Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Tonight at Mass here in California, we had the Gospel reading of Martha and Mary followed by a very good homily about the reading. For some reason I heard it in a completely new way for me and it 'clicked' in my heart. I have always felt like a 'Mary' but for the past six years  I have been so busy wanting to 'be a nun' that perhaps I wandered into 'Martha' territory instead? Because tonight for some reason it seemed as if the Martha in me was complaining to Our Lord that she was tired of working so hard at something that hasn't borne any fruit. I know, it sounds strange, but it was really the first time that I felt I was both Martha and Mary- and not just Mary.

 

Tonight I heard Jesus saying to Martha that Mary was completely occupied in listening to God's word (Jesus Himself) and that this was the 'better' part so it wouldn't be taken from her - and the message I got from all of this was that I mustn't worry about what I am going to 'do' when I return to Australia or how I am going to serve God or try to respond to Him - but that I must just listen to His word and hear His voice in my heart. It was a very liberating feeling - as if a great weight had been lifted from me - a weight I didn't even know I was carrying!

 

Now I know there are many interpretations of this Gospel passage - and I am sure that it strikes different people in different ways at different times, so this isn't a Martha/Mary debate. It is one of my favorite passages in the Gospels and I was just reflecting on how I understood it tonight and wondering how others felt on hearing it again?

 

 

Sister Marie
Posted

There's a great book on this called "Having a Mary Heart in a Martha World" I think... the title could be slightly different.  I read it a few years ago and loved it.  A sister who I consider a saint gave me the book before she died and she was definitely the personification of having a Mary Heart in the midst of a Martha life.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

Whats wrong with martha, the Lord didn't rebuke her works of mercy/service, he rebuked her fussing about it. The Lord never stated Marthas works where bad or fruitless, just that mary was in a better position, marthas works are still very important to the Lord but her complaining not so much.

 

Onward christian souls.

JESUS iz LORD.

 

\St Teresa Benedicta of the cross, Pray for us.

 

P.s. this is just my own thoughts and i have no theological degree, just what i was thinking after reading fr cappies word and listening to the homily of our parish deacon last night and this morning.pretty raw deal as if she is lesser or something, her works i am sure are highly prized by the LORD.

Edited by Tab'le Du'Bah-Rye
Posted

There's a great book on this called "Having a Mary Heart in a Martha World" I think... the title could be slightly different.  I read it a few years ago and loved it.  A sister who I consider a saint gave me the book before she died and she was definitely the personification of having a Mary Heart in the midst of a Martha life.

 

 

Sounds like a good book. I have met a few cloistered nuns who seem to live out that ideal of being a Martha with a Mary heart. Perhaps the trick is not to separate the two but to integrate them fully?

Posted

These verses show us something more—they show us the wrong type of kindness. Think where Jesus was going when this happened. He was on his way to Jerusalem—to die. His whole being was taken up with the intensity of the inner battle to bend his will to the will of God. When Jesus came to that home in Bethany it was a great day; and Martha was eager to celebrate it by laying on the best the house could give. So she rushed and fussed and cooked; and that was precisely what Jesus did not want. All he wanted was quiet. With the cross before him and with the inner tension in his heart, he had turned aside to Bethany to find an oasis of calm away from the demanding crowds if only for an hour or two; and that is what Mary gave him and what Martha, in her kindness, did her best to destroy. “One thing is necessary”—quite possibly this means, “I don’t want a big spread; one course, the simplest meal is all I want.” It was simply that Mary understood and that Martha did not.

 

Here is one of the great difficulties in life. So often we want to be kind to people—but we want to be kind to them in our way; and should it happen that our way is not the necessary way, we sometimes take offence and think that we are not appreciated. If we are trying to be kind the first necessity is to try to see into the heart of the person we desire to help—and then to forget all our own plans and to think only of what he or she needs. Jesus loved Martha and Martha loved him, but when Martha set out to be kind, it had to be her way of being kind which was really being unkind to him whose heart cried out for quiet. Jesus loved Mary and Mary loved him, and Mary understood.

 

Posted (edited)

Cappie, Thank you, that was Beautiful.

 

Nunsense and Sister Marie, I do like your insights as well.

 

Much to pray over....

Edited by AnneLine
Posted

These verses show us something more—they show us the wrong type of kindness. Think where Jesus was going when this happened. He was on his way to Jerusalem—to die. His whole being was taken up with the intensity of the inner battle to bend his will to the will of God. When Jesus came to that home in Bethany it was a great day; and Martha was eager to celebrate it by laying on the best the house could give. So she rushed and fussed and cooked; and that was precisely what Jesus did not want. All he wanted was quiet. With the cross before him and with the inner tension in his heart, he had turned aside to Bethany to find an oasis of calm away from the demanding crowds if only for an hour or two; and that is what Mary gave him and what Martha, in her kindness, did her best to destroy. “One thing is necessary”—quite possibly this means, “I don’t want a big spread; one course, the simplest meal is all I want.” It was simply that Mary understood and that Martha did not.

 

Here is one of the great difficulties in life. So often we want to be kind to people—but we want to be kind to them in our way; and should it happen that our way is not the necessary way, we sometimes take offence and think that we are not appreciated. If we are trying to be kind the first necessity is to try to see into the heart of the person we desire to help—and then to forget all our own plans and to think only of what he or she needs. Jesus loved Martha and Martha loved him, but when Martha set out to be kind, it had to be her way of being kind which was really being unkind to him whose heart cried out for quiet. Jesus loved Mary and Mary loved him, and Mary understood.

 

 

Cappie- I never thought about it from Jesus' point of view before - and that is an amazing perspective. Thank you so much. It takes the whole story out of just the active/contemplative debate and puts it into an entirely new realm. This is such a good example of how the Gospels reveal themselves over time in so many different ways to people. The richness of scripture is such a great gift to us all, as well as the diverse ways in which they are interpreted. It shows that even though we might read the same passages over many years, each time they can mean something new to us and open us up to deeper understandings.

 

Really, a wonderful post- thank you for sharing.

Posted

Absolutely.   I have found great benefit over the years in the suggestion of a spiritual director to 'pray through Jesus eyes' sometimes.  And your insights, Father, prove the value of that....

 

And... (somewhat off THIS topic....)  == both Cappie and Nunsense...

 

I saw Nunsense's thread asking about the Secular Franciscans here in Transmundane Lane.  For some reason it has been archived. (?)  And no one can reply in there (?).   (dUSt's cleanup may be a little TOO Franciscan -- get rid of ALL the posts!!!)

 

If you want an answer, Nunsense, you may need to repost that... and perhaps Fr. Cappie can answer some of the questions you are raising.... and some of the rest of us might have some thoughts, too!

Posted (edited)

Always makes me think of this song. It's a sad song, but relevant in a lot of ways.

 

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ive-zxmqk3Q[/media]

 

I'm Mary and I'm Martha all at the same time;
I'm sitting at His feet and yet I'm dying to be recognized.
I am a picture of contentment and I'm dissatisfied.
Why is it easy to work and hard to rest sometimes?
I'm restless, and I rustle like a thousand tall trees;
I'm twisting and I'm turning in an endless daydream.
You wrestle me at night and I wake in search of You...
but try as I might, I just can't catch You
But I want to, because I need You, yes, I need You
I can't catch You, but I want to.

 

How long, how long until I'm home?

I'm so tired, so tired of running
How long until You come for me?
I'm so tired, so tired of running

Edited by MissyP89
Posted

Re Martha, Mary debate over contemplative Vs active: Graham Hutchings, a Methodist minister once said - there is a need occasionally to get the visionaries in the kitchen and the kitchenaries in the vision. :hehe2:

Posted

Re Martha, Mary debate over contemplative Vs active: Graham Hutchings, a Methodist minister once said - there is a need occasionally to get the visionaries in the kitchen and the kitchenaries in the vision. :hehe2:

 

 

Wish we still had props!  :)

Posted

:saint2:   Props from me as well, Fr. Cappie!

maximillion
Posted

Amen to all that.

 

Fascinating and profound. Thanks to all........

 

Oh and I do so hope we have our props back SOON.

 

 

 

Vincent Vega
Posted

These verses show us something more—they show us the wrong type of kindness. Think where Jesus was going when this happened. He was on his way to Jerusalem—to die. His whole being was taken up with the intensity of the inner battle to bend his will to the will of God. When Jesus came to that home in Bethany it was a great day; and Martha was eager to celebrate it by laying on the best the house could give. So she rushed and fussed and cooked; and that was precisely what Jesus did not want. All he wanted was quiet. With the cross before him and with the inner tension in his heart, he had turned aside to Bethany to find an oasis of calm away from the demanding crowds if only for an hour or two; and that is what Mary gave him and what Martha, in her kindness, did her best to destroy. “One thing is necessary”—quite possibly this means, “I don’t want a big spread; one course, the simplest meal is all I want.” It was simply that Mary understood and that Martha did not.

 

Here is one of the great difficulties in life. So often we want to be kind to people—but we want to be kind to them in our way; and should it happen that our way is not the necessary way, we sometimes take offence and think that we are not appreciated. If we are trying to be kind the first necessity is to try to see into the heart of the person we desire to help—and then to forget all our own plans and to think only of what he or she needs. Jesus loved Martha and Martha loved him, but when Martha set out to be kind, it had to be her way of being kind which was really being unkind to him whose heart cried out for quiet. Jesus loved Mary and Mary loved him, and Mary understood.

Thanks, Father. I was reflecting on this reading all throughout our Eucharist yesterday, and I had a hard time figuring out how to make sense of Jesus telling Martha not to work in a world that begs for work. This provides a very keen insight. I appreciate it.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

These verses show us something more—they show us the wrong type of kindness. Think where Jesus was going when this happened. He was on his way to Jerusalem—to die. His whole being was taken up with the intensity of the inner battle to bend his will to the will of God. When Jesus came to that home in Bethany it was a great day; and Martha was eager to celebrate it by laying on the best the house could give. So she rushed and fussed and cooked; and that was precisely what Jesus did not want. All he wanted was quiet. With the cross before him and with the inner tension in his heart, he had turned aside to Bethany to find an oasis of calm away from the demanding crowds if only for an hour or two; and that is what Mary gave him and what Martha, in her kindness, did her best to destroy. “One thing is necessary”—quite possibly this means, “I don’t want a big spread; one course, the simplest meal is all I want.” It was simply that Mary understood and that Martha did not.

 

Here is one of the great difficulties in life. So often we want to be kind to people—but we want to be kind to them in our way; and should it happen that our way is not the necessary way, we sometimes take offence and think that we are not appreciated. If we are trying to be kind the first necessity is to try to see into the heart of the person we desire to help—and then to forget all our own plans and to think only of what he or she needs. Jesus loved Martha and Martha loved him, but when Martha set out to be kind, it had to be her way of being kind which was really being unkind to him whose heart cried out for quiet. Jesus loved Mary and Mary loved him, and Mary understood.

 

 

Excellent reflection.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Perhaps if Martha had done her work quietly, without becoming bitter because Mary was at the feet of Jesus, she may have had a "Mary experience" while being Martha.

When I am bitter and angry, my thoughts are occupied with bitter and angry thoughts - reasons why I have the right to feel as disturbed as I do.  But when things are getting to me and I am stressing out over them (negative thinking), I find that if I use that energy to get stuck into something menial that needs doing, a Peace and calm returns and all the disturbance subsides i.e. I have a "Mary experience".

 

I never thought of this story from the angle of Jesus either.

Jesus had been pretty busy.  He is travelling through the various towns preaching the Gospel with His apostles and disciples.  Perhaps by the time He got to Bethany (roughly 2miles or so out of Jerusalem) and the home of His friends, He was tired and wanted some Peace and quiet and a good meal.  Mary certainly gave Him the Peace and quiet and He talked softly to her (all in my imagination) as Mary was banging the dishes and "Tsk!  Tsk' Tsking!" over Mary with Martha's thought racing around occupying her head about how unfair it all was.  Finally, she complains to Jesus about her sister.  Jesus takes the side of Mary, Martha's sister, telling her that Mary has chosen the better part.  So Martha goes back to her work humiliated and very quiet, except for the occasional bang of a dish not quite able to let go of anger..........and Jesus, and all, have a measure of quiet and Peace........and still have a good meal to boot.  If Martha had gone about her work quietly, she may have overheard what Jesus was saying and her heart would have filled with wonder.  

 

The Martha and Mary story is always a great meditation and now I have some new angles.

 

Life is often, as nunsense commented, a matter of Martha and Mary living as one (integrated) and it really is amazing how when the two are integrated into the one person just how each is totally fulfilled and that fulfilment is a unity.  Sometimes Martha leads, sometimes Mary but both are working together.  Now and then (more then than now) I get there.  It is not the achieving so much as it is the continual striving despite failures and things coming adrift. Then it is simply "Try again!" in failure and drifting.  Thanksgiving and Praise to The Lord for His Grace in any success. 

"Lord grant success to the work of our hands". (Psalm, Divine Office

 

 

Posted

Perhaps if Martha had done her work quietly, without becoming bitter because Mary was at the feet of Jesus, she may have had a "Mary experience" while being Martha.

When I am bitter and angry, my thoughts are occupied with bitter and angry thoughts - reasons why I have the right to feel as disturbed as I do.  But when things are getting to me and I am stressing out over them (negative thinking), I find that if I use that energy to get stuck into something menial that needs doing, a Peace and calm returns and all the disturbance subsides i.e. I have a "Mary experience".

 

I never thought of this story from the angle of Jesus either.

Jesus had been pretty busy.  He is travelling through the various towns preaching the Gospel with His apostles and disciples.  Perhaps by the time He got to Bethany (roughly 2miles or so out of Jerusalem) and the home of His friends, He was tired and wanted some Peace and quiet and a good meal.  Mary certainly gave Him the Peace and quiet and He talked softly to her (all in my imagination) as Mary was banging the dishes and "Tsk!  Tsk' Tsking!" over Mary with Martha's thought racing around occupying her head about how unfair it all was.  Finally, she complains to Jesus about her sister.  Jesus takes the side of Mary, Martha's sister, telling her that Mary has chosen the better part.  So Martha goes back to her work humiliated and very quiet, except for the occasional bang of a dish not quite able to let go of anger..........and Jesus, and all, have a measure of quiet and Peace........and still have a good meal to boot.  If Martha had gone about her work quietly, she may have overheard what Jesus was saying and her heart would have filled with wonder.  

 

The Martha and Mary story is always a great meditation and now I have some new angles.

 

Life is often, as nunsense commented, a matter of Martha and Mary living as one (integrated) and it really is amazing how when the two are integrated into the one person just how each is totally fulfilled and that fulfilment is a unity.  Sometimes Martha leads, sometimes Mary but both are working together.  Now and then (more then than now) I get there.  It is not the achieving so much as it is the continual striving despite failures and things coming adrift. Then it is simply "Try again!" in failure and drifting.  Thanksgiving and Praise to The Lord for His Grace in any success. 

"Lord grant success to the work of our hands". (Psalm, Divine Office

 

 

 

My only question about this depiction of the Martha and Mary story is the portrayal of Martha's reaction after Jesus had spoken to her. as being humiliated and then returning to the kitchen angry enough to bang pots. :)

 

 

If I am going to imagine and embellish scriptural stories, I like to make them a little more positive. Since Jesus was the Incarnation of Love, I prefer to think that His gentle rebuke was said with so much love that Martha immediately felt humbled (not humiliated) and sat down at His feet with Mary to listen to Him.

 

Then (if we continue the imagination), after listening to Him for awhile, I see her either getting up and returning to her work feeling much refreshed and able to cope without Mary or even listening until He had finished what He was saying completely and then both Martha and Mary going into the kitchen to prepare the meal together in a spirit of love.

 

Mary+and+Martha++Vermeer_opt.jpg

 

Just my perspective on it.

Posted (edited)

My only question about this depiction of the Martha and Mary story is the portrayal of Martha's reaction after Jesus had spoken to her. as being humiliated and then returning to the kitchen angry enough to bang pots. :)

 

I see what you mean there, Nunsense... but I know my own experience tends to be that I do EXACTLY that initially.  And then slowly the Lord's word and grace kind of quiets me down, and I start the move from humiliated to humbled... and then I am able to listen.  And I would imagine... if this was me going forward... that Jesus, who knew her, and her loving heart SO WELL, would know that she would get to that place, and he would raise his voice just a bit.... and address her loving heart in a way that she could listen to him as she finished up the dinner....

 

If I am going to imagine and embellish scriptural stories, I like to make them a little more positive. Since Jesus was the Incarnation of Love, I prefer to think that His gentle rebuke was said with so much love that Martha immediately felt humbled (not humiliated) and sat down at His feet with Mary to listen to Him.

 

Then (if we continue the imagination), after listening to Him for awhile, I see her either getting up and returning to her work feeling much refreshed and able to cope without Mary or even listening until He had finished what He was saying completely and then both Martha and Mary going into the kitchen to prepare the meal together in a spirit of love.

 

I could see your scenario.... in mine, as Martha brought in the dinner, the serving was delayed just a second while they all embraced in His love....

 

They had a meal that was truly a small 'e' 'eucharist' -- a meal of thanksgiving and fellowship, gathered in love together around the table with the Lord --

 

And all 4 of them did the dishes together with great joy after the meal!  And NO banging of pots!

 

Just my perspective on it.

 

Yup!     "And God saw that all that He had created was GOOD!"

 

Edited by AnneLine
Posted (edited)

My manner of meditating very often is to put myself into the story just as I am and imagine my own personal reactions within the context of the story - my reactions not as I hope they would be but as they very likely could be.  In my imagination, I was Martha.  Jesus to me was not a wishy washy sort of person - his criticism of the Pharisees and at times others reveal that if He had something to say, then He simply said it.  I really love this about Jesus.  To my way of thought, Jesus would reach out to the other in an attempt to call them to change (behaviour) as in the Martha Mary story.  Jesus could be quite brisk or cutting times!  (As with Peter "Get behind me Satan!" = poor Peter, He was only very concerned about Jesus)  Although in the Martha/Mary story, I imagine Jesus turning very gently to Martha and simply commenting "Mary has chosen the better part" and then turning back to Mary.  But Martha (or me) rather regularly do not take a type of criticism joyfully initially at all, I can react in very negative ways. So Martha heats up with the criticism (and indirectly it was criticism) and negative thinking occupies and bounces around her mind as she bangs the dishes (a habit of my Mum's if upset).  This was the side of me I put into the story as a focused part of me and my reactions at times.

 

Then I began to reflect on the overall story I had presented to myself with Martha as me and how the story could be turned around from something negative into something positive in Martha by reflecting on a change of behaviour on the part of Martha or me.

 

There are many ways of prayerfully meditating and many ways of teasing out of a meditation what one needs to take.  And all are valid to me.  :)

Edited by BarbaraTherese
Posted

Yes, Barb - it's amazing how many ways there are to meditate on scripture. I hadn't seen this whole story from Jesus' point of view as described by Cappie until I read his post.

 

Lately though I have to admit that I want to be a Martha (keeping busy) because I am finding being Mary (contemplative) difficult right now. I am waiting for something and I never wait well. I could be using the time as I did in my hermit days, as a Mary, but right now I am finding that very difficult so I just want to keep busy. But there isn't really enough to keep me as busy as I would like because I have to wait for one thing before another is possible.

 

Life is amusing, isn't it?

 

 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...