evangelical Catholicism. And not just because I love shoving this essay in peoples faces. :| It's written by one of my favorite professors like ten years ago before Evangelical Catholicism was cool.

http://communio-icr.com/articles/PDF/portier31-1.pdf


Go read it. :)

In other news I haven't read the Weigel book.


Very, very cool. Thanks for the article!
morostheos
Posted

I think if you had, you'd probably remember; it just came out this year.

 

lol, oh, right. ;)

 

I think he has written a few essays in the past on evangelical Catholicism then? I remember reading something several years ago...

 

I think I must be thinking of his book The Courage to Be Catholic which John Allen has called the manifesto of evangelical Catholicism.

Posted

I had him. Easy, and a pretty decent class. Hahn or Bergsma would be much better though.

 

I enjoyed his Church a lot. Most of my friends are taking Bergsma, but by the time I could register, his classes had a combined waitlist of about 21 people, I think.

 

lol, oh, right. ;)

 

I think he has written a few essays in the past on evangelical Catholicism then? I remember reading something several years ago...

 

I think I must be thinking of his book The Courage to Be Catholic which John Allen has called the manifesto of evangelical Catholicism.

 

That's possible. I've heard The Courage to Be Catholic is pretty good.

Posted

I enjoyed his Church a lot. Most of my friends are taking Bergsma, but by the time I could register, his classes had a combined waitlist of about 21 people


Yeah that happens. I took his PBS II class this spring, I had to get in off the waiting list. Actually, he usually drops his waiting list. Meaning if people want to get in they need his signature.
Posted

I enjoyed his Church a lot. Most of my friends are taking Bergsma, but by the time I could register, his classes had a combined waitlist of about 21 people


Yeah that happens. I took his PBS II class this spring, I had to get in off the waiting list. Actually, he usually drops his waiting list. Meaning if people want to get in they need his signature.
Posted

I had him. Easy, and a pretty decent class. Hahn or Bergsma would be much better though.


I wouldnt recommend hahn. Very hard to follow due to all his tangents. Brilliant author but I was not impressed with him as a professor.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...