Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

ithinkjesusiscool
Posted

Pax! I found this on Youtube:

I have no idea why it says Credo in unum deum. It is grammatically wrong. It should be Credo uno Deo. Credo takes its object in the dative case, not in + accusative. This rule is for, at least Classical Latin; I guess the creed was written, after the classical era of Latin. And the Greek has the same mistake here: This is Liturgical Latin, not Classical Latin. What do you think?

Posted (edited)

I think we have more urgent things to worry about...

Edited by Norseman82
Posted

I think the grammatical construction of the creed (both in Greek and Latin) is intentional, because the "I believe in" phrase is used only in reference to the persons of Holy Trinity, and this specific usage is meant to convey the fact that a Christian believes "in" the divine persons as opposed to merely believing certain things about them. That is why that same grammatical structure is not used later in the creed when the Church is mentioned; instead, the creed simply says "and one, holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church," and this structure is meant to convey the truth that we do not "believe in" the Church, but that we believe the Church, that is, we believe what the Church teaches.

Vincent Vega
Posted

Pax! I found this on Youtube:

I have no idea why it says Credo in unum deum. It is grammatically wrong. It should be Credo uno Deo. Credo takes its object in the dative case, not in + accusative. This rule is for, at least Classical Latin; I guess the creed was written, after the classical era of Latin. And the Greek has the same mistake here: This is Liturgical Latin, not Classical Latin. What do you think?

I'm no Latin scholar, but to go off of what Apotheoun was saying above, consider the following:

 

a. Credo amico meo.

 

and

 

b. Credo in amicum meum. 

 

Without knowing how it would have been taken contemporaneously, it seems to me that using the dative -- as in example a -- has the implication of believing someone (e.g., in what they say or think), whereas the accusative construction -- example b -- implies believing in someone/something.  

 

 

Perhaps I am horrifyingly wrong.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Just to make sure I am understanding this here, are you trying to correct the grammar - on a language in which you are not fluent - of a document which is literally older than the English language itself?

Posted

something like that....

Vincent Vega
Posted

Just to make sure I am understanding this here, are you trying to correct the grammar - on a language in which you are not fluent - of a document which is literally older than the English language itself?

Seemed like a more or less innocent enough question to me (if phrased a little heavy-handedly...). 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Seemed like a more or less innocent enough question to me (if phrased a little heavy-handedly...). 

The heavy-handed phrasing is what is getting me. :P

Vincent Vega
Posted

Maybe [s]he has been doing a lot of shakeweighting.

 

clip_image005_0000.gif

Nihil Obstat
Posted

WGJJLWZEelVKWEk=.jpg

That was one of only two good parts of that entire movie. :P

Posted

That was one of only two good parts of that entire movie. :P


False, there were at least three.
Nihil Obstat
Posted

False, there were at least three.

I remember that part and the part with the useless philosophers. The rest I recall finding really lame. :P

Brother Vinny
Posted (edited)

I remember that part and the part with the useless philosophers. The rest I recall finding really lame. :P

 

I liked Cleese's summation of the Beatitudes as saying the blessed are those maintaining the status quo.

 

I liked the stoning scene with all the women wearing long beards.

 

I liked the discussion about the different sects ("Judean People's Front" vs. "Peoples Front of Judea").  "Splitters!"

 

And, of course, the scene referenced above.

 

Oh, and the guy complaining because he got healed and now he's out of his begging job.

Edited by Brother Vinny
ithinkjesusiscool
Posted

I think we have more urgent things to worry about...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SuIZ9E4T8uQ 

 

 

Just to make sure I am understanding this here, are you trying to correct the grammar - on a language in which you are not fluent - of a document which is literally older than the English language itself?

this is not about correcting something. it's about understanding the language used in the Liturgy...

Nihil Obstat
Posted


this is not about correcting something. it's about understanding the language used in the Liturgy...


Then perhaps saying "it is grammatically wrong" was a bit hasty. :|
Posted

St. Thomas Aquinas was aware of this usage of Credo Deo vs. Credo in Deum (and he also adds Credo Deum). In the Summa theologiae, IIa IIae, Q 2, A 2, ob. 1 he writes, Ad secundum sic proceditur. Videtur quod inconvenienter distinguatur actus fidei per hoc quod est credere Deo, credere Deum et credere in Deum. Unius enim habitus unus est actus. Sed fides est unus habitus, cum sit una virtus. Ergo inconvenienter ponuntur plures actus eius." It's the first part of this that's important here, the distinction between credere Deo, credere Deum, and credere in Deum. The old Dominican Fathers edition has it translated as to believe God, believe in a God, and to believe in God. The Blackfriars edition (ever loose with their translations, but perhaps better at conveying Thomas' true meaning), has "to believe God, to believe in God, to believe unto God." If you've not read much Thomas before you might expect him to choose one or another of these meanings, but he simply answers that they are all different aspects of the same act of faith, seen from different perspectives.

 

This last idea of believing unto God actually gets at the problem with both in and eis (Greek for "in"). They both imply a movement toward something. But this is why Thomas (and perhaps all of the Church Fathers who use the term) are perfectly willing to use such a term outside of its normal grammatical construction: faith is a virtue and thus describes a type of movement itself. Thomas uses this moment to remind us (following St. Augustine's lead) that belief is understood as it is moved by the will to be assented to (i.e. we understand what we believe and then we give an assent to it: cum enim credere ad intellectum pertineat prout est a voluntate motus ad assentiendum). In this case I think that the sentence is grammatically correct, given what the Fathers wanted to say. Many of them were classically trained and use Greek and Latin forms more rigorously than even the ancients did in their own time (e.g. St. Basil the Great is better at writing Attic Greek than Plato was).

 

 

Let me also add that credo + dat. normally means to believe someone, not in someone. It means that they're telling the truth. At least, this is the way that I have seen it written (which is what Thomas explains above).

Posted

I think the grammatical construction of the creed (both in Greek and Latin) is intentional, because the "I believe in" phrase is used only in reference to the persons of Holy Trinity, and this specific usage is meant to convey the fact that a Christian believes "in" the divine persons as opposed to merely believing certain things about them. That is why that same grammatical structure is not used later in the creed when the Church is mentioned; instead, the creed simply says "and one, holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church," and this structure is meant to convey the truth that we do not "believe in" the Church, but that we believe the Church, that is, we believe what the Church teaches.

 

The creed uses the same language for "in one, holy, catholic, and Apostolic Church" in the same format as the Trinity (eis mian agian katholicen kai apostoliken ekklesian or in unam catholicam et apostolicam ecclesiam). Only after this moment does the Greek/Latin verb switch to "I confess." St. Thomas didn't really like this part and said (ST IIa IIae Q 1, A 9, ad 5):

 

If we say: "'In' the holy Catholic Church," this must be taken as verified in so far as our faith is directed to the Holy Ghost, Who sanctifies the Church; so that the sense is: "I believe in the Holy Ghost sanctifying the Church." But it is better and more in keeping with the common use, to omit the 'in,' and say simply, "the holy Catholic Church," as Pope Leo [Rufinus, Comm. in Sym. Apost.] observes.

 

I think he's silly, but oh well.

Posted (edited)

The creed uses the same language for "in one, holy, catholic, and Apostolic Church" in the same format as the Trinity (eis mian agian katholicen kai apostoliken ekklesian or in unam catholicam et apostolicam ecclesiam). Only after this moment does the Greek/Latin verb switch to "I confess." St. Thomas didn't really like this part and said (ST IIa IIae Q 1, A 9, ad 5):

 

 

I think he's silly, but oh well.

That is correct about the original Greek text, but I was referencing the Latin liturgical version which reads as follow: 

 

"Et unam, sanctam, cathólicam et apostólicam Ecclésiam."

 

There are minor modifications in both the Latin and Greek liturgical versions of the creed (e.g., the "We believe" of the bishops is replaced by "I believe" in the liturgical versions of the creed).

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted (edited)

Anscar Chupungco O.S.B. wrote an excellent treatment of the liturgical creed (of the Latin Church) in a book edited by Edward Foley entitled, "A Commentary on the Order of Mass of the Roman Missal: New English Translation" (see the pages on the creed), which supports the notion that we do not in fact have faith in the Church, but that we believe what the Church teaches. Faith, as a divine gift. really is centered upon the Holy Trinity.

Edited by Apotheoun

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...