PhuturePriest Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 I don't intend for this to be a debate. It's an honest question. Is there anything in the rubrics or somewhere else of equal importance that says you should not clap with the music during Mass? I personally have a huge problem with it, but I don't know if that's me being a traditionalist or if there is an actual liturgical problem with it.
Nihil Obstat Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 No, there is no rubric which indicates that it is an acceptable addition to the Mass.
cmaD2006 Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 And I don't think there is something specifically that says you *can't* clap with the Music in Mass.
PhuturePriest Posted June 15, 2013 Author Posted June 15, 2013 No, there is no rubric which indicates that it is an acceptable addition to the Mass. Have any Popes or Saints commented on it?
ToJesusMyHeart Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 And I don't think there is something specifically that says you *can't* clap with the Music in Mass. Well, except common sense.
Basilisa Marie Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 (edited) Not that I know of. Some people would be against clapping because it's not in the rubrics and may not foster due reverence. Others would be for it because there's nothing prohibiting it and it can be justified under the "inculturation" provision in Vatican II documents. I think most people would agree that clapping isn't appropriate in all (musical) situations, and that clapping *with* music is different from clapping after mass or the homily. So ultimately I think it's something that's up to a bishop's or priest's discretion. Edited June 15, 2013 by Basilisa Marie
Chestertonian Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 (edited) Edited June 15, 2013 by Chestertonian
RCIA ~ Class of 09 Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 Ugh, I hate that so bad. Uh, that's an understatement....You look like you're going to pop a blood vessel in your forehead whenever we go to a Parish that does it :unsure:
Nihil Obstat Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 Have any Popes or Saints commented on it? Probably not, because it would have been absolutely foreign to the Liturgy, and rightly so, until our weird modern era.
Noel's angel Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 Rubrics aren't really there to list all the things we shouldn't do/have at Mass. If it's not in, it's out. So whilst I don't believe it says anywhere: "No clapping along with the hymns," it does not give an option FOR clapping along...therefore....don't clap. It doesn't say anywhere that we can't have someone riding an elephant up during the offertory procession, but we wouldn't do that.
Quid Est Veritas? Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 If there's no provision for it, then I think it's logical to conclude that it shouldn't be done. And as a hardline Gregorian chant lover, I have issues with music that lends itself to clapping along anyway. :P
mysisterisalittlesister Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 I don't see anything wrong with clapping at something like a Stubenville Youth Conference or a Catholic camp. But yeah, clapping to regular church hymns is just weird.
Amppax Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 I don't see anything wrong with clapping at something like a Stubenville Youth Conference or a Catholic camp. But yeah, clapping to regular church hymns is just weird. The question then arises, is a Holy Mass at a youth conference or something similar son Ina way that is in keeping with the rubrics? I'm not saying it isn't, I'm actually trying to sort through all of this myself.
Guest Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 The Parish I go to in Vegas the Priest sometimes anounces who the choir is at the end of Mass and everyone claps. I always thought it was weird. I know its not what you're talking about in this thread but this is the first Catholic Church I have experienced this in. Really nice Church though and good Priest.
Annie12 Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 Even if it is allowed if people get weirded out by it, then it is interfering with their ability to properly worship God. I'm not a fan of it myself...
ContemporaryCaflicCrusader Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 At my parish they clap for the band after mass. I refuse too, in fact it was one of my many reasons I stated for leaving the band.
ToJesusMyHeart Posted June 15, 2013 Posted June 15, 2013 At my parish they clap for the band after mass. I refuse to, in fact it was one of my many reasons I stated for leaving the band. You rock. Good for you!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now