Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Ef Mass In New York?


Recommended Posts

ChristinaTherese
Posted

I'm going to New York for a few days and was just wondering if anyone knew of an EF Mass around there.... I intend to get to daily Mass (probably around noon or 5-ish or so downtown) and figured that I'd check with y'all just in case. (I've been at Novus Ordo Masses exclusively for the last month.... I'd like a change for a little, since I've been used to EF Mass about 4 days a week (and NO the other 3) at college.)

PhuturePriest
Posted

http://www.ecclesiadei.org/masses.cfm#New%20York
 
Holy Innocents might be your best bet.
 


Manhattan

Church of the Holy Innocents

Sunday: 10:00 AM; Mon - Fri: 6:00 PM; Sat: 1:00 PM



 

Holy Day falling on weekday: 6:00 PM

Question: Why have Mass on Saturday at 1:00 since that doesn't count for your Sunday obligation? It's clearly stated that it must be 4:00 on Saturday evening for a Mass to be counted for your Sunday obligation.

ChristinaTherese
Posted

Question: Why have Mass on Saturday at 1:00 since that doesn't count for your Sunday obligation? It's clearly stated that it must be 4:00 on Saturday evening for a Mass to be counted for your Sunday obligation.

Because daily Mass on Saturdays is a good thing, and because if you want a vigil Mass they have a NO Mass at 4:00. (Their website is here: http://www.innocents.com/)

 

Oh, and thanks, Nihil! I'll see if I can get there (that is, if it fits in with my parents' desired schedule or they'd rather I go at an earlier time).

PhuturePriest
Posted

Because daily Mass on Saturdays is a good thing, and because if you want a vigil Mass they have a NO Mass at 4:00. (Their website is here: http://www.innocents.com/)

 

Oh, and thanks, Nihil! I'll see if I can get there (that is, if it fits in with my parents' desired schedule or they'd rather I go at an earlier time).

 

But you can just have a Vigil Mass and then go to Mass again on Sunday. It doesn't make sense to have a daily Mass on Saturday, I don't think. Besides, what if you wanted to go to the EF but could only go on Saturdays?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Anticipated Masses are a bit of a new thing. Perhaps more traditional churches prefer to simply have a daily Mass.
I know at my parish the Novus Ordo does the vigil, and we do not.

Posted

But you can just have a Vigil Mass and then go to Mass again on Sunday. It doesn't make sense to have a daily Mass on Saturday, I don't think. Besides, what if you wanted to go to the EF but could only go on Saturdays?

If it's a fraternity parish, it won't offer an anticipatory Mass. They stopped those several years ago... I remember my parents-in-law switching parishes for that very reason.
OnlySunshine
Posted (edited)

Question: Why have Mass on Saturday at 1:00 since that doesn't count for your Sunday obligation? It's clearly stated that it must be 4:00 on Saturday evening for a Mass to be counted for your Sunday obligation.

 

It is stated that as long as Mass on Saturday falls after 12pm, it fulfills the Sunday obligation.  It can be a nuptial or funeral Mass or a Vigil (meaning that the liturgy is the Sunday readings).
 

http://www.canonlaw.info/2008/11/time-period-for-fulfilling-sunday.html

 

 

Edited by MaterMisericordiae
PhuturePriest
Posted

It is stated that as long as Mass on Saturday falls after 12pm, it fulfills the Sunday obligation.
 

http://www.canonlaw.info/2008/11/time-period-for-fulfilling-sunday.html

 

Well, that makes no sense. In Jewish tradition, the next day begins at four o'clock. That's why in my diocese and in the neighboring dioceses, if a Mass is before 4:00, it doesn't fulfill your Sunday obligation. That's how it is in all the dioceses in Kansas. I figured that was a universal rule.

OnlySunshine
Posted (edited)

Well, that makes no sense. In Jewish tradition, the next day begins at four o'clock. That's why in my diocese and in the neighboring dioceses, if a Mass is before 4:00, it doesn't fulfill your Sunday obligation. That's how it is in all the dioceses in Kansas. I figured that was a universal rule.

 

In my diocese, there is a large Church with a website that says that Masses held after 12pm fulfill the requirement.  Maybe it's exclusive to your state to hold it after 4pm?

Edited by MaterMisericordiae
OnlySunshine
Posted (edited)

OK, I'm confused.  This answer from an apologist states that Rome hasn't been specific.  Maybe a Church Scholar can weigh in?

 

http://forums.catholic.com/showthread.php?t=20461

 

All I know is there is a Church in my diocese that offers a Mass at noon and they specifically state it fulfills the Sunday obligation.

Edited by MaterMisericordiae
OnlySunshine
Posted

OK, here is another website that states the Saturday Vigil Mass MUST take place after 4pm to be considered a Sunday Mass.

 

http://stlouisreview.com/article/2012-06-27/dear-father-when-does
 

 

In 1953, Pope Pius XII expanded the option of celebrating the vigil Mass to Sundays, holy days of obligation and special local celebrations to the Church. In his Encyclical "Christus Dominus," the Holy Father declared that such a celebration should not begin before 4 p.m. While some places celebrate the vigil at 4 p.m., most follow the custom of the Diocese of Rome, which begins the vigil Mass at 5 p.m.

 

 

If you are at a Mass before 4 p.m. on a Saturday, plan on going later that day or on Sunday. If it is after 4 p.m., the priest likely will announce if that Mass will fulfill the obligation or not.

 

 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

It may (or may not) be within the diocese's prerogative to allow Masses to fulfill an obligation where normally they would not.
I do not know, but canon law makes allowances like that for ordinaries in other situations.

Lilllabettt
Posted

why should the saints, Mass readings, etc., get cheated just because they fall on a Saturday?

when I was tiny my Mom used to say that the only days of the year without a Mass were Good Friday and Holy Saturday.

 

Posted

Walk half way down 1st street and turn left and then go about 20 paces.  Can't miss it  :winner:

Nihil Obstat
Posted

why should the saints, Mass readings, etc., get cheated just because they fall on a Saturday?
when I was tiny my Mom used to say that the only days of the year without a Mass were Good Friday and Holy Saturday.


Mass of the Presanctified still counts. :sad2:
PhuturePriest
Posted

Walk half way down 1st street and turn left and then go about 20 paces.  Can't miss it  :winner:

 

Hasan!!!!!!

Dr. Bombay
Posted

My Cathedral has a Saturday afternoon Mass at 2:30 and it fulfills the obligation. 

To Jesus Through Mary
Posted

Yeah, in NYC the only daily EF I have found is Holy Innocents. Also if you get a chance to do tourist stuff, go check out St Vincent Ferrer on 63rd and Lex- beats St Pat's hands down and awesome confessors there (they hear Confessions daily). Also if you are around for a Sunday, check out Our Savior- the most beautiful liturgy I have ever seen. Ever. It was Pentecost and the choir was out of this world. I don't know if they have anything special it in the summer. But it is worth a visit (that is at like 38th and Park Ave.) Enjoy NY! 

 

And FP- Mass on Saturday makes perfect since when one goes on a daily basis. :) 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...