Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Excellent. They probably should be treated that way. Whoever sends a C&D because of an improper citation on a web forum is probably a pathetic human being. :P

 

Sounds good to me. Nice and sensible.

I seem to recall that the C&D was from some obscure rando with a weird fundamentalist website. He was either trolling the Catholics or suffering from delusions of grandeur. 

Posted

I seem to recall that the C&D was from some obscure rando with a weird fundamentalist website. He was either trolling the Catholics or suffering from delusions of grandeur. 

 

aren't we all? 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I seem to recall that the C&D was from some obscure rando with a weird fundamentalist website. He was either trolling the Catholics or suffering from delusions of grandeur. 

Hopefully. I do not remember if I asked her for any details, but someone would have to have a uniquely pointless existence to go around threatening webforums with under 100 active members, with copyright claims that are worthless and silly. :P

Posted

I seem to recall that the C&D was from some obscure rando with a weird fundamentalist website. He was either trolling the Catholics or suffering from delusions of grandeur. 

 

i like that word. 

Posted

So non-harmful criticism of the Novus Ordo is allowed?

Yes, but I am the judge of what is and isn't harmful, and have an extremely low tolerance on this subject with a very itchy ban finger.

Anastasia13
Posted

Yes, but I am the judge of what is and isn't harmful, and have an extremely low tolerance on this subject with a very itchy ban finger.

 

Thank you. Now I know the trick.  :idea2:

Posted

Thank you. Now I know the trick.  :idea2:

 

rotfl

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

Yes, but I am the judge of what is and isn't harmful, and have an extremely low tolerance on this subject with a very itchy ban finger.

 

You should have Winchester be a mod again.

franciscanheart
Posted

You should have Winchester be a mod again.

Especially because he's the standard for what is and is not acceptable. He, of all, should be the best judge of what should be moderated and what should not.
Posted

Especially because he's the standard for what is and is not acceptable. He, of all, should be the best judge of what should be moderated and what should not.

 

yes! :hehe: 

Posted

Can we ban ponies?

Posted

Can we ban ponies?

Props to you bro for being brave enough to say that around here...

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Can we ban ponies?

 

They may take our lives, but they will NEVER. TAKE. OUR. PONIES!!!

 

Props to you bro for being brave enough to say that around here...

Your appreciation for Mulan will only get you so far, child.

Posted

Yes, but I am the judge of what is and isn't harmful, and have an extremely low tolerance on this subject with a very itchy ban finger.

 

I was actually thinking of more of an academic criticism, like one might find in a seminary setting.  Not that there’s a huge amount of criticism of the Mass in the seminary (in my experience), but there are some issues that are occasionally raised, if not in the class room, at least among seminarians themselves.

 

But I think your itchy finger is probably wise since I’ve seen these interwebz discussions quickly devolve into nothing but a bash fest.  The Novus Ordo seems to be the bête noire of a certain type of Calathumpian Catholic and they won’t admit anything good about it which is rather a provincial view in my opinion. 

 

It’s hard to mention an objection to the Mass without sounding like one is questioning the validity of the Mass overall, even if that is not the intent.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Bambi, are you familiar with Laszlo Dobszay's two books?

Posted

Bambi, are you familiar with Laszlo Dobszay's two books?

 

I've heard of them but not read them. 

 

I think Mosebach's Heresy of Formlessness is a pretty sensible critique.  He seems to write with a sense of sadness of what was so cavalierly tossed away, rather than from anger, as so many other Trads do.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I've heard of them but not read them. 

 

I think Mosebach's Heresy of Formlessness is a pretty sensible critique.  He seems to write with a sense of sadness of what was so cavalierly tossed away, rather than from anger, as so many other Trads do.

Restoration and Organic Development of the Roman Rite completely changed the way I look at the whole debate.
In comparison I actually found Heresy of Formlessness a little disappointing. It is an ok book, for sure. There is not anything I dislike about it. But reading that right after Restoration, it felt especially non-scholarly and sort of directionless.
Basically, I should have read Heresy of Formlessness right after I read A Bitter Trial, then read Restoration and Organic Development. :P

Posted

Restoration and Organic Development of the Roman Rite completely changed the way I look at the whole debate.
In comparison I actually found Heresy of Formlessness a little disappointing. It is an ok book, for sure. There is not anything I dislike about it. But reading that right after Restoration, it felt especially non-scholarly and sort of directionless.
Basically, I should have read Heresy of Formlessness right after I read A Bitter Trial, then read Restoration and Organic Development. :P

 

$35 and no Kindle edition?  Hmmm.  Going to wait on that one I'm afraid.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

$35 and no Kindle edition?  Hmmm.  Going to wait on that one I'm afraid.

I think I got mine on sale. But a week or two ago I purchased a second copy for Katy and me to give as a gift to the priest who is celebrating our Nuptial Mass. :) He learned the traditional Mass so that he could do it.
I thought about giving him a copy of the Ottaviani Intervention, but I decided that might be a bit provocative. :|

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...