Norseman82 Posted July 14, 2013 Posted July 14, 2013 Abortion is a safe procedure. The rates of complications are extremely low. And aside from the shooting, how was the play, Mrs. Lincoln?
CatholicsAreKewl Posted July 14, 2013 Posted July 14, 2013 (edited) No one has actually answered Hasan properly. The ends don't justify the means, right? Lying about the purposes of a law, regardless of how beneficial the outcome, is wrong. It doesn't matter if democrats do the same thing with laws on other issues. That's irrelevant. Edited July 14, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
Socrates Posted July 14, 2013 Posted July 14, 2013 No one has actually answered Hasan properly. The ends don't justify the means, right? Lying about the purposes of a law, regardless of how beneficial the outcome, is wrong. It doesn't matter if democrats do the same thing with laws on other issues. That's irrelevant. There's absolutely nothing immoral about the means of tightening regulations and restrictions on abortion. As, I've pointed out, there's nothing safe about abortions, for either the mother or the baby. The fewer abortions, the safer everyone will be. Nobody's lying about anything. Wishing to protect the health/safety of women and the life of babies are not mutually exclusive goals. The safest and healthiest thing would no abortions, but until the supremely dishonest abortion of a Supreme Court ruling, Roe v. Wade, is overturned, pro-lifers will have to do with what restrictions we can get.
Ice_nine Posted July 15, 2013 Posted July 15, 2013 No one has actually answered Hasan properly. The ends don't justify the means, right? Lying about the purposes of a law, regardless of how beneficial the outcome, is wrong. It doesn't matter if democrats do the same thing with laws on other issues. That's irrelevant. It's not outright lying. Although Hasan likes to insinuate the average pro-lifer as a group of men who don't care about women only insofar as they would like to control them, their bodies and their sexuality (which I READILY admit that a number of pro-life men probably fit the bill, and that even larger swaths are simply insensitive in the sense they have never given more than 2 seconds of fleeting thought on the unjust obstacles that women face), most pro-lifers I've met do have concern for the women who face abortion, such concerns include: post abortive depression and other psychological complications, medical complications, and spiritual moral complications. Even if the former two complications don't result from abortion (the woman is physically happy and healthy as a pig in shit) allowing a woman to kill her child has much more graver consequences. Of course my primary concern with women (and men in connection) who can kill their unborn children is the child itself, but I am also concerned for the spiritual welfare of the parents. You well know such a concern would be laughed down in the modern atheist state. So how do we decrease abortions? Again no matter how sympathetic I might be to a person considering murder (of any type, not just abortion, but people sometimes land themselves in impossible situations and see murder as an option, and me I'm a bleeding heart and can understand, but of course not condone, how people might end up there) my primary concern lies with the would be victim. This is not to say that the life of the unborn child is less than the life of the mother, but that the life of the child is worth more than the perhaps grave discomfort and distress of the mother. But I am immensely concerned with the welfare of the woman as well, don't get me wrong. So when it comes down to this law, yes we all know the primary purpose is to reduce access to abortion (cite your primary motive as concern for unborn persons or control of women as you fancy) but there is also a concern for the safety of the mothers (even if the medical concern is a really minor motive next to the psychological and spiritual problems for would-be parents). If this bill has an ulterior motive, chalk it up to the thousands of other laws that do. It's a ridiculous game really, but it's a game I think we need to play. I don't think bill-makers have medical safety as their primary concern for the goal that it is striving to achieve, but as long as there is a medical concern, even a slight one, is it ok to use this reason? Well, it's the only one that will really resonate with a modern audience. Psychology is a soft-science and can be manipulated to suit both pro-choice and pro-life arguments, and "leave your religion out of the state/law" is not gonna work. It's not lying outright, it's playing a game. 100% honesty is not possible and I'm not even sure if it's the ideal. This bill is not showing all it's cards, even though the guy across the table can see the hand. It's a tactical move. Politics is dirty. I rambled a lot. My bizad
CatholicsAreKewl Posted July 15, 2013 Posted July 15, 2013 It's not outright lying. So when it comes down to this law, yes we all know the primary purpose is to reduce access to abortion (cite your primary motive as concern for unborn persons or control of women as you fancy) but there is also a concern for the safety of the mothers (even if the medical concern is a really minor motive next to the psychological and spiritual problems for would-be parents). If this bill has an ulterior motive, chalk it up to the thousands of other laws that do. It's a ridiculous game really, but it's a game I think we need to play. I don't think bill-makers have medical safety as their primary concern for the goal that it is striving to achieve, but as long as there is a medical concern, even a slight one, is it ok to use this reason? Well, it's the only one that will really resonate with a modern audience. Psychology is a soft-science and can be manipulated to suit both pro-choice and pro-life arguments, and "leave your religion out of the state/law" is not gonna work. It's not lying outright, it's playing a game. 100% honesty is not possible and I'm not even sure if it's the ideal. This bill is not showing all it's cards, even though the guy across the table can see the hand. It's a tactical move. Politics is dirty. I rambled a lot. My bizad Thanks for the post! I still find it wrong to accept this way of playing politics. Even if it's the way our system works, that doesn't make it right. Half lies and white lies are still lies. It doesn't really make sense to me for a group to claim to stand for a higher moral cause and be zen with using immoral means of getting there.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted July 15, 2013 Posted July 15, 2013 (edited) There's absolutely nothing immoral about the means of tightening regulations and restrictions on abortion. As, I've pointed out, there's nothing safe about abortions, for either the mother or the baby. The fewer abortions, the safer everyone will be. Nobody's lying about anything. Wishing to protect the health/safety of women and the life of babies are not mutually exclusive goals. The safest and healthiest thing would no abortions, but until the supremely dishonest abortion of a Supreme Court ruling, Roe v. Wade, is overturned, pro-lifers will have to do with what restrictions we can get. You're arguing the same way I would in my high school theology classes whenever I'd get bored. This isn't a real argument. Do you actually believe they meant whatever you're implying? Edited July 15, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
KnightofChrist Posted July 15, 2013 Posted July 15, 2013 Thanks for the post! I still find it wrong to accept this way of playing politics. Even if it's the way our system works, that doesn't make it right. Half lies and white lies are still lies. It doesn't really make sense to me for a group to claim to stand for a higher moral cause and be zen with using immoral means of getting there. Those who supported slavery when states began to put restrictions on slavery probably attempted to use the same kind of 'lets us a twist view of morality against those with morals' logic. Even if this law was created with the intent of restricting abortion it doesn't make it a lie that it was also intended to tighten regulations on abortion.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted July 15, 2013 Posted July 15, 2013 (edited) Those who supported slavery when states began to put restrictions on slavery probably attempted to use the same kind of 'lets us a twist view of morality against those with morals' logic. Even if this law was created with the intent of restricting abortion it doesn't make it a lie that it was also intended to tighten regulations on abortion. And they would have been right if the abolitionists were being disingenuous. I can't believe I'm actually arguing with you guys on a point that Catholics taught me. The ends never justify the means. Nixon found this out the hard way. Edited July 15, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
KnightofChrist Posted July 15, 2013 Posted July 15, 2013 And they would have been right if the abolitionists were being disingenuous. I can't believe I'm actually arguing with you guys on a point that Catholics taught me. The ends never justify the means. Nixon found this out the hard way. I don't see this as a lie, like you see it. Having a dual purpose doesn't necessarily make the official purpose a lie.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted July 15, 2013 Posted July 15, 2013 I don't see this as a lie, like you see it. Having a dual purpose doesn't necessarily make the official purpose a lie. See, I'm fine with this position, if that's the case. However, as Ice has pointed out, there it seems there was a bit of a dirty political game played here. If true, I don't see why Catholics would be okay with this.
KnightofChrist Posted July 15, 2013 Posted July 15, 2013 (edited) See, I'm fine with this position, if that's the case. However, as Ice has pointed out, there it seems there was a bit of a dirty political game played here. If true, I don't see why Catholics would be okay with this. I don't believe their using this law as a political game. You'll have to talk to those who do and are ok with it, about that, I cannot read minds or hearts. Maybe it's similar to those who would lie to Nazis about hiding Jews in their house, or choosing the lesser of two evils. I don't know.I don't see the official stated purpose as a lie even if it has a secondary purpose of preventing more babies from being murdered in mass. Edited July 15, 2013 by KnightofChrist
Socrates Posted July 16, 2013 Posted July 16, 2013 You're arguing the same way I would in my high school theology classes whenever I'd get bored. This isn't a real argument. Do you actually believe they meant whatever you're implying? See, I'm fine with this position, if that's the case. However, as Ice has pointed out, there it seems there was a bit of a dirty political game played here. If true, I don't see why Catholics would be okay with this. Do I actually believe who meant what? Please show me what specifically in this bill is a lie that Catholics cannot support in good conscience. As I've said repeatedly, one can legitimately have multiple reasons or motivations for for an action, and protecting the health and safety of women and the lives of unborn children are not mutually exclusive goals. Also, one is not morally obligated to proclaim to everyone all of one's motivations for performing a certain action, so long as it does not actually involve lying (and you have not demonstrated that an actual lie is involved). Lying also involves the intent to deceive, and I don't think any actual attempt at deception is going on. Everyone knows that pro-lifers intend to save as many unborn lives as they can (and conversely, that "pro-choicers" want abortion to be as unrestricted as possible), and no one is denying this. Also, I fail to see how the "game" in this case is any "dirtier" than that involved in passing any piece of controversial legislation. (And, while this is not an argument, I find this new-found moral scrupulosity on the part of the advocates of legal baby-killing amusing and ironic. Some of those who are supposedly outraged over the alleged "dishonesty" of this bill are also consistent and adamant defenders of the Roe v. Wade ruling that got us into this whole mess. It is obvious from a study of that case that the justices who made this decision were motivated by a desire to have near-universal legal abortion, not by any actual honest concern that the Constitution was being violated. They used grotesque and tortured twisting of logic, and far-fetched extrapolations stretched to the breaking point, to make their "interpretation" of the Constitution support their desired predetermined outcome of a "right" to abortion. Not to mention that the plaintiff in that case lied about being raped, on the advice of her lawyers.)
Socrates Posted July 16, 2013 Posted July 16, 2013 (edited) It's not outright lying. Although Hasan likes to insinuate the average pro-lifer as a group of men who don't care about women only insofar as they would like to control them, their bodies and their sexuality (which I READILY admit that a number of pro-life men probably fit the bill, and that even larger swaths are simply insensitive in the sense they have never given more than 2 seconds of fleeting thought on the unjust obstacles that women face), most pro-lifers I've met do have concern for the women who face abortion, such concerns include: post abortive depression and other psychological complications, medical complications, and spiritual moral complications. Not to mention that at least half of those active in the pro-life movement are women. Trying to attack or dismiss pro-lifers as a group as misogynists not caring about women or being clueless about the concerns of women is absurd, when huge numbers of them are women. It's also stupid (and I'd say sexist) to blithely dismiss the female half of pro-lifers as all idiots or traitors to their sex. Also, I'm sure you can find hypocrites and @$$holes in any group of persons, but you can't use them to stereotype or dismiss the entire cause. Edited July 16, 2013 by Socrates
Ice_nine Posted July 17, 2013 Posted July 17, 2013 Thanks for the post! I still find it wrong to accept this way of playing politics. Even if it's the way our system works, that doesn't make it right. Half lies and white lies are still lies. It doesn't really make sense to me for a group to claim to stand for a higher moral cause and be zen with using immoral means of getting there. Again, I don't really see it as lying. Saying I want tighter medical restrictions (knowing full well it will reduce abortions) is not a lie. The motives as to why I want this are not being fully disclosed I guess. I've not read the bill, I don't know how the reasoning is officially explained but irreguardless (lololololol) I still don't see it as lying if the only reasons cited are medical reasons. I genuinely do believe that cranking open a woman's cervix and sucking out a fetus shouldn't be treated like a dental cleaning. That is absurd. As to my reasons why, do I have to reveal ALL of them up front? Especially when we all know what's going on? Not to mention that at least half of those active in the pro-life movement are women. Trying to attack or dismiss pro-lifers as a group as misogynists not caring about women or being clueless about the concerns of women is absurd, when huge numbers of them are women. It's also stupid (and I'd say sexist) to blithely dismiss the female half of pro-lifers as all idiots or traitors to their sex. All of them yes, but it's quite possible for women to be misogynist or at the very least have feelings of inferiority and inadequacy that they project onto the entire gender.
4588686 Posted July 17, 2013 Posted July 17, 2013 All of them yes, but it's quite possible for women to be misogynist or at the very least have feelings of inferiority and inadequacy that they project onto the entire gender. I am a woman, a wife, a mother, and a proud misogynist.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now