Slappo Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 http://www.foxnews.com/leisure/2013/06/11/nyc-restaurant-bans-tipping-opts-instead-to-pay-workers-set-wage-and-increase/ That's right! One NYC restaurant has made the move to increase all prices by 15% and fully compensate wait staff through their salary. I'd love to see this done universally. If a waiter has a bad day and isn't treating customers nicely, he'll get complaints about him to management. Management could then make employment and pay decisions based on overall performance of the waiter. He won't get his wages cut 50% for a day because he gave horrible service, but if it happens several times he may get passed up for that pay increase.
Chestertonian Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 http://www.foxnews.com/leisure/2013/06/11/nyc-restaurant-bans-tipping-opts-instead-to-pay-workers-set-wage-and-increase/ That's right! One NYC restaurant has made the move to increase all prices by 15% and fully compensate wait staff through their salary. I'd love to see this done universally. If a waiter has a bad day and isn't treating customers nicely, he'll get complaints about him to management. Management could then make employment and pay decisions based on overall performance of the waiter. He won't get his wages cut 50% for a day because he gave horrible service, but if it happens several times he may get passed up for that pay increase. So they get 15% more per hour? So if they were making $10 an hour, they'll now be making $11.50 an hour? If that's the case, that equals an extra $12 per shift. Considering many servers make upwards of $100 a day in tips, I'm not sure why a server would opt to work there.
Ice_nine Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 Will servers end up with more or less money? Will that affect people who will take nights and weekends (normally those pay out higher because they're busier but if you're getting the same for a monday afternoon, then you wouldn't wanna work saturday night you know?)
Slappo Posted June 12, 2013 Author Posted June 12, 2013 So they get 15% more per hour? So if they were making $10 an hour, they'll now be making $11.50 an hour? If that's the case, that equals an extra $12 per shift. Considering many servers make upwards of $100 a day in tips, I'm not sure why a server would opt to work there. No no no... not 15% wage increases and no tips... 15% increase on all their prices. The article and business didn't disclose how much the wages of the wait staff changed, only that the wait staff are now fully compensated by the restaurant. Basically if you have what would normally be a $100 bill, it is now $115 but you don't leave a tip. The wait staff are paid living wages by the business. I would imagine a large percentage of that 15% increase is going towards salaries and benefits.
Chestertonian Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 No no no... not 15% wage increases and no tips... 15% increase on all their prices. The article and business didn't disclose how much the wages of the wait staff changed, only that the wait staff are now fully compensated by the restaurant. Basically if you have what would normally be a $100 bill, it is now $115 but you don't leave a tip. The wait staff are paid living wages by the business. I would imagine a large percentage of that 15% increase is going towards salaries and benefits. 10/4
Brother Adam Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 Which means if you are a really good waiter or waitress you make less. Many customers routinely leave 20-30% tips. I left a 25% tip on a bill tonight because our waitress was attentive to our needs and did a great job. I never leave less than 15%. If you can't leave that much, don't dine out.
Nihil Obstat Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 So, your new favourite restaurant in the country, Slappo? ;)
Slappo Posted June 12, 2013 Author Posted June 12, 2013 Which means if you are a really good waiter or waitress you make less. Many customers routinely leave 20-30% tips. I left a 25% tip on a bill tonight because our waitress was attentive to our needs and did a great job. I never leave less than 15%. If you can't leave that much, don't dine out. You're assuming that many really good waiters or waitresses don't get stiffed though too. One customer leaves awesome 30% tip, next customer stiffs you. You're also assuming that the business doesn't take into account the expertise of the waiter or waitress when determining pay rates...
Brother Adam Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 You're assuming that many really good waiters or waitresses don't get stiffed though too. One customer leaves amesome 30% tip, next customer stiffs you. You're also assuming that the business doesn't take into account the expertise of the waiter or waitress when determining pay rates... There are pros and cons to mandatory tipping which many places already do for tables of 8 or more. Which is interesting because I have never left a tip larger than the automatic 15 or 18% on those larger parties.
Papist Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 I never understood why the tip is supposed to be a % of your bill? What the difference of waiter serving you a $8 chopped steak vs $35 filet mignon?
CatholicCid Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 While it may be slightly off-putting for patrons to pay a little more up front and not leave a tip behind, Rosenberg says he has not seen any change in the volume of customers. He says the move to a no tipping system will help foster stability in his workforce, who receive vacation time and paid sick leave. I like this. It's approaching the problem head on, which is an underpaid wait staff. The customer should not be expected to ensure that the wait staff is given a just wage via tipping. The restaurant should be paying a just wage to begin with. It seems this restaurant is attempting to do that. Good job!
CatholicCid Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 While it may be slightly off-putting for patrons to pay a little more up front and not leave a tip behind, Rosenberg says he has not seen any change in the volume of customers. He says the move to a no tipping system will help foster stability in his workforce, who receive vacation time and paid sick leave. I like this. It's approaching the problem head on, which is an underpaid wait staff. The customer should not be expected to ensure that the wait staff is given a just wage via tipping. The restaurant should be paying a just wage to begin with. It seems this restaurant is attempting to do that. Good job!
brianthephysicist Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 I never understood why the tip is supposed to be a % of your bill? What the difference of waiter serving you a $8 chopped steak vs $35 filet mignon? I agree. There's a restaurant near my old college that does 99cent unlimited pancakes. My buddies and I would go there and get water to drink (because it is free) so a bill for four of us would come to a little over $4 after tax. We figured a percentage based tip (typically ~$1) wasn't fair because he/she worked just as hard for our table as he/she did for the tables around us with a significantly higher bill so we always ended up leaving well over 100% tip. I like this. It's approaching the problem head on, which is an underpaid wait staff. The customer should not be expected to ensure that the wait staff is given a just wage via tipping. The restaurant should be paying a just wage to begin with. It seems this restaurant is attempting to do that. Good job! I like it too. It might not be a perfect solution, but they've seen a problem with the current system and are trying to fix it. Maybe they're right or maybe they're wrong, but I think trying out novel ideas like this is the only way we're going to figure out the right solution.
Papist Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 I agree. There's a restaurant near my old college that does 99cent unlimited pancakes. My buddies and I would go there and get water to drink (because it is free) so a bill for four of us would come to a little over $4 after tax. We figured a percentage based tip (typically ~$1) wasn't fair because he/she worked just as hard for our table as he/she did for the tables around us with a significantly higher bill so we always ended up leaving well over 100% tip. I like it too. It might not be a perfect solution, but they've seen a problem with the current system and are trying to fix it. Maybe they're right or maybe they're wrong, but I think trying out novel ideas like this is the only way we're going to figure out the right solution. Tip needs to reflect price without discounts of any kind. For example, if wife and I use a buy entree get one free coupon. The tip needs to reflect what the cost would be for two entrees.
CrossCuT Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 I never understood why the tip is supposed to be a % of your bill? What the difference of waiter serving you a $8 chopped steak vs $35 filet mignon? Yeah! Why does one waiter/waitress get tipped less for doing the exact same thing? Just because the dish they are carrying is more expensive? In all reality is the same type of work. Take orders, understand menu, deliver food, check on customers etc. I think its great that the restaurant is taking more care of their employees and not leaving it up to the customers in the sense that the waiter/waitress might NOT get tipped.
Papist Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 Yeah! Why does one waiter/waitress get tipped less for doing the exact same thing? Just because the dish they are carrying is more expensive? In all reality is the same type of work. Take orders, understand menu, deliver food, check on customers etc. I think its great that the restaurant is taking more care of their employees and not leaving it up to the customers in the sense that the waiter/waitress might NOT get tipped. Also, the waiter serving chopped steak my deserve a better tip than his coworker serving the filet at the next table...yet gets a smaller tip only b/c people at his table didn't buy expensive meal.
CrossCuT Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 When I first read the thread title I thought it said "Tripping Banned" and I was like .... well thats interesting.
Aloysius Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 given my cynical nature, I'm going to say right here that I very much doubt that the entire 15% increase will go to server wages... otherwise they'd make it a 15% automatic gratuity tipped out to the whole wait staff evenly. sounds to me like a tricky way for the restaurant itself to get a bit of the money that used to go to the wait staff. I could be wrong, but if you think about it it would seem that increasing prices by 15% and then disconnecting what servers get paid from what the sales are is going to result in the restaurant ending up with more of the money out of what is being paid by the customer than they used to get compared to how much servers used to get. whatever, I'm sure there are pros and cons. I don't really understand the problem people have with the tipping obligation as part of servers' wages, is it really that big of a deal for you to take on that responsibility when you choose to utilize the luxury of going out and getting cooked for and served? but whatever, I guess if a restaurant wants to do it that way instead then that's their choice... I presume voluntarily adding an extra gratitude exceptionally on top is still possible. I do like not having to tip in bars in Europe, I guess, but tipping in restaurants seems like a perfectly reasonable thing to consider when you're receiving food service, how are people so troubled by it?
KnightofChrist Posted June 12, 2013 Posted June 12, 2013 given my cynical nature, I'm going to say right here that I very much doubt that the entire 15% increase will go to server wages... otherwise they'd make it a 15% automatic gratuity tipped out to the whole wait staff evenly. sounds to me like a tricky way for the restaurant itself to get a bit of the money that used to go to the wait staff. I could be wrong, but if you think about it it would seem that increasing prices by 15% and then disconnecting what servers get paid from what the sales are is going to result in the restaurant ending up with more of the money out of what is being paid by the customer than they used to get compared to how much servers used to get. whatever, I'm sure there are pros and cons. I thought about the same thing. That not all of the 15% would go directly to paying the servers. But rather a percentage of the increase would go to cover the cost of bumping the servers up (likely) the min. wage in NYC. The rest would go to profit or other costs. Maybe not though, but likely in a cynical kind of way.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now