Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

 June 24, 2013

 

Pope Francis was a no-show by  at a concert where he was to have been the guest of honor.

 

Since his election on March 13, Francis, the former cardinal Jorge Bergoglio of Agentina, has not spent a single night in the opulent and spacious papal apartments.

He has preferred to live in a small suite in a busy Vatican guest house, where he takes most meals in a communal dining room and says Mass every morning in the house chapel rather than the private papal chapel in the Apostolic Palace.

 

The day before the concert, Pope Francis said bishops should be "close to the people" and not have "the mentality of a prince".

 

 

Posted

He is definitely my kind of Pope.

Lilllabettt
Posted (edited)

The way I was raised, I was taught that skipping out on a prior commitment at the last minute was an ungracious thing to do, and very inconsiderate of all the people who were expecting me.  The only possible excuse for such behavior was an emergency, which in this case the Pope's spokesman said there was and apologized for it. 

 

The media thinks there was no emergency, rather the Pope was deliberately rude and disappointed so many hardworking people just to send a political message, that message being that since poor people can't appreciate Beethoven neither should bishops. And the media goes on to say that this supposed behavior is praiseworthy and should be applauded.  The Pope is a Christian and a gentleman and would never dispose of people that way.  But the media does not know the definition of the words "Christian" or "gentleman."

 

Anyone who is buying the media presentation of this episode and joining in on their characterization of it as a show of humility, I'm sorry, but that is bad manners.

 

 

Edited by Lilllabettt
Posted

I agree about skipping out on commitments, but I doubt that he made this commitment. My husband has a bad habit of making appointments for me without consulting me. I feel no guilt if I do not comply. If it embarrasses him or inconviences him, that is an appropriate consequence.

Lilllabettt
Posted

I agree about skipping out on commitments, but I doubt that he made this commitment. My husband has a bad habit of making appointments for me without consulting me. I feel no guilt if I do not comply. If it embarrasses him or inconviences him, that is an appropriate consequence.

 

Actually, he did make it ... when Papa took the reigns he confirmed or cancelled the dates that were coming on the calendar.  This concert was part of the Year of Faith celebrations and it was confirmed.

 

Embarrassing a cardinal is one thing, but disappointing all of those musicians is another. It takes a great deal of trouble to get ready for a performance like that.  The Pope knows better than anyone that you have to consider the little people when you make a decision, and that certainly people count more than politics. So I feel confident saying he wouldn't do this to "send a message."

KnightofChrist
Posted

The Pontiff is a prince.

Posted

The Pontiff is a prince.

 

This Kingdom is not an earthly kingdom.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Actually, he did make it ... when Papa took the reigns he confirmed or cancelled the dates that were coming on the calendar.  This concert was part of the Year of Faith celebrations and it was confirmed.

 

Embarrassing a cardinal is one thing, but disappointing all of those musicians is another. It takes a great deal of trouble to get ready for a performance like that.  The Pope knows better than anyone that you have to consider the little people when you make a decision, and that certainly people count more than politics. So I feel confident saying he wouldn't do this to "send a message."

I certainly hope one would not skip an event like that one simply in order to 'send a message', because it is a rather poor message. I would like to think that it was some sort of mistake, or something quite important.

Posted

The way I was raised, I was taught that skipping out on a prior commitment at the last minute was an ungracious thing to do, and very inconsiderate of all the people who were expecting me.  The only possible excuse for such behavior was an emergency, which in this case the Pope's spokesman said there was and apologized for it. 

 

The media thinks there was no emergency, rather the Pope was deliberately rude and disappointed so many hardworking people just to send a political message, that message being that since poor people can't appreciate Beethoven neither should bishops. And the media goes on to say that this supposed behavior is praiseworthy and should be applauded.  The Pope is a Christian and a gentleman and would never dispose of people that way.  But the media does not know the definition of the words "Christian" or "gentleman."

 

Anyone who is buying the media presentation of this episode and joining in on their characterization of it as a show of humility, I'm sorry, but that is bad manners.

 

Great post. :) 

 

Simcha Fischer (whose writing I love) wrote in a similar way about this whole thing: http://www.patheos.com/blogs/simchafisher/2013/06/24/oh-francis-haters-you-sound-very-lovely-when-you-get-played-that-way/

filius_angelorum
Posted

All that I think can be said is that:
(1.) He's the pope, so we should be very circumspect in criticizing him on a personal level. 
(2.) Music is VERY important, and the role of a properly restored appreciation for music is essential in a renewal of the faith.

(3.) Although the bishop of Rome was not at a very important music concert, a very large number of cardinals and bishops were. You have a multitude of good examples to follow.

Posted

I don't really care where the pope lives (guest house or papal apartments). That said, he seems like a genuinely nice sort of fellow and I am willing to wait and see how his pontificate unfolds.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted
Pope tells priests to buy unpretentious things.   The pontiff advises that having the latest smartphone, a fancy car or fashion accessory is not the route to happiness. 
"A car is necessary to do a lot of work, but please, choose a more humble one. If you like the fancy one, just think about how many children are dying of hunger in the world,"
The ANSA news agency said the pope's car of choice for moving around the walled Vatican City was a compact Ford Focus.

 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I have honestly never seen a priest with a fancy car. Is that a thing in Italy, maybe? Or Brazil?

PhuturePriest
Posted

I have honestly never seen a priest with a fancy car. Is that a thing in Italy, maybe? Or Brazil?

 

My spiritual director always has fancy Lincolns with video cameras that go out the back so you can look at the screen instead of having to look behind you. I'd never seen cars so fancy before in my life before I met him. They aren't brand new, they're usually from the '80s or '90s. But they are really fancy cars that you wouldn't expect a clergymen to use.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

Which reminds me...

You all realize that not everyone is a straight A student right ? Some are straight B's, some B's and C's, some straight C's and some C's and D's, and some straight D's etc etc. A brick layer or a dock hand can love and be loved by Jesus as much as someone who has a uni degree, even though there grammar and spelling isn't that great they can know Jesus' too. Not that it's bad to have a uni degree in whatever including theology, just it isn't strictly knowledge that's going to get you to heaven, understanding the less fortunate may.

 

Onward christian souls.

JESUS iz LORD

 

P.s. Sounds like Pope Francis 1 is going to be the working poors Pope.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

I wonder how many degrees Pope Francis1 has, possibly more than any of you.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

Prime example. In my diocease there is a priest from a south east asian country his english isn't great, it isn't horrible but it isn't great either. When he says his homily you have to be mindful and focus on his voice, when i do this i understand most of what he says. He actually is a very holy priest, with wonderful homilies, if you take the time to listen more care fully.

 

Long live Pope Francis1 

 

Onward christian souls.

Jesus is Lord.

 

P.s. Of course a straight C or D student doesn't mean your free from sin, and nore does straight A or B.

Edited by Tab'le Du'Bah-Rye
Posted

My spiritual director always has fancy Lincolns with video cameras that go out the back so you can look at the screen instead of having to look behind you. I'd never seen cars so fancy before in my life before I met him. They aren't brand new, they're usually from the '80s or '90s. But they are really fancy cars that you wouldn't expect a clergymen to use.

 

One of my former pastors always drove a Lincoln Continental, but he didn't buy it. It was a gift from a prishioner who bought a new car every year (he owned his own company - it was part his image of success) and then gave last year's car to a priest and used it as a tax write-off.

 

The car was still being put to good use, it helped him in his ministry, and he didn't pay a dime for it. But it was often perceived as pretentious or indulgent.

 

I guess the moral of the story is to not make a judgment until you know the full situation.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

Perhaps there's a shortage of priests because many think there that little old lady that puts in one coin, i hear plenty of clinking in the church plates and not much else. Without the available finances how can we support more priests and other religious? I don't know, i understand that giving something small or large isn't the major point, but perhaps what pope Francis has said about smartphones is also aimed at the laity. Why not by a $50 mobile at safeways instead of a $750 smartphone and give the difference to the church plates or some kind of charity, even a homeless man. That would be random giving a homeless person $700 he or she would totally freak, give him or her a pocket bible too. But than of course we do need some for ourselves. I think Tobit says it wonderfully, "if you have a lot give a lot, if you have a little don't be ashamed of that little you can give." 

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

One of my former pastors always drove a Lincoln Continental, but he didn't buy it. It was a gift from a prishioner who bought a new car every year (he owned his own company - it was part his image of success) and then gave last year's car to a priest and used it as a tax write-off.

 

The car was still being put to good use, it helped him in his ministry, and he didn't pay a dime for it. But it was often perceived as pretentious or indulgent.

 

I guess the moral of the story is to not make a judgment until you know the full situation.

 

 

I hear what your saying, a donation is a donation, but i don't think this is what the Pope is getting at. He is having a go at materialism, buying more than what we actually need. I have heard the present age in the west being compared to the roman empire of the past in it's fascination with material possessions, supposedly the roman empire was really bad at this.

Edited by Tab'le Du'Bah-Rye

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...