Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I think we PMers should divvy up the list and answer them all, then pin them at the top of one of the phorums. Or put them in the Defense of the Faith database. People have said we used to have a phorum just for converts. This could be enlightening for a lot of newcomers. And it might lead to some interesting discussion on some of the questions, cuz I think we'd go a lot deeper than my pastor is expecting the 8th-graders to.

Posted

:cry:

Yeah...that's how I felt too.  "Uh well I would, and technically if you're Catholic, you should..."

truthfinder
Posted

Not for confirmation, but for a grade of religious ed, we had a list very similar in nature to this. Everyone learnt it and it was pounded into us. Guess what? Next year in religious ed, a new teacher was going over some of the same information and we not only remembered but were able to point out if she had made a mistake. It was not just regurgitation either, we could explain ourselves.  10 years later, I still remember most of what I learnt ( well, most of the 10 plagues, but definitely the 10 Commandments).

 

It is very good to see that someone is taking the sacrament seriously. 

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Yeah, I'd tweak a few questions too, but I really liked how they encouraged the kids to help each other and to get help with it, and that they'd discuss the questions at the end of every session.  Most of the questions are pretty reasonable, I think.  I know here in the Seattle Archdiocese the confirmation age is 16 (usually junior year of high school), so a detailed list like the one above is more than appropriate for high schoolers. 

franciscanheart
Posted

I was confirmed in 8th grade at age 14. Some of my friends were only 13.

Posted

I could seriously answer just about every question. I think these are common questions about our catholic faith.

TheLordsSouljah
Posted

I was confirmed in 8th grade at age 14. Some of my friends were only 13.

Wait..... is 14 the normal age in the US? I had mine at 11....hmm...

PhuturePriest
Posted

I was confirmed in 8th grade at age 14. Some of my friends were only 13.

 

I was eleven. Win.

Posted

Good for this pastor!

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I think I was 13. Maybe 12.

Posted

I was a senior in high school and 18, which was normal at our parish.

Posted

8th grade for me...That list is to much...I'm sure some kids wouldn't get confirmed because of it...But mabey that's the
point...

Posted

I have run into many young "confirmed" Catholics who know more about Hinduism than Catholicism. It's pretty pathetic really. But hey, large numbers of Catholics in the SF Bay Area have embraced all sorts of heresies (Christological, moral, etc.), so what should I expect from kids who went through CCD or Faith Formation programs at parishes that have been overrun by liturgical nonsense and theological error.

jazzytakara
Posted

It seems to me that they are merely trying to ensure that candidates understand the basics of Catholicism, understand some theology, understand the basics of Church History, and know what goes on within the parish and the diocese as a whole. All of this will be covered in RCIA/Confirmation, most of which would be covered from attending church, practicing the faith, etc. Also the questions on the parish and diocese are to help those being tested to know when mass and reconciliation are being held, and who the appropriate authorities are within the parish and diocese. At the end of the day if anyone can answer all or most of these questions, then they have a pretty decent understanding and knowledge of their faith. Reading these questions is making me want to look into the answers to the questions I don't want know the answers too. 

Posted

I take my comment back...Mabey its not to much...

Posted (edited)

You can lead a horse to water, but you can't force him to drink.

 

Agree!

Gave the list to my sister, she answered just about all corectly. She was educated by the sisters, she is older than me, brought up under the "old" system. She has not been to Mass for at least 10 years. When I celebrated 25 years of priesthood, none of my family (parents are deceased), attended the Mass. :unsure:

Edited by cappie
Anastasia13
Posted

I have run into many young "confirmed" Catholics who know more about Hinduism than Catholicism. It's pretty pathetic really. But hey, large numbers of Catholics in the SF Bay Area have embraced all sorts of heresies (Christological, moral, etc.), so what should I expect from kids who went through CCD or Faith Formation programs at parishes that have been overrun by liturgical nonsense and theological error.

 

And that is how we end up having ex-Catholics who are way messed up spiritually and don't even know it.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...