Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

So, I was wondering if I were to ask God for a sign and I revived that sign, would it be possible that God didn't give me the sign but the guy downstairs was trying to throw me off? I know this sounds very paranoid, but I am just curious!

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

meh, I'd be careful about these sorts of things. It's human nature to look into situations closely and connect dots that aren't there. Successful psychics and mediums base their entire careers on exploiting this. I'm not going to discount the idea that one can experience something miraculous. I just think that a God would probably fix other things before answering this type of prayer. 

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
To Jesus Through Mary
Posted

St John of the Cross says it's a no-no to ask for signs for that reason (that the sign doesn't necessarily come from God). The only examples of signs being given in Scripture before the Incarnation and the Church. That the Lord have given us many means at leading us now outside of signs and sensible feelings. Accent to Mt Carmel is a pretty good read on the subject if you are curious. :) 

Posted (edited)

okay, I didn't know about this! Woah. Can you tell me more?

 

Edit: In first post I wrote "revived" I meant received. sorry!

Edited by Annie12
Posted

As my old parish priest used to say, a sign is a sign when you think it's a sign. I'm not discounting that God can send us signs, but almost anything can be a sign if you take it that way - and if you're looking for one, chances are you'll find one pointing to what you want.

Posted

The novena to the little flower does the same for me... but meh this post does not forward the convo I am merely interested in the subject.

Posted

I feel like its tempting to ask for signs instead of trusting God. But, still, I don't want to trust a sign that goes against what I think God would be saying to me. Therefore, I err on the side of caution when it comes to signs. Signs just seems so vague...

HisChildForever
Posted

So, I was wondering if I were to ask God for a sign and I revived that sign, would it be possible that God didn't give me the sign but the guy downstairs was trying to throw me off? I know this sounds very paranoid, but I am just curious!

 

CPR on a sign, this I gotta see!

Posted

lol! I corrected my self in a later reply which you can see above...

Posted
An evil and unfaithful generation seeks a sign, but no sign will be given it except the sign of Jonah.

--Matt 16:4

 

So I guess if some guy shows up after spending three days in the belly of a large fish and tells you God is going to destroy you, you may safely take that as a sign.  Otherwise, no.

To Jesus Through Mary
Posted

So I guess if some guy shows up after spending three days in the belly of a large fish and tells you God is going to destroy you, you may safely take that as a sign.  Otherwise, no.

 

Props. 

Posted

Echoing what others have said, sometimes a sign is just what we make of it or not.  Part of why I've always been wary of asking for them personally, that and the verse Dr. Bombay quoted always makes me feel guilty. 

 

Personal experience wise though...back when I was a Baptist, I had never gone forward for baptism, despite believing.  I told God I needed just one sign to be sure; I was going to summer camp and had never seen the stars without a city's lights before, and if at some point I could just see those stars, I'd go forward for baptism.  I didn't get my sign.  Two years went by and during that time, I often struggled with my faith and my fellow Baptists treatment of me.  Summer camp came for a third time and as I was walking back to my cabin in the hot July evening around 1am, the lights around the camp just failed.  Every single light turned off and I stared up at the sky and began to cry.  I went forward for baptism the next week, because two years after asking for it, I got the sign I had wanted.  But the question becomes...did God send me that sign, or did I wishful think it was a sign?  Obviously, I thought and still think that it's the former, but people have every right to question if it was the latter.

 

So I guess pray and use your own judgment is what my rambling is getting at!  Sorry for taking the long way there.

PhuturePriest
Posted

So, I was wondering if I were to ask God for a sign and I revived that sign, would it be possible that God didn't give me the sign but the guy downstairs was trying to throw me off? I know this sounds very paranoid, but I am just curious!

 

Signs are way overblown. Jason Evert has a great story concerning "signs":

 

In college, I did a novena to St. Raphael the Archangel for discernment on a relationship. At the time, I was in school in Austria and my girlfriend was back in school in Ohio. I really wanted to marry her, and on the ninth day of the novena, as I said the word "Amen," the phone rang and it was her, just saying hi. I went through the roof, seeing this as divine providence . . . and she's now happily married to a friend of mine. So, while novenas can be a great spiritual gift, we can often misinterpret them to see what we're hoping for.

maximillion
Posted

Signs, no.

 

God will show you His Will for you if you listen attentively. I would say spend some time in silence, paying attention to the Holy Spirit, then see what arises 'naturally' in your life.

Posted

St John of the Cross says it's a no-no to ask for signs for that reason (that the sign doesn't necessarily come from God). The only examples of signs being given in Scripture before the Incarnation and the Church. That the Lord have given us many means at leading us now outside of signs and sensible feelings. Accent to Mt Carmel is a pretty good read on the subject if you are curious. :)

 

St. John of the Cross says everything is a no-no because it might be from the devil.

 

But on this one, I'd have to agree with him.

 

Now, if you have a proliferation of "signs" that you didn't ask for, of a great variety of types, well then, I'd start to think, maybe...

Posted

Signs are way overblown. Jason Evert has a great story concerning "signs":

 

In college, I did a novena to St. Raphael the Archangel for discernment on a relationship. At the time, I was in school in Austria and my girlfriend was back in school in Ohio. I really wanted to marry her, and on the ninth day of the novena, as I said the word "Amen," the phone rang and it was her, just saying hi. I went through the roof, seeing this as divine providence . . . and she's now happily married to a friend of mine. So, while novenas can be a great spiritual gift, we can often misinterpret them to see what we're hoping for.

 

What do you mean "in college"? Aren't you 16?

Posted

He's obviously immensely precocious. God bless his soul.

Posted

Annie: As most people around here know, I interviewed 35 nuns about how they discerned their religious vocations. Pretty much everything they said could be construed as a "sign". If you're looking for God's will, anything that indicates to you what His will might be could be considered a "sign". Got a strong longing to enter religious life? That's a "sign". Keep running into nuns everywhere? That's a "sign". Did the sky open up and a voice say to you, "I want you to be a nun"? That's a "sign". But that small, soft voice inside you that just won't let nunhood off your mind—that is also a "sign".

 

The problem with "signs" is that everything is a sign. We just don't know it till we notice them and give them significance. To me, what makes the difference between a meaningful sign and one that you "looked for" is that, when a meaningful sign pops up, you get a feeling inside you immediately that it's somehow significant. You might not know how in the moment, but you'll have a feeling that "someone's saying something to you", that this is meaningful. If you have to read meaning into a thing, if you have to try, if you have to force it, so to speak—then you made a "sign" out of something that God may not have intended as one.

 

The difficult part of discerning signs is that, when you want something really bad, you look for signs. And then you will find them. Even if God didn't send them.

 

That being my experience of signs, I take issue with people who say that you ought to ignore signs. I agree that you ought not ask for them outright, or look for them. But, honestly, what it is we're all doing when we ask God "Please reveal your will to me?" How do we expect Him to do that if not through some kind of sign? If the small, still voice in you and the nagging longing and the strange attraction to x, y, or z doesn't count as a "sign", then I don't know what does. I consider all those things "signs" (because the sisters did).

 

I think that Jesus' condemnation of "this generation's" hunger for signs was not for the kind of signs a person is looking for when she asks God to reveal His will to her (via signs, because... what else?). They were asking for Him to perform miracles. So don't ask for a miracle. Just ask Him to show you His will. Don't look for it, don't try too hard for it, get yourself into a state in which you can accept and embrace and love whatever He sends (yes, I know that is HARD), and then kick back and let Him show you what He wants in the way He wants.

 

I assure you, it will come through a "sign"—broadly construed.

 

One sign won't be enough, I expect. Unless it's really big and obvious. (I know one sister who immediately knew God wasn't calling her to a certain community because she got rear-ended on the highway on her way to visit the place.) Most times we build a "cumulative case" for God's will. Many small, subtle signs that just seem to grow the feeling in us that... "Hmm... Yeah... I think God's telling me this." If that's all you're talking about, God bless you. I hope you have many signs.

Posted

He's obviously immensely precocious. God bless his soul.

 

That is most certainly true. But college in Austria at 15?

Posted

That is most certainly true. But college in Austria at 15?

 

Maybe he got tired of all the American girls chasing after his stunning good looks and decided to give the European ladies a chance.

 

 

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jne9t8sHpUc

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...