Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Friend Is Considering Abortion


Recommended Posts

photosynthesis
Posted

I'm on the leadership team for a local [secular] mom's group and just found out that one of our members is going through a really rough pregnancy.  It seems that the child has some kind of genetic disorder where the brain doesn't completely form and it's unlikely that she'll survive for very long outside the womb.  This mother is really heartbroken and her doctor has recommended that she 'terminate' the pregnancy.  

 

And we all know what that means.

 

Does anyone have any advice as to how to counsel her?  I'm not a doctor so I'm not sure if she'll listen to me when her doctor is telling her to terminate, even though it's disgraceful that this passes for 'healthcare.'

 

anyone here have any advice?

Posted

she will regret for the rest of her life not looking upon the face of her child. i would contact feminists for life and see if they have any resources to help. 

Posted

Don't have any advice but I'll pray for her.

Adoro te devote
Posted (edited)

Let's pretend her name is Shelly.  If it were me I would say... "Shelly, that kid's still fighting, don't give up on him/her!  They say that he/she wont likely live long outside of the womb?  Screw the doctors!  Your child, flesh of your flesh, blood of your blood, is still fighting right now no matter what those doctors are saying.  I don't know if he/she will make it, I don't know if he/she will grow into a healthy little guy/girl.  But I do know that you are his/her mum and he/she needs you to be strong and give him/her a shot at life.  Even if he/she only takes one breath after coming out, he/she'll have earned that breath, he/she'll have fought for that taste of air with all that was in his/her power.  Shelly I know it's heartbreaking.  But don't give him/her life only to take it away again before he/she's even had a chance."

Edited by Adoro te devote
organwerke
Posted

Well, I highly recommend her to see this video:

 

http://www.chiaracorbellapetrillo.it/tag/audiovideo/

 

 

I know this is an incredible story of a modern saint since this woman who went through a similar situation and decided not to practice abortion had then the most incredible disadventures and finally died for cancer at the age of 28 last year because she decided to protect the new life of her third child before she started to cure herself.

But this video explains why she refused to practice abortion with her first child who had the same diagnosis of your friend's child.

Also, I have 2 first hand experiences where the doctors had diagnosed the worst scenario (really similar to this one that you describe) and then actually the damages were much more limited and the children are born with some problems yes but very lighter than those who were diagnosed and now are doing well.

So, in one case as another I would say: abortion is ALWAYS the worst option!!

To Jesus Through Mary
Posted

That is such a hard situation. I will be praying for her. I do know of a couple places that specialize in this. This being such a complicated and extremely sensitive situation, you might want to reach out to those who know this well.  

 

 

http://www.katherineelizabethfoundation.org/

 

http://www.benotafraid.net/

 

Then after reading your post, I called the life office in NYC (I saw you were in Jersey, but I don't know how close to the City you are...) and Sr. Shirley Ann from the Sisters of Life recommended you called the Gianna Center (which is a pro-life obgyn/fertility office in NYC) because the Dr. there is really starting to get involved with this. So you might try that route as well... 

http://www.fertilitycare.org/giannacenter

 

 

Many prayers for you and her. 

VeniJesuAmorMi
Posted

I volunteer at a pregnancy care center. These Centers are blessings for girls and women facing difficult situations and decisions. The people that volunteer there truly want to be there for them and help them make the right choice. I would recommend finding one for her that she could contact and get the real help she needs while going through this painful time.

 

I'll be going to the Center on Thursday and I will be sure to tell the other advisors there with me about her and we'll pray for her and add her to the rosary intentions.

VeniJesuAmorMi
Posted

That is such a hard situation. I will be praying for her. I do know of a couple places that specialize in this. This being such a complicated and extremely sensitive situation, you might want to reach out to those who know this well.  

 

 

http://www.katherineelizabethfoundation.org/

 

http://www.benotafraid.net/

 

Then after reading your post, I called the life office in NYC (I saw you were in Jersey, but I don't know how close to the City you are...) and Sr. Shirley Ann from the Sisters of Life recommended you called the Gianna Center (which is a pro-life obgyn/fertility office in NYC) because the Dr. there is really starting to get involved with this. So you might try that route as well... 

http://www.fertilitycare.org/giannacenter

 

 

Many prayers for you and her. 

 

I'd really have to recommend this as well. :)

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

I'm on the leadership team for a local [secular] mom's group and just found out that one of our members is going through a really rough pregnancy.  It seems that the child has some kind of genetic disorder where the brain doesn't completely form and it's unlikely that she'll survive for very long outside the womb.  This mother is really heartbroken and her doctor has recommended that she 'terminate' the pregnancy.  

 

And we all know what that means.

 

Does anyone have any advice as to how to counsel her?  I'm not a doctor so I'm not sure if she'll listen to me when her doctor is telling her to terminate, even though it's disgraceful that this passes for 'healthcare.'

 

anyone here have any advice?

 

Maybe try convincing her to get a second opinion? A lot of doctors are idiots.

homeschoolmom
Posted

Wasn't there a thread a few years ago that contained a link to something like "Why I carried my baby to term" about just such a situation? Does anyone remember that?

Brother Adam
Posted

A lot of excellent advice in this thread. I will keep her in my prayers today.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

If I were in your shoes (and I was a couple years ago) I would just tell her that I know this is a horrible and heartbreaking thing to face, but if I were in her shoes I wouldn't terminate, I would carry the pregnancy to term so I could hold my baby for as long as we had together. So I could look on her face, and she would know the love of her mother, even if only for a very short period of time. It may not convince her (it didn't convince the woman I knew, I was the ONLY one saying it, and I just think it needs to be said), but it can't hurt.

OnlySunshine
Posted (edited)

I think I would probably bring up the story of Tim Tebow, whose mother was told that he would likely not survive outside the womb and she should terminate because of placental abruption and they expected a stillbirth.  Not only did he survive but he has done terrific things for UF football and promoting Christianity in sports!  Think what would have happened if he was aborted because of a wrongful diagnosis?

 

Now, her child might not have the same outcome, unfortunately, but doctors are not always right.  What if the child were to survive and live a long life?  I'd also show her this incredible story from the Sisters of Life:

 

http://www.sistersoflife.org/vocation-story-two

 

If everything else fails, contact the Sisters of Life and give them her phone number.  Maybe they can do something to help.

Edited by MaterMisericordiae
FutureCarmeliteClaire
Posted

Many, many prayers.

Archaeology cat
Posted

Praying

ToJesusMyHeart
Posted

I'm on the leadership team for a local [secular] mom's group and just found out that one of our members is going through a really rough pregnancy.  It seems that the child has some kind of genetic disorder where the brain doesn't completely form and it's unlikely that she'll survive for very long outside the womb.  This mother is really heartbroken and her doctor has recommended that she 'terminate' the pregnancy.  

 

anyone here have any advice?

 

This is a mother who had the same (or a very similar) pre-natal diagnosis. 

 

"....at an 18-week ultrasound, they discovered that the baby Micah was carrying had a condition called anencephaly. This meant that their daughter had not developed a major portion of her brain, skull and scalp. Doctors said she would not survive outside of the womb. 

Micah's doctor immediately suggested abortion. And though Micah and Kyle refused at first, Micah confessed that for a week following the diagnosis, abortion actually seemed like the more attractive option. She feared that it would be more painful to carry the child to term and deliver a stillborn than to simply "terminate the pregnancy" at 18 weeks.  "I was carrying a baby that would more than likely not even be born alive. My daughter couldn’t survive outside of the safe haven I had created for her,” she said. “It took months before I came to terms with my decision to carry. I was constantly faced with questions. Why? How?"

 

Yet Micah began to understand the answers to these painful and difficult questions. "Why? Because no matter what, she was my daughter. There was a life inside of me and I couldn’t just take that away from her. She didn’t choose to have this happen to her, so how could I choose to end her life to save myself from more heartache? “How? Just go on with every day life! The bottom line was simple. She was alive she had a life and it was my job as a mother to give her the best life she could possibly have."

 

During her pregnancy, Micah was astounded at the insensitivity of people she encountered. "Many people were so rude about the idea of carrying a baby that wasn’t meant to live outside the womb. The amounts of comments I got like, 'why don’t you just abort?' People seemed to think by aborting it would be easier. It would somehow just go away, like it never happened." 

But Micah knew that carrying her baby was the only option she had. 

Ambra-240x361.jpg
 

"I explained to them, 'I would rather endure the heartache that is surely to come if I carry her because at least I can give her a fighting chance.'" 

 

Micah and Kyle had three and a half hours with their daughter. They were astonished to discover Ambra's beautiful and familiar features. 

 

"Throughout my pregnancy it was important for me to not mourn her. She was still alive and I wasn’t going to mourn her until she was gone." 

 

"I got to meet my daughter, to hold and kiss her. I couldn’t imagine not being able to share those few hours with her."

 

Full article: http://www.lifesitenews.com/news/pregnant-at-17-with-a-baby-doomed-to-die-at-birth-but-she-chose-life

 

Prayers most of all. 

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)


I'm on the leadership team for a local [secular] mom's group and just found out that one of our members is going through a really rough pregnancy.  It seems that the child has some kind of genetic disorder where the brain doesn't completely form and it's unlikely that she'll survive for very long outside the womb.  This mother is really heartbroken and her doctor has recommended that she 'terminate' the pregnancy.  

 

And we all know what that means.

 

Does anyone have any advice as to how to counsel her?  I'm not a doctor so I'm not sure if she'll listen to me when her doctor is telling her to terminate, even though it's disgraceful that this passes for 'healthcare.'

 

anyone here have any advice?

 

that's so sad :(

 

I found this article very moving. http://www.lifesitenews.com/meet-celeste-born-at-22-weeks-she-only-lived-3-hours-but-her-life-changed-t.html

Just how the family showed so much love to the baby though she only lived 3 hours.

 

If someone were in this situation, I'd maybe talk to them about how even if a baby only lives a short time, if that time is filled with love, that is what the family would remember. They would remember how they just showed love to this baby, like Celeste... I'd maybe share the article with them too. It's also a way to properly say goodbye. Importantly if we think about the baby: how at least their life, though brief, would be one of love, and being held by their mother and father - not being killed in the womb :(

 

I find it really sad how there's such a mentality about this that the person should abort. How is killing the baby a solution? :( and it's making their last moments into moments of extreme pain, rather than love. It's just so heartbreaking :(

Edited by MarysLittleFlower

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...