Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

A few years back a BA 777 had a similar crash (minus the fire) at LHR due to Ice crystals forming in the fuel line and that caused thrust issues during landing causing the flight to land almost 1000ft short of the runway. In SFO, something like that would fit with the landing gear clipping the seawall and then slamming the plane into the runway threshold. 

 

It really is a testament to today's airliners that so many people survived a crash/fire like this one. Flying has never been safer than these modern times.

 

That and God's providence.

Posted

So glad things have been (relatively) good so far...I'll go with God's providence and modern engineering for there only being two deaths out of over 300 people!

Posted

As noted before, lots of conflicting stuff.

 

This seems to summarize most recent stuff.... sounds like mistakes may have been made... but good choices were made after that which minimized what could have been horrific..... and that the planes are designed for maximum survivability and ease of egress... Thank God.

 

http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/07/us/plane-crash-main/index.html?hpt=hp_t1

 

Posted

They are pretty sure it was NOT ice crystals, I think.  That was one of the early hypotheses, but quickly was rejected.

 

And of course, it was one of our few really beautiful days this time of year... no fog, no wind.   THAT probably helped in making it better than it could have been...

 

 

Posted

If the weather was clear, then I think they can only assume the plane was not answering to the controls properly, perhaps an unusual loss of thrust. Experienced pilots (and I can only assume he was a seasoned pilot with an airline that large) don't just do things like put the tail into a sea wall.

Posted

I've been doing some reading about the safety systems on the 777, and given what I'm reading, either those systems had to have failed, or the pilots somehow managedto convince themselves that those systems couldn't possibly be correct. But then, I don't know how you manage to ignore sensors which are telling you that you are going into a stall condition.

Posted

Ah, the pilot was new to the 777. That might explain a lot. Still, the 777 has a lot of really impressive safety features, including a motorized flight stick that will tug against you and vibrate if you're off course. I wonder if those were working. :ohno:

Dr. Bombay
Posted

I thought I recalled seeing on Mythbusters that modern commercial airliners can basically land themselves.  How is it possible an error of this type could have been made?

 

Perhaps I shouldn't watch Mythbusters....

Posted

I thought I recalled seeing on Mythbusters that modern commercial airliners can basically land themselves.  How is it possible an error of this type could have been made?

 

Perhaps I shouldn't watch Mythbusters....

 

That is actually true. The planes have good enough nav systems that they know how fast they are going, what orientation they are at, and the orientation and distance to the runway. They also know the wind and such. You don't need anything more to land a plane. In fact, the various drone systems the US employs are capable of self-landing, based on the same kind of tech they have in the 777, just smaller scale.

CatherineM
Posted

San Francisco is one of the airports that is on the list for natural hazards.

Chestertonian
Posted

I've few into SF a number of times. It's scary as carp because the runway is so close to the water.

southern california guy
Posted

That is scary.  It sounds like an inexperienced pilot just brought the plane in too "low and slow".....  He "stalled" it and dragged the tail into the edge of the runway just as he began landing.  Unbelieveable...  Did the plane have a power loss?  Why didn't he push the throttle forward and increase the speed and pull it out of the stall?  Of course those jets don't accelerate all that fast... :(

Posted

That is scary.  It sounds like an inexperienced pilot just brought the plane in too "low and slow".....  He "stalled" it and dragged the tail into the edge of the runway just as he began landing.  Unbelieveable...  Did the plane have a power loss?  Why didn't he push the throttle forward and increase the speed and pull it out of the stall?  Of course those jets don't accelerate all that fast... :(

 

Well apparently 7 seconds before impact he had a big warning from the computer system, and then 4 seconds before impact he pushed the throttle up and the engines seemed to respond as expected. Less than 2 seconds before impact they said they wanted to go a "go around."

ithinkjesusiscool
Posted

I do agree that this is kinda sad but why do we all need to know about this!?!

If you want a discussion about this it would be ok. Maybe we could learn something from it.

I just complain about the stupid media.

Posted

Yeah, I know what you mean.  I use it to pray for them, but try to stay clear from too much of the reports.

 

I think the general consensus out here (for what it is worth, and my husband works at that airport and deals with the customers all night long...) is that the guy was experienced, just not on that plane.  Everyone has to fly --and land-- a new plane a first time.    Apparently they send 2 pilots to spell each other on the long trips, and it was that guy's turn in the seat.   Having said that, what they are also saying is that the pilot who is not in the flight chair has the responsibility feed numbers and watch stuff for the pilot...so if there was a screw up... maybe the back-up was the one who should have been watching more carefully.

 

But I'm going to take a hint from 'Sully', the captain who miraculously landed that plane in the Hudson a few years back?   He was asked point-blank if he thought it was pilot error and he said, that's a complicated question... and a very tough airport.   I'm not going to judge.

 

I for one am glad judging what happened in this case is NOT something I have to do.   But good reminder, ITJC!

Posted

Prayers for the souls of the deceased and for those who are recovering from this crazy crash.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...