HisChildForever Posted June 21, 2013 Posted June 21, 2013 I read Pride and Prejudice about three years ago. The beginning was a bit slow and dry at times but the latter portion of the novel really had me hooked. Anyway, the other night I bought Sense and Sensibility, Persuasion, and Emma. It was a buy 2, get 1 free deal for the classics - so I spent like ten bucks for the three of them. I know it's not a series lol, but which should I read first? I'm also interested in hearing thoughts, opinions, reviews, things you didn't like about a particular novel or her writing style, etc. Thanks!
Era Might Posted June 21, 2013 Posted June 21, 2013 (edited) I never never never would have read Jane Austen. I don't like women writers, number one, and I just assumed she was chick lit. But I took a class on 19th Century British novels when I was in college and had to read Pride & Prejudice and Sense & Sensibility. Great stuff, really entertaining. I also read Jane Eyre, a great novel, by another female writer. They seem like "chick lit" on the surface, but they're just great books, as opposed to being "Look at me I'm a woman and I'm writing about women stuff," which wouldn't have interested me at all. This post probably sounds more sexist than it should.... :flex2: Edited June 21, 2013 by Era Might
CrossCuT Posted June 21, 2013 Posted June 21, 2013 PERSUASION I like that one equal if not more than Pride & Prejudice. Sense & Sensibility is really good too. Emma is good too although you will likely HATE Emma in the beginning. The only two that I really didnt like that much was Mansfield Park and Northanger Abbey. ALTHOUGH!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My favorite Jane Austen hunk is from Northeranger Abbey. Henry Tilney forever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
HisChildForever Posted June 21, 2013 Author Posted June 21, 2013 I don't like women writers, number one, Why?
Era Might Posted June 21, 2013 Posted June 21, 2013 Why? Just don't. There are exceptions of course, I like Austen, Flannery O'Connor, Marianne Moore. Maybe I relate more to what men have to say because I am one.
Not The Philosopher Posted June 21, 2013 Posted June 21, 2013 Emma is one of my favourite novels. Austen is, I think, one of the great moral/psychological realists. I come out of her books feeling I know a little bit more about people (including myself).
Luigi Posted June 21, 2013 Posted June 21, 2013 1. Read Sense and Sensibility first. It's another comparison & contrast novel, like Pride and Prejudice and focuses on the relationship between sisters (as well as beaux). One sister represents a more intellectual approach to life and the other is more self-indulgent of her own whims; she suffers for her lack of sense, although the sensible one also suffers from doing the right thing. 2. Then read Emma. Like the women in Pride and Prejudice and in Sense and Sensibility, Emma is young; her heart is in the right place, but she doesn't have much consideration for people. In the course of the novel, she learns to be less judgmental & manipulative and more supportive. 3. Then read Persuasion. The heroine is still a single woman, but she's older - almost beyond marriageable age. She seems to be somewhat weak because she is very dutiful and puts others' needs before her own, but she's actually quite strong and knows her own mind. I consider Persuasion to be Austen's most "mature" novel. 4. I wasn't crazy about Northanger Abbey, but the heroine is interesting because she's a relatively poor girl who gets thrust into a higher social circle and has to figure out how things are done and where she fits in. 5. Mansfield Park is my favorite Austen novel, but largely because the heroine (Fanny) reminds me of someone I used to know. Again, she's a poor girl thrust into an upper level of society, she has to figure out how things are done and where she fits in, and although she is "the least of the least" in the household she's also the only one who has any real moral compass. Keep in mind, though, that when I read literature, I read primarily for language. And I love Austen's language. Pride and Prejudice has one of the greatest opening sentences in the English language, but all of her novels open with a good sentence. Her language is also quite subtle, so modern readers often miss her nuances - tongue-in-cheek humor, polite sarcasm, and understatement. If you're not that interested in the language, your mileage may vary. But she's also got the character development (in the heroines, at least) and the plot development. Some people complain of her, "I don't actually care who the girl marries." In the end, the heroine does usually marry the man of her dreams, but that's mostly a payoff for acting morally throughout the book - those who act immorally come to unhappy ends. Austen had few other happy endings except 'the good marriage' available to her in those days (although she herself never married).
Basilisa Marie Posted June 21, 2013 Posted June 21, 2013 Just don't. There are exceptions of course, I like Austen, Flannery O'Connor, Marianne Moore. Maybe I relate more to what men have to say because I am one. Then don't say you don't like women writers. That's sexist. Say you don't like chick lit. :)
Era Might Posted June 21, 2013 Posted June 21, 2013 Then don't say you don't like women writers. That's sexist. Say you don't like chick lit. :) Well, I don't think that's accurate, because I think writers have different preoccupations. I don't think it's accidental that I don't like women writers. I don't think being a writer is genderless. That's not a bad thing, I just don't relate to the style of many women writers, particularly contemporary women writers whose writing is a sort of extension of academic feminism.
Basilisa Marie Posted June 21, 2013 Posted June 21, 2013 Well, I don't think that's accurate, because I think writers have different preoccupations. I don't think it's accidental that I don't like women writers. I don't think being a writer is genderless. That's not a bad thing, I just don't relate to the style of many women writers, particularly contemporary women writers whose writing is a sort of extension of academic feminism. If you didn't like women writers, you wouldn't like Austen, O'Connor, Charlotte Bronte (Jane Eyre author) or Moore. You don't like academic feminism or Chick Lit. But to unilaterally dismiss female authors is sexist. And just not true. Jane Austen writes about women. Charlotte Bronte writes about women. O'Connor writes about all kinds of people. You can't just say you don't like women writers, but then make exceptions whenever you find one you do like. :)
Era Might Posted June 21, 2013 Posted June 21, 2013 (edited) If you didn't like women writers, you wouldn't like Austen, O'Connor, Charlotte Bronte (Jane Eyre author) or Moore. You don't like academic feminism or Chick Lit. But to unilaterally dismiss female authors is sexist. And just not true. Jane Austen writes about women. Charlotte Bronte writes about women. O'Connor writes about all kinds of people. You can't just say you don't like women writers, but then make exceptions whenever you find one you do like. :) Sure I can. :) I don't dismiss them, just saying I don't like them. Doesn't mean there aren't great women writers. Emily Dickinson is another great woman writer. But if I am sitting down to read a book, and I have a choice between a man and a woman author, I will pick the man. I will always pick Shakespeare over Sappho, Dickens over Austen, Hawthorne over Stowe. Edited June 21, 2013 by Era Might
Basilisa Marie Posted June 21, 2013 Posted June 21, 2013 Sure I can. :) I don't dismiss them, just saying I don't like them. Doesn't mean there aren't great women writers. Emily Dickinson is another great woman writer. But if I am sitting down to read a book, and I have a choice between a man and a woman author, I will pick the man. I will always pick Shakespeare over Sappho, Dickens over Austen, Hawthorne over Stowe. Psh, fine. :)
Era Might Posted June 21, 2013 Posted June 21, 2013 Maybe "don't like" is not the right phrasing. Don't relate to, maybe.
CrossCuT Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 Emma is one of my favourite novels. Austen is, I think, one of the great moral/psychological realists. I come out of her books feeling I know a little bit more about people (including myself). She is amazing. Her understanding of social culture of that time was amazing. Not only that but she has a wicked sense of humor in a subtle way! I find her hilarious how she is able to spin together a book full of the social norms of her time as well as poke fun at them in the process.
RCIA ~ Class of 09 Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 ALTHOUGH!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My favorite Jane Austen hunk is from Northeranger Abbey. Henry Tilney forever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Say it ain't so!!! Mr. Darcy is rolling over in his grave!
HisChildForever Posted June 22, 2013 Author Posted June 22, 2013 1. Read Sense and Sensibility first. It's another comparison & contrast novel, like Pride and Prejudice and focuses on the relationship between sisters (as well as beaux). One sister represents a more intellectual approach to life and the other is more self-indulgent of her own whims; she suffers for her lack of sense, although the sensible one also suffers from doing the right thing. 2. Then read Emma. Like the women in Pride and Prejudice and in Sense and Sensibility, Emma is young; her heart is in the right place, but she doesn't have much consideration for people. In the course of the novel, she learns to be less judgmental & manipulative and more supportive. 3. Then read Persuasion. The heroine is still a single woman, but she's older - almost beyond marriageable age. She seems to be somewhat weak because she is very dutiful and puts others' needs before her own, but she's actually quite strong and knows her own mind. I consider Persuasion to be Austen's most "mature" novel. 4. I wasn't crazy about Northanger Abbey, but the heroine is interesting because she's a relatively poor girl who gets thrust into a higher social circle and has to figure out how things are done and where she fits in. 5. Mansfield Park is my favorite Austen novel, but largely because the heroine (Fanny) reminds me of someone I used to know. Again, she's a poor girl thrust into an upper level of society, she has to figure out how things are done and where she fits in, and although she is "the least of the least" in the household she's also the only one who has any real moral compass. Keep in mind, though, that when I read literature, I read primarily for language. And I love Austen's language. Pride and Prejudice has one of the greatest opening sentences in the English language, but all of her novels open with a good sentence. Her language is also quite subtle, so modern readers often miss her nuances - tongue-in-cheek humor, polite sarcasm, and understatement. If you're not that interested in the language, your mileage may vary. But she's also got the character development (in the heroines, at least) and the plot development. Some people complain of her, "I don't actually care who the girl marries." In the end, the heroine does usually marry the man of her dreams, but that's mostly a payoff for acting morally throughout the book - those who act immorally come to unhappy ends. Austen had few other happy endings except 'the good marriage' available to her in those days (although she herself never married). Awesome, thank you so much for sharing all this!! I'll read in the order you suggest. :) Would any of the 3 novels I purchased be considered romances?
CrossCuT Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 Say it ain't so!!! Mr. Darcy is rolling over in his grave! He is my second favorite! The main female in Northanger Abbey is meh, and the storyline is meh, but Henry makes it all worth it! Read the book if you get a chance and if not, there is a good movie out! In my imaginary perfect world, Henry Tilney and Elizabeth Bennet would be a couple!
RCIA ~ Class of 09 Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 amesome, thank you so much for sharing all this!! I'll read in the order you suggest. :) Would any of the 3 novels I purchased be considered romances? They're all romances. But true to Austen's upbringing by her father (who was rector of their parish) and the era in which they were written you don't have to worry about anything more than a healthy courtship.
Luigi Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 amesome, thank you so much for sharing all this!! I'll read in the order you suggest. :) Would any of the 3 novels I purchased be considered romances? As RCIA says, all of them would be classified as romances since the main story line is basically girl-meets-boy and so forth, but they always include a lot more than just that.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now