Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Confession Question


Recommended Posts

Poorly Catechized Convert
Posted

I'll be going to confession in a couple of days and will be confessing some bad things I thought about the priest's religious order. The idea of actually stating it was the Jesuits terrifies me. I don't want to offend the priest. In the confessional, am I allowed to just say "a religious order" or should I actually state which one? I don't want to invalidate my confession by concealing information, that should be disclosed.

 

Posted

I don't think you need to worry about that. Just confess to the best of your ability, and it'll be alright. :)

Posted (edited)

I also saw your question on the other board, and I don't think you committed the sin of apostasy. Far from it. You had real doubts, tested that thought to see if it was valid or not without actually acting on it, and rejected it. Everyone experiences doubts, it's not a sin.

Edited by arfink
Nihil Obstat
Posted

If the fact that it was Jesuits as opposed to, say, Dominicans or Benedictines makes the sin graver, then perhaps it should be mentioned. But if it does not really affect the nature of the sin (and I am leaning towards thinking it probably does not), it is probably not necessary to be quite so specific. Unless the priest asks, in which case do not hide it.

 

As I understand it, most priests prefer that your confession is concise, rather than getting bogged down in little details.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

More importantly, good luck when you get there. :) Pray for strength to make a good confession, and everything will be fine. You probably will not be saying anything that the priest has not heard hundreds of times before. And the forgiveness of our Lord is mind-boggling.

Posted

You don't have to state what religious order. One day a person spoke to me (out of confession) and said they didn't like the priest who was saying Mass in their parish. I asked who and they said they did not want to say. I said it doesn't matter as priests have a sense of humor, so they said it's you Father :lol4:

Poorly Catechized Convert
Posted

Thanks for the replies. That's a relief; I don't know the priest real well and I don't know how he would react.

 

 

I also saw your question on the other board, and I don't think you committed the sin of apostasy. Far from it. You had real doubts, tested that thought to see if it was valid or not without actually acting on it, and rejected it. Everyone experiences doubts, it's not a sin.

 

You don't have to state what religious order. One day a person spoke to me (out of confession) and said they didn't like the priest who was saying Mass in their parish. I asked who and they said they did not want to say. I said it doesn't matter as priests have a sense of humor, so they said it's you Father :lol4:

 

Thanks, both of you for answering my question on the other thread. I guess I felt guilt primarily because I was enjoying reading from non-Christians who were working against the Church. Well just feeling a pull away from the Church bothers me. It's good to know I don't have to worry about excommunication and that I'll be able move past it.

 

 

Posted

Welcome to Phatmass! smiley-greet013.gif

seashorerock
Posted

:hehe2:

 

I'm tempted to turn this into a thread making fun of Jesuits.  Us Franciscans have some pretty good jokes.  :bounce:

 

 

 

A Franciscan and a Jesuit found it difficult to pray without a cigarette. They sought permission from their superiors to smoke. The Franciscan came back downcast. “I asked if I could smoke while I prayed, but he said ‘no.’” The Jesuit smiled. “I asked if I could pray while I smoked." He replied: “Of course.’”

 

 

 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

:hehe2:

 

I'm tempted to turn this into a thread making fun of Jesuits.  Us Franciscans have some pretty good jokes.  :bounce:

Yeah... I was going to say, he has probably heard every knock against Jesuits in the book. :|

Posted

You don't have to state what religious order. One day a person spoke to me (out of confession) and said they didn't like the priest who was saying Mass in their parish. I asked who and they said they did not want to say. I said it doesn't matter as priests have a sense of humor, so they said it's you Father :lol4:

 

:hehe: father, I heart you! :hehe: 

Chestertonian
Posted

Jesuits>Dominicans . Just so you know.

Poorly Catechized Convert
Posted

I need to throw in another question. Tomorrow after Mass I was supposed to ask the priest for a dispensation to miss Mass, due to vacation. I'm 18, but I'm going with my parents, in their car, and have been told that I cannot use their car to go to Mass during our trip. Me trying to use public transportation would only cause a large argument. Since they decided to leave tomorrow before I can go to Mass, the only time I'll have contact with the priest will be in the confessional. Would it be proper, if after I confessed my sins, but before absolution, I mentioned my situation and asked if I could receive a dispensation for this week and possibly next? I don't like the idea of doing this inside to confessional, but it will be my only option. Also, I'd like to note that this priest isn't my pastor, but he is standing in for him since he is away. Due to me not attending Mass, often, at my territorial parish because of many issues, I had forgotten about this. As a result, when I tried to contact him I was told that he would be unavailable for a month. So am I even able to validly receive a dispensation from this priest?

Posted

You don't need a dispensation because it's beyond your control. However if you think you need it then ask the priest, but I repeat you are in good conscience.

ContemporaryCaflicCrusader
Posted

In confession you're suppose to use nouns, no proper nouns.  So you could say, I detracted such and such a religious order, or, I dunno, punched so and so in the face or what have you.  The toughest ones are in a small fam especially, when you are face to face with a familiar confessor.  My sibling, well guess what, he was the priest at my sister's wedding, my one and only sibling, did the marital classes, Catholic wedding around here are almost unheard of, so the anonymity just went out the door.  And parents are, well, parents.  Mom and Dad if you are so fortunate are difficult not to refer to as Mom and Dad.  I believe my advice is good feel free to critique if you can properly.  :-P

Poorly Catechized Convert
Posted

So I went to confession today and I confessed a sin that I had confessed previously. The reason I did this was that I remembered new information that I thought may change the gravity. I couldn't remember if I had provided this information so I thought it would be good to bring up. Well instead of saying all of that I just called it a sin that I had forgot to confess. When I first remembered this sin a few days ago I had planned to mention the extra information, but by today it was in my mind as a forgotten sin. Does this count as a lie, that would invalidate my confession?

Also, the priest gave me advice in regards to scruples. Well by investigating whether or not I invalidated my confession I violated this advice. I did do my penance though. So by doing this did I commit a mortal sin?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

So I went to confession today and I confessed a sin that I had confessed previously. The reason I did this was that I remembered new information that I thought may change the gravity. I couldn't remember if I had provided this information so I thought it would be good to bring up. Well instead of saying all of that I just called it a sin that I had forgot to confess. When I first remembered this sin a few days ago I had planned to mention the extra information, but by today it was in my mind as a forgotten sin. Does this count as a lie, that would invalidate my confession?

Also, the priest gave me advice in regards to scruples. Well by investigating whether or not I invalidated my confession I violated this advice. I did do my penance though. So by doing this did I commit a mortal sin?

First off, relax. :smile3: Your confession was valid.

 

If you remember new information about a sin, it is ok to bring it back to confession, if it makes you feel better about it. If you sincerely forgot the first time, it was forgiven anyway. But if it is better for your conscience, it is fine.

That said, it sounds like your confessor thinks you are suffering from scupulosity, and based on this post he is probably correct. :P That does not mean it is a sin for you to struggle with it. He is giving you advice that will, over time, make things better in this respect. Work at following his advice, work at controlling your scrupulosity, and above all trust in the grace of the sacrament, because you are forgiven. Your intentions, presumably, have been pure, and as long as they are, you are fine.

Poorly Catechized Convert
Posted

Thanks. For the first part I guess the primary problem was that I felt that by calling it a forgotten son I was being untruthful. For the second part I may have mostly felt bad. This was more first time confessing to this priest and he handled my scrupulousity better than any other priest. I did think that violating advice may be so.similar to not doing the penance. My mind was jumping back and forth between thinking it would be mortal sin and thinking it wasn't. Sadly by the time I posted I had the thought that if it was a mortal sin I was already guilty, but if it wasn't I needed to know so that I'd stop worrying.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...