franciscanheart Posted June 22, 2013 Author Posted June 22, 2013 If any of us did that, would you really listen? I don't think everyone here would listen to me. Try me. Thank you for posting this, franciscanheart. Unfortunately I'm outta props :/ However, there is something I'd like to say. Going to Franciscan University, I've had a friend who's asked the exact same question as you: "Why aren't we more genuine? Why do we all pretend to be so holy and righteous? Why can't everyone just be real?" And I understand the questions. Franciscan and Phatmass are both large communities of Catholics, and sometimes I think that can feel... stuffy. Everyone else seems so darn holy, and it feels like no one can admit their faults, weaknesses, or just let their saint-facade down for five seconds. But, while I think there are people who put up these fronts, I think there are also genuinely holy people. Sometimes, it's easy to see people being holy and assume that they're doing it because everyone else is watching. And sometimes that is true. But, I think, there are people who would be that way regardless of who they were around, and that's not a bad thing. I'm not saying that you don't believe these people exist. I'm saying that perhaps what my come across as self-righteousness or a fake holiness may actually be totally genuine. We cannot know the content of another's heart, after all. :) As for me, as I'm sure you all know, I'm FAR from holy, but I will say this: I don't feel like I've ever put up a mask here on Phatmass. Everything I say is genuine, and while I may not tell everyone all the details of my life (that'd be obnoxious), I don't feel like I'm hiding anything from anyone. Does that make sense? I'm not sure if ANY of this makes sense, but I feel like it needed to be said. Again, I'm not disagreeing with you, franciscanheart, I'm sort of just adding a caveat of sorts. ;) God bless you and keep you all! :love: Absolutely! Don't disagree with any of that. :) The difference in my mind is not so much those who are holy and those who are not. I don't believe "holiness" is what I'm getting at. Even still, holy people make mistakes. They goof up, slip, have fears and doubts. They are still human. And when we can see humanity alongside holiness (or striving for it), that's when, I believe, we are living our best. I believe authenticity is important not just for the sake of fellow Catholics, but for the WHOLE WORLD. My non-Catholic friends know my struggles and doubts, but they also know where I go with them and why. They know I am imperfect but that I have, deep in my heart, an important and meaningful understanding of God and His love for me. They know that when I am struggling, I do not abandon faith, but lean into it -- though it is often physically invisible. I embrace my humanity and find comfort in spirituality. And they know this because I find peace even in turmoil. I don't have to be perfectly resigned. I still get angry and sad and frustrated. But those things don't consume me. Though I will never be a Saint, I do hope to be a saint. I have never claimed perfection and I pray I never will. But I do claim to be faithful in spite of myself. I'm not saying that's holiness, but I do want to emphasize the value and worth of those who may live differently but whose hearts are as open to God as they can be in those moments. We were all blest with different hearts and minds, and we will always see differently and do differently because of it. When we can see each other as true equals in spite of this, that is when we will find real love living among us -- because it will be Love Himself who is directing our lives.
franciscanheart Posted June 22, 2013 Author Posted June 22, 2013 So basically, what you seem to be saying is that if you feel like being [mod] edited..language...rc [/mod]decide to say whatever happens to come into your mind at that time, and if the person on the receiving end doesn't like it, then it's their fault because you're just 'being real'. OK.:blink: Um, no. Not at all, actually. But this along with several other posts in this thread have revealed for me something I never could have illustrated on my own. The hostility in this community is alarming. I've been guilty of the same, and for that I apologize. But no, that wasn't my point at all. Interesting how our opinions of others prevent us from hearing what's really being said.
arfink Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 (edited) :blink: Um, no. Not at all, actually. But this along with several other posts in this thread have revealed for me something I never could have illustrated on my own. The hostility in this community is alarming. I've been guilty of the same, and for that I apologize. But no, that wasn't my point at all. Interesting how our opinions of others prevent us from hearing what's really being said. Being articulate can greatly lessen the chances of being misheard. :like: Also, I don't think the hostility is built into this community, but is the result of many recent upsets, and possibly other factors. Edited June 22, 2013 by arfink
franciscanheart Posted June 22, 2013 Author Posted June 22, 2013 Being articulate can greatly lessen the chances of being misheard. :like: :huh: :blink:
CrossCuT Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 In the past the hostility has gone both ways, just saying.
FutureCarmeliteClaire Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 There's always money in the banana stand.
franciscanheart Posted June 22, 2013 Author Posted June 22, 2013 I'm sorry for any hostility on my part. Is that what y'all are looking for? Can we please get back on topic? This wasn't supposed to he a witch hunt...
arfink Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 :huh: :blink: [media]http://youtu.be/3R58HCiky28[/media]
Oremoose Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 Being articulate can greatly lessen the chances of being misheard. :like: Also, I don't think the hostility is built into this community, but is the result of many recent upsets, and possibly other factors. I agree. Being articulate is hard. I for one struggle to harness the full power of our language. And I have noticed in my times here. That every few months everyone gets wound up and sensitive (having seven sisters makes it easy to be attuned to such things :SOS:) And then foolish things are said. Then everyone is fine for awhile and it then repeats...am I right in that observation? Or just crazy?
CrossCuT Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 I'm sorry for any hostility on my part. Is that what y'all are looking for? Can we please get back on topic? This wasn't supposed to he a witch hunt... I think everyone IS on topic...the topic that things are crazy all up in phatmass. Seems like people are just trying to point out that, while your intentions on here are good, you have also contributed to the atmosphere (we all have) you are now speaking against. Which is fantastic! Also, I think people are getting super fed up with the drama anyway and this thread seems to be reopening that sore. But I am glad it is here for people to speak whats on their mind since you opened the conversation up to begin with. So even if you dont like what youre hearing, be open to the feelings of others as they are struggling as well. Phatmass will never get past this silliness until people start being "real" and willing to be willing to be willing. Its very important.
franciscanheart Posted June 22, 2013 Author Posted June 22, 2013 That's not the topic. :lol: I'm dealing with new house things and don't have Internet yet. As such, I'm limited to my phone. That in addition to chores means I don't have much time to resay what I've already said. As soon as I can put kid gloves on and type out a thoughtful, clear response, I will. To those who would rather point fingers at me and tell me what a terrible person I am, thank you for the opportunity to grow in humility, love and forgiveness. It's not helpful, but I won't try to change your mind or stop you. If you want to tell me what you really think, my email is [myusername] @ phatmass.com. I'm going to sound like Nihil, but maybe he's for this part right: if you want to talk something out (or just talk at me) please feel free to message or email. Gods peace. More later.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 I thought this thread was gunna be about swimwear.
CrossCuT Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 The level of irony in this thread is killing me. :|
Lil Red Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 In the past the hostility has gone both ways, just saying. I think everyone IS on topic...the topic that things are crazy all up in phatmass. Seems like people are just trying to point out that, while your intentions on here are good, you have also contributed to the atmosphere (we all have) you are now speaking against. Which is fantastic! Also, I think people are getting super fed up with the drama anyway and this thread seems to be reopening that sore. But I am glad it is here for people to speak whats on their mind since you opened the conversation up to begin with. So even if you dont like what youre hearing, be open to the feelings of others as they are struggling as well. i guess i don't see where franny is saying it was just one way? she has already (several times) said that she is sorry for her actions. i have said the same. i know that franny doesn't have a hidden agenda here. i don't think franny started this thread to have everyone beat up on her - she acknowledged her own faults at the beginning of this thread. so have i (or i've tried). yet, it seems to be turning into a "franny hasn't apologized enough" thread. to the bolded part: i'm only seeing my part, and especially with those that i don't agree with, i have an extremely hard time seeing things from their point of view. but i don't want (and i don't think franny wants) this thread to turn into a one-sided, let's point fingers thread? Phatmass will never get past this silliness until people start being "real" and willing to be willing to be willing. Its very important. can i just ask - because it's hard to tell tone/inflection/what-have-you on the internet, and because of past interactions i've had with you. are you being serious here or making fun? ending here (for now), and to everyone reading: i'm trying harder to just be open to what others are saying, regardless if i've disagreed/not gotten along with them in the past - to see what they're saying essentially as a stranger to these phorums would hear it. i'm trying, instead of getting all "het up" about a phrase, to just simply ask - and please know that i'm not trying to be snotty when i ask. i'm trying to understand.
ardillacid Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 Though I will never be a Saint... Why do you feel this way?
FutureCarmeliteClaire Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 (edited) If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all (or just post pony pictures). That should be a giant banner pinned to the top of every board of Phatmass. Edited June 22, 2013 by FutureCarmeliteClaire
CrossCuT Posted June 22, 2013 Posted June 22, 2013 i guess i don't see where franny is saying it was just one way? she has already (several times) said that she is sorry for her actions. i have said the same. i know that franny doesn't have a hidden agenda here. i don't think franny started this thread to have everyone beat up on her - she acknowledged her own faults at the beginning of this thread. so have i (or i've tried). yet, it seems to be turning into a "franny hasn't apologized enough" thread. I have never asked her for an apology. The only reason I asked if this thread WAS an apology of sorts was because I was having a hard time understanding her underlying message. can i just ask - because it's hard to tell tone/inflection/what-have-you on the internet, and because of past interactions i've had with you. are you being serious here or making fun? ending here (for now), and to everyone reading: i'm trying harder to just be open to what others are saying, regardless if i've disagreed/not gotten along with them in the past - to see what they're saying essentially as a stranger to these phorums would hear it. i'm trying, instead of getting all "het up" about a phrase, to just simply ask - and please know that i'm not trying to be snotty when i ask. i'm trying to understand. I was being serious. In any situation where there is tension, it is difficult to step outside of yourself and look at the conversation from an outsiders view; to look at it from a different perspective. Like you said very well (which is why I used the same language), we ALL need to be willing to be willing. If not, where does that leave us? Its hard. I suck at it, but I will ALWAYS try. Always. When I get fed up and crazy, its usually my last resort...and Im not proud of it, but I struggle like everyone else, but it is NOT an excuse. I have no excuse to be rude and I will not offer any. And while this is my personal prospective, I have noticed a huge difference in how you address me LilRed. We have had our tension in the past, but the fact that youre openly communicating with me right now has probably made my entire day. :bounce:
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now