Apotheoun Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 Ah yes, but that isn't an option easily available if one has made solemn profession... That is when a person needs to go to his superiors (i.e., meaning those above his direct superiors) in order to seek redress of his grievance. Obedience is always obedience in truth.
Anselm Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 Quite, but taking into account the extent of change within such changes in the last 40 years I can't imagine that individual representations would get very far, sadly.
Apotheoun Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 (edited) Thankfully, when looking at the Legionaries of Christ situation, people eventually went to their superiors (i.e., those above their direct superiors) and the Church was able begin to correct the problems in that order. None of the Legionaries owed any obedience to Fr. Marcial Maciel when he was committing his crimes. Edited July 29, 2013 by Apotheoun
Apotheoun Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 Quite, but taking into account the extent of change within such changes in the last 40 years I can't imagine that individual representations would get very far, sadly. There is truth in what you are saying here, and that is probably why religious life in the United States (and many other countries) is in trouble.
Anselm Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 Quite, but isn't there a difference between those religious who believe that their superior has broken a criminal law from those who suspect that their superior's theology is a little suspicious?
Apotheoun Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 Quite, but isn't there a difference between those religious who believe that their superior has broken a criminal law from those who suspect that their superior's theology is a little suspicious? I don't think so. Clearly you cannot go along with criminal activity, but I don't think it is right, proper, or just to go along with a person's heresies either. After all, we are talking about a person's eternal salvation.
Anselm Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 You're absolutely right, but I can imagine that many would be naturally much swifter in acting upon a law clearly broken than church dogma, whatever we may think of that. Thankfully in the UK we don't appear to have such a division, though that may be because of a smaller number of religious overall.
Apotheoun Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 I have no problem saying that if I had lived in Constantinople in the first half of the 4th century I would not have gone along with Nestorios in his Christological heresy.
Sister Marie Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 But the orders aren't members of the club, their superiors are. It's not like a governance thing, it's more like a social club. Of course it's a problem when the LCWR leaders are doing not-kosher stuff, but like Sister Marie said, members of the orders aren't members of the LCWR, so we shouldn't make the assumption that they'd automatically agree with everything the LCWR does. Thanks Basilisa... my general superior belongs to the LCWR. I honestly haven't heard any conversation within my community about any of the stances of the LCWR or anything like that. It's not like its some big organization that really impacts our lives. It doesn't impact mine at all. The only time I hear about or talk about the LCWR is like this with people outside of religious life. The average sister is really not involved at all. She's busy living her religious life, ministering to people, praying... Part of the culture of religious life is not to put on show any disagreements for the public either... so if there are superiors who disagree with the direction of the LCWR but are still a part of it, they may have voiced their concerns to the proper authorities but they aren't going to go on NBC and tell everyone. It's just not the way religious deal with problems. The truth is none of us, other than the sisters directly involved, know what has been said or done behind the scenes. For all we know, the visitation and the doctrinal assessment could be the result of general superiors who belong to the organization reporting issues. I don't know how to quote but I saw the next comment that was asking about obedience. Are some people disobedient? Absolutely. For no good reason? I'm sure there are some! However, I do think that there are a lot of religious women who have lost the trust in the Church that is necessary for obedience to be lived out. Where I live right now, obedience was used as a way to cover up the rape and molestation of children by priests. If a sister refused to drop an issue in a school of a child being molested or raped, in some circumstances, the diocese fired her even if there was proof. If she wasn't fired, she was moved by her community out of fear of retribution by the bishop. In that case, she owed no obedience to the bishop who was asking her to do something immoral... her obedience was primarily to the Gospel of Jesus. But the bishops pitted her love for the Church and her vow of obedience against the Gospel. You don't get over that easily. Trust is needed for obedience to flourish and the relationships between the male leaders of the Church and women religious have been damaged. I have personally never been through something like that, thank you Jesus, but if I had, I don't know if I would ever be able to trust another bishop to tell me the morally right thing to do. It really would destroy me. I have given my life to teaching children and bringing them closer to God and to have my conscience violated so a man could sexually abuse one of those children would really, well, destroy me. I have heard horrible stories about some of the things that were done to my own sisters at the hands of the men of the Church and, even if they were immoral, the sisters had nowhere to turn. (Tonight at dinner one of the sisters was just telling the story of a Msgr. who refused to allow anyone but a white and blonde girl be the May queen in a predominantly african american parish in recent history. It was disgusting but since he was the pastor, it didn't matter how immoral and unchristian his decision was.) Now, I know, you aren't talking about covering up rape or molestation or discriminating against children based on the color of their skin. But something like that really leaves a scar on a religious and its a wound that needs healing and there hasn't been any healing. In my opinion, and it is only that, healing must happen before obedience can be forced. Maybe the more virtuous thing would be to stoically deny oneself and grin and bear it and just give in and do what one is being told to do - but I don't think that makes for a good religious. I think it makes for someone bitter and angry and hopeless and for someone who can't make sense out of what happened in the Church. After the things I outlined above women religious need to hear that the Church values them and that they won't force them to be their foot soldiers in covering up abuse and discrimination. It seems silly because, of course the Church doesn't want that, but it has been the reality for some women and that needs to be healed.
Apotheoun Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 You're absolutely right, but I can imagine that many would be naturally much swifter in acting upon a law clearly broken than church dogma, whatever we may think of that. Thankfully in the UK we don't appear to have such a division, though that may be because of a smaller number of religious overall. That is a common enough viewpoint, but it is a strange one to me, because breaking a law can lead to punishment in this life; while embracing heresy (or remaining silent and possibly allowing others to be deceived) has eternal consequences.
Anselm Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 That is a common enough viewpoint, but it is a strange one to me, because breaking a law can lead to punishment in this life; while embracing heresy (or remaining silent and possibly allowing others to be deceived) has eternal consequences. Yes but I didn't say that it was right, did I? All I said was that it is common. However, if you're talking about everlasting consequences, I'm sure Our Lord will not judge those contemplative religious who did not agree with the potentially heretical opinions of their superiors but who kept silent through holy obedience.
Apotheoun Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 Yes but I didn't say that it was right, did I? All I said was that it is common. However, if you're talking about everlasting consequences, I'm sure Our Lord will not judge those contemplative religious who did not agree with the potentially heretical opinions of their superiors but who kept silent through holy obedience. St. Maximos the Confessor was a monk, but he was anything but silent in the face of the monothelite heresy. Of course he also suffered a martyrs death for his fidelity to Christ. :smile3:
Anselm Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 St. Maximos the Confessor was a monk, but he was anything but silent in the face of the monothelite heresy. Of course he also suffered a martyrs death for his fidelity to Christ. :smile3: So? He had hardly spent a quiet, contemplative life up to then. As much as I admire him he was a professional theologian and debater.
BG45 Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 CrossCuT, is your boyfriend considering joining the Catholic Church? He seems to keep bringing up some rather pointed disagreements with Catholicism to you; which I know that personally, I was desperate to find fault with the Church when I was scared of converting.
Apotheoun Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 (edited) So? He had hardly spent a quiet, contemplative life up to then. As much as I admire him he was a professional theologian and debater. In the 7th century there was no such thing as a "professional theologian." And in the Eastern Christian tradition all monks and nuns are contemplative, the modern Western proclivity of breaking things and people into different categories has never been accepted in the East. As far as the distinction between a martyr and a confessor is concerned, it is a quibble, because he ultimately died for defending the Orthodox faith and bore the effects of the passion in his body by the torture inflicted upon him. A torture that eventually brought about his death for Christ. Edited July 29, 2013 by Apotheoun
Apotheoun Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 The following is a life of St. Maximus the Confessor and Martyr compiled by St. Demetrius of Rostov The Twenty-First Day of the Month of January The Life of Our Holy Monastic Father Maximus the Confessor and Martyr
CrossCuT Posted July 29, 2013 Author Posted July 29, 2013 CrossCuT, is your boyfriend considering joining the Catholic Church? He seems to keep bringing up some rather pointed disagreements with Catholicism to you; which I know that personally, I was desperate to find fault with the Church when I was scared of converting. He already went through RCIA and received his sacraments this past Easter. I know his intentions are good but I was honestly trying to understand this topic more myself because I felt that this couldnt have been as big of an issue as it has blown up to be. Sister Maries last post helped a lot. Seems like there are some rogue sisters out there who made it appear as if the majority is behind them.
Anselm Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 In the 7th century there was no such thing as a "professional theologian." And in the Eastern Christian tradition all monks and nuns are contemplative, the modern Western proclivity of breaking things and people into different categories has never been accepted in the East. As far as the distinction between a martyr and a confessor is concerned, it is a quibble, because he ultimately died for defending the Orthodox faith and bore the effects of the passion in his body by the torture inflicted upon him. A torture that eventually brought about his death for Christ. In the Western Christian Tradition, there is and most of his academic career was spent in western, Latin, Carthage. In any case, the proving of the opinions of one saint hardly proves the case. Again, in the Western Church he is a Confessor, not a Martyr.
Anselm Posted July 29, 2013 Posted July 29, 2013 He already went through RCIA and received his sacraments this past Easter. I know his intentions are good but I was honestly trying to understand this topic more myself because I felt that this couldnt have been as big of an issue as it has blown up to be. Sister Maries last post helped a lot. Seems like there are some rogue sisters out there who made it appear as if the majority is behind them. Crosscut, the problem is when they democratically represent the whole - then they technically do represent all of those in their communities.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now