Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Asexuality And Marriage


Recommended Posts

Posted

You guys are forgetting that in every marriage there will be a difference in the level of sexual desire between the spouses. Sometimes it depends on hormone levels, fatigue, and child care issues. Later in life, it can be medical. People with low sex drives are still capable of loving deeply, otherwise they aren't asexual, they're sociopathic.

Posted

    Canon 1060 Marriage enjoys the favour of law. Consequently, in doubt the validity of a marriage must be upheld until the contrary is proven. Emphasis mine.

 

 

    Canon 1061.1 A valid marriage between baptised persons is said to be merely ratified,  if it is not consummated; ratified and consummated, if the spouses have in a human manner engaged together in a conjugal act in itself apt for the generation of offspring. To this act marriage is by its nature ordered and by it the spouses become one flesh.

 

    Canon 1061.2 If the spouses have lived together after the celebration of their marriage, consummation is presumed until the contrary is proven. Emphasis mine.

 

This is a reasonable presumption of law and is of practical importance in cases where it is alleged not to have been consummated.  If the parties have lived together, even for a very brief period, the presumption can be displaced only by contrary proof

 

 

southern california guy
Posted

I've certainly heard about marriages where the wife refuses to have any sex and the husband sneaks off to the Asian massages.  But maybe that is more a case of a problem marriage rather than true asexual feelings.

homeschoolmom
Posted (edited)

I've certainly heard about marriages where the wife refuses to have any sex and the husband sneaks off to the Asian massages.  But maybe that is more a case of a problem marriage rather than true asexual feelings.

You are one of the weirdest posters Phatmass has ever had.

Edited by homeschoolmom
southern california guy
Posted (edited)

You are one of the weirdest posters Phatmass has ever had

 

Maybe not my most thought out post.  I was trying to say that I think that married people who say that they have no interest in intimacy with their spouse, aren't really not interested in intimacy, they are just angry at their spouse or "getting even" for something.

 

Having never been married I am certainly not an expert in this, but this wouldn't be the first time that I said something dumb.

Edited by southern california guy
Poorly Catechized Convert
Posted (edited)

Obviously this is the kind of thing you'd want to discuss before you get married to someone...

 

Of course, but some times something may sound okay until it's put into practice. At that point things could change quite a bit. My thought is that there's the possibility that while the asexual person and the non-asexual person may have talked about these things and found them doable, once they've been married for a while they find that the opposite is true. Granted it is also likely that things could work out just find and both remain satisfied.

 

 

So what happens if two  asexual Catholics ended up marrying. I know this is unlikely, but it's still relevant. How would the Church look upon such a marriage? In this case there is sex in order to have children. So the marriage is consummated and it is open to life. In such a marriage would the sex outside of trying to have children still be necessary? Since neither wants sex, would it its eventual absence be considered a problem?

 

 

 

Edited by Poorly Catechized Convert
Posted

Um, at this point I just wonder, why are you asking this?

 

The scenarios you are positing are contrived and/or uncommon enough as to be very unlikely.

Anastasia13
Posted

 

Of course, but some times something may sound okay until it's put into practice. At that point things could change quite a bit. My thought is that there's the possibility that while the asexual person and the non-asexual person may have talked about these things and found them doable, once they've been married for a while they find that the opposite is true. Granted it is also likely that things could work out just find and both remain satisfied.

 

 

So what happens if two  asexual Catholics ended up marrying. I know this is unlikely, but it's still relevant. How would the Church look upon such a marriage? In this case there is sex in order to have children. So the marriage is consummated and it is open to life. In such a marriage would the sex outside of trying to have children still be necessary? Since neither wants sex, would it its eventual absence be considered a problem?

 

 

 

Often even then, there is enough frustration beforehand if it's not going to work.

 

Usually asexual people either stayed about the same or became slightly more sexual rather than less sexual if there was a change once they finished puberty/entered a serious relationship. Sexuals in a relationship with an asexual would either become frustrated or stick it out. You will not find a strongly sexual in a lasting relationship with an asexual-they would break up before the alter.

 

It's doubtful that they would be obligated to have sex as long as they were both not interested.

Poorly Catechized Convert
Posted

Um, at this point I just wonder, why are you asking this?

The scenarios you are positing are contrived and/or uncommon enough as to be very unlikely.


I'm asking in part due to curiosity and also because, from what I can tell, it's likely that I'm asexual. Maybe I should have mentioned that sooner, but I prefer to keep myself out of questions like this.
Poorly Catechized Convert
Posted

Um, at this point I just wonder, why are you asking this?

The scenarios you are positing are contrived and/or uncommon enough as to be very unlikely.


I'm asking in part due to curiosity and also because, from what I can tell, it's likely that I'm asexual. Maybe I should have mentioned that sooner, but I prefer to keep myself out of questions like this.
Poorly Catechized Convert
Posted (edited)

Um, at this point I just wonder, why are you asking this?

The scenarios you are positing are contrived and/or uncommon enough as to be very unlikely.


I'm asking in part due to curiosity and also because, from what I can tell, it's likely that I'm asexual. Since I couldn't find a religious perspective on any of this, I had to ask. Maybe I should have mentioned that sooner, but I prefer to keep myself out of questions like this. Edited by Poorly Catechized Convert
Posted

It happens to all of us.

Posted

Except me.

Posted

Except me.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...