KnightofChrist Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Obviously, as Catholics, we find it very harsh (and not true!) Catholics or not it is harsh and it is a falsehood. It makes me very sad for the kid... I will pray for them.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 (edited) Yes. Really. If she lied would she lie? This is what you are asking? Yeah if she lied it would be a lie. Please reread my question and answer it again. If you would like me to clarify, I will. Edited July 31, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
KnightofChrist Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Please reread my question and answer it again. If you would like me to clarify, I will. No. I gave my answer, if she lied to them that there was no life after death she would have told a lie. And frankly no one would ever find comfort in the lie that mom is dead and completely nonexistent now. Good night, God bless.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 (edited) No. I gave my answer, if she lied to them that there was no life after death she would have told a lie. And frankly no one would ever find comfort in the lie that mom is dead and completely nonexistent now. Good night, God bless. Avoiding the question. So telling the children honestly that there isn't an afterlife was only wrong because you consider it a lie. Lying to comfort people in general is not okay? Good night. Edited July 31, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
TheresaThoma Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 So kind of back on topic. My mom is pretty much agnostic, potentially borderline atheist. So after my dad passed away we have had a couple of conversations about what happens after death (ok maybe not conversations but her just wondering aloud and me listening). She wasn't certain about an afterlife at all. Hearing her talk about it I saw that there was a whole extra layer of pain and confusion in her grief. Where I had been able to seek comfort from Holy Mother Church my mom has nothing. I'm not sure how to adress that layer, except for accepting that it is present and she will have to work through that. (So on a whole different note as far as what to say. If the person doesn't mention it don't bring it up. They are probably just trying to find some normalcy, when everyone around you is constantly trying to console you it is exhausting. One of the best things my friend did for me after my dad died was to call me and just have a normal conversation with me, she didn't mention my dad but because she called I knew that she cared without having to say anything. That said just try to act normal, let them know that you heard about their loss but don't make it a major event/topic. Ok I'm off my soapbox now)
Anomaly Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 (edited) Lying is a sin in Catholicism, so speaking according to one's conscience and being honest must have been the right thing, no?It's not a lie if you believe it. Judging the "harshness" of what she said is impossible without knowing the context of the entire conversation. It's a lie if Catholic adults say mom is in heaven with God and angels looking down on you when the Catholic "truth" is: -Few get to heaven. -Only God knows His final judgement. -Mom may be in hell regenerating flesh that will be burned away for eternal agony. -Mom may be in suffering in Purgatory for a million years in agony for temporal imperfections. -Grandson faces the same agony that will last much longer than imaginable in the best case scenario when he inevitably dies. -Odds are slim if grandson will ever see his mom again even if there is an afterlife. Edited July 31, 2013 by Anomaly
Era Might Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 (edited) A Christian is one who has hope. That is what makes a Christian a Christian. I guess non-Christians can put things delicately for children, but that's all just beside the point. We assume that non-Christians have no hope, whether they phrase it in stoic bravery or secular realism. All Christians can do is witness to the hope that is in them, which is Christ and nothing else. We do not hope in an afterlife, which is a hopeless hope where we project ourselves, a sort of Life pt. 2. Instead, we hope in Christ the man. Edited July 31, 2013 by Era Might
HisChildForever Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Just out of curiosity, would you consider that a Catholic wasn't being honest if they had answered with a flat out yes, there is an afterlife? Because after all, there's no way you can be 100% positive. Do you think Catholic (or Christian of any stripe) parents should tell their children, "we believe there is an afterlife but some don't and it's what you believe in your heart that's important." I would focus on "we believe" statements. And if questions ever arose about someone else's religion (or non-religion), I'd tell them that it's important to understand not everyone shares our faith. Then when the questions come about why are they different from us, I'd tell them not to focus so much on the other person's faith but about the joy we get from ours.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 (edited) A Christian is one who has hope. That is what makes a Christian a Christian. I guess non-Christians can put things delicately for children, but that's all just beside the point. We assume that non-Christians have no hope, whether they phrase it in stoic bravery or secular realism. All Christians can do is witness to the hope that is in them, which is Christ and nothing else. We do not hope in an afterlife, which is a hopeless hope where we project ourselves, a sort of Life pt. 2. Instead, we hope in Christ the man. It's interesting to see the different perspectives on this topic. Btw, when were you a mod? How did I miss this? Edited July 31, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
Era Might Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 It's interesting to see the different perspectives on this topic. Btw, when were you a mod? How did I miss this? When laws were stern and justice stood, and people were behaving like they ought to: good.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 I would focus on "we believe" statements. And if questions ever arose about someone else's religion (or non-religion), I'd tell them that it's important to understand not everyone shares our faith. Then when the questions come about why are they different from us, I'd tell them not to focus so much on the other person's faith but about the joy we get from ours. Lol, that would be harder to say verbatim as an atheist. Statements like, "we believe there is no afterlife" or "there is no afterlife" will have similar effects on a child. There are better ways to go about explaining that there's no afterlife. I don't know if sugarcoating it is a better option. This brings me back to the Dawkins thread. I can see parallels, though I think the idea of eternal hellfire is more damaging than that of nonexistence. I'm mainly conflicted because I would prefer to let my children read a bunch and come up with their own conclusions about such questions.
Anomaly Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 I'm mainly conflicted because I would prefer to let my children read a bunch and come up with their own conclusions about such questions.Why would you just abandon your children to other people's opinion and supposition? In reality, individuals know little for sure. Scientists operate under reasonable theories and suppositions. Have you seem an electron or proton? You accept others work in theory as reasonable and worthy of acceptance. An atheist is exactly like a Christian, accepting the unprovable as a fact to believe.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 (edited) Why would you just abandon your children to other people's opinion and supposition? In reality, individuals know little for sure. Scientists operate under reasonable theories and suppositions. Have you seem an electron or proton? You accept others work in theory as reasonable and worthy of acceptance. An atheist is exactly like a Christian, accepting the unprovable as a fact to believe. Hey there! This is a good question. In my opinion, the question of the existence of a divine entity is a very important one. Ideally, I would want my children to read through various religious texts and views on the existence of God before they make a decision. I'd prefer that they explore this issue for themselves instead of have me tell them what to believe. I don't know if we can say that not seeing an electron or a proton is the same as not seeing a God. We can see the effects of an electron and our knowledge of protons and electrons has real world applications. Also, our understanding of science can change. If a bunch of new findings come out suggesting that what we know about gravity is wrong, we won't hold on to the same old ideas. Here's a portion of an article because I'm too lazy to summarize: Ernest Rutherford fired alpha particles (other tiny things you can’t see!) at gold foil and looked at the pattern the particles made after hitting the foil. This pattern indicated that the atoms of gold had a closely packed, positively charged nucleus. The reasoning behind this picture of an atom had to do with the fact that alpha particles are positively charged and would be repelled by a positively charged nucleus. Although most alpha particles went straight through the gold foil, some “bounced off†at sharp angles, even to the point of heading back in the direction from which they came. Only a closely packed, positively charged, nucleus of a gold atom could accomplish this. This experiment, plus many others like it, plus observations of chemical reactions, nuclear reactions, and the light that substances emit, all combine to give us a particular picture of what atoms look like. Just as with that dark room in which you can’t turn on the lights, though, we cannot isolate a single atom and look directly at it to see if our drawings are correct. The important thing is that everything we observe is consistent with our current view of atoms. The same statement goes for all sorts of other scientific models, such as quarks, electric and magnetic fields, and black holes. They’re useful models because they explain our observations and help us predict new observations. http://www.nsta.org/publications/news/story.aspx?id=51054 I wouldn't say an atheist necessarily accepts unprovable facts. As we discussed earlier, labels can be misleading. My definition of an atheist is merely someone who doesn't believe in a higher power. I would never claim that a god doesn't exist. My answer is simply, "I don't know". Edited July 31, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
Era Might Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 I would want my children to read through various religious texts and views on the existence of God before they make a decision. I'd prefer that they explore this issue for themselves instead of have me tell them what to believe. What room does that leave for surprise in life? Life's too short, in my experience, to be afraid to enter it. Everyone needs a community to grow into, and maybe to grow out of. All religions grow out of some community context, and even within Christianity, there is no such thing as a "general Christian." Christians are shaped by their particular communities, particular saints, particular historical circumstances, etc. To put all this another way, St. Paul could never have been knocked off his horse if he had never gotten on one with his pre-existing zeal. Love, too, does not exist in a vacuum. Love is the result of relationship, not the creator of one. You grow to love a person because you know them already, because you have decided to go on the journey with them already. Personally, I think science is a very poor model for life. Scientists chase facts, not meaning. And even scientists are only able to find facts once they enter the community of science, with all its rituals, sacrifices, relationships, guiding principles, etc. It's unfortunate when we don't have a soil to grow into: cultural soil, literary soil, religious soil, family soil. You only get about 100 years if you're lucky, why waste it trying to be a "generic person."
Guest Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 It's not a lie if you believe it. Judging the "harshness" of what she said is impossible without knowing the context of the entire conversation. It's a lie if Catholic adults say mom is in heaven with God and angels looking down on you when the Catholic "truth" is: -Few get to heaven. -Only God knows His final judgement. -Mom may be in hell regenerating flesh that will be burned away for eternal agony. -Mom may be in suffering in Purgatory for a million years in agony for temporal imperfections. -Grandson faces the same agony that will last much longer than imaginable in the best case scenario when he inevitably dies. -Odds are slim if grandson will ever see his mom again even if there is an afterlife. hahha word....what hope !
Anomaly Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 Hey there! This is a good question. In my opinion, the question of the existence of a divine entity is a very important one. Ideally, I would want my children to read through various religious texts and views on the existence of God before they make a decision. I'd prefer that they explore this issue for themselves instead of have me tell them what to believe. I don't know if we can say that not seeing an electron or a proton is the same as not seeing a God. We can see the effects of an electron and our knowledge of protons and electrons has real world applications. Also, our understanding of science can change. If a bunch of new findings come out suggesting that what we know about gravity is wrong, we won't hold on to the same old ideas. I wouldn't say an atheist necessarily accepts unprovable facts. As we discussed earlier, labels can be misleading. My definition of an atheist is merely someone who doesn't believe in a higher power. I would never claim that a god doesn't exist. My answer is simply, "I don't know".Agnostic is not atheist. The human experience of life is more than energized matter interacting in sophisticated and measurable reactions. My happiness in my children's laughter is more than a carbon based entity physiologically reacting to vibrations in the atmosphere. Just because I, and they, will eventually cease to exist, doesn't make it meaningless to us now. That meaning and value to our current (temporary) existence does not require or lend itself to scientific physical measurement and "proof" to be real. Reason, rational logic, and observation provides self aware individuals to means comprehend and experience our shared existence of things that can't be distilled in apparatus. If a tree falls in a forest without witness, does it mean it never stood previously and grew from a sapling? Human intellect can imagine and appreciate the beauty of its leaves many summers previously without ever sitting in its shade or counting its leaves.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 (edited) Agnostic is not atheist. You're right. Agnosticism answers the epistemological question of whether we can, or ever will be able to, know whether God exists. Atheism answers whether one believes in a god. That's why one can be an agnostic theist or an agnostic atheist. The human experience of life is more than energized matter interacting in sophisticated and measurable reactions. My happiness in my children's laughter is more than a carbon based entity physiologically reacting to vibrations in the atmosphere. Just because I, and they, will eventually cease to exist, doesn't make it meaningless to us now. That meaning and value to our current (temporary) existence does not require or lend itself to scientific physical measurement and "proof" to be real. Reason, rational logic, and observation provides self aware individuals to means comprehend and experience our shared existence of things that can't be distilled in apparatus. If a tree falls in a forest without witness, does it mean it never stood previously and grew from a sapling? Human intellect can imagine and appreciate the beauty of its leaves many summers previously without ever sitting in its shade or counting its leaves. Very well written. Agreed. Edited July 31, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
CatholicsAreKewl Posted July 31, 2013 Posted July 31, 2013 (edited) What room does that leave for surprise in life? Life's too short, in my experience, to be afraid to enter it. Everyone needs a community to grow into, and maybe to grow out of. All religions grow out of some community context, and even within Christianity, there is no such thing as a "general Christian." Christians are shaped by their particular communities, particular saints, particular historical circumstances, etc. To put all this another way, St. Paul could never have been knocked off his horse if he had never gotten on one with his pre-existing zeal. Love, too, does not exist in a vacuum. Love is the result of relationship, not the creator of one. You grow to love a person because you know them already, because you have decided to go on the journey with them already. Personally, I think science is a very poor model for life. Scientists chase facts, not meaning. And even scientists are only able to find facts once they enter the community of science, with all its rituals, sacrifices, relationships, guiding principles, etc. It's unfortunate when we don't have a soil to grow into: cultural soil, literary soil, religious soil, family soil. You only get about 100 years if you're lucky, why waste it trying to be a "generic person." Lol, I must really suhck at expressing my views because so far I've gotten two responses that I mostly agree with. Edited July 31, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
CatholicsAreKewl Posted August 1, 2013 Posted August 1, 2013 (edited) What room does that leave for surprise in life? Life's too short, in my experience, to be afraid to enter it. Everyone needs a community to grow into, and maybe to grow out of. All religions grow out of some community context, and even within Christianity, there is no such thing as a "general Christian." Christians are shaped by their particular communities, particular saints, particular historical circumstances, etc. To put all this another way, St. Paul could never have been knocked off his horse if he had never gotten on one with his pre-existing zeal. Love, too, does not exist in a vacuum. Love is the result of relationship, not the creator of one. You grow to love a person because you know them already, because you have decided to go on the journey with them already. Personally, I think science is a very poor model for life. Scientists chase facts, not meaning. And even scientists are only able to find facts once they enter the community of science, with all its rituals, sacrifices, relationships, guiding principles, etc. It's unfortunate when we don't have a soil to grow into: cultural soil, literary soil, religious soil, family soil. You only get about 100 years if you're lucky, why waste it trying to be a "generic person." I reread your post and I think I might understand it more now. I still don't really disagree with it. It's a valid point. I believe a child can still grow in a non-religious community. I'm not opposed to taking my child through religious schooling. The way I was brought up was Catholic, true, but I didn't actually take it seriously until I made the decision. I think the reason why great Christian writers like Chesterton were so sure of their faith was because they went through a spiritual journey. It'll be hard for me not to influence my children with my belief system, mainly because I can't answer every question with, "some people say this, others say this". However, I would prefer that I help them learn about many religions at an age when they can actually decide for themselves. Whether my children end up as Hindus, Christians, Atheists, or Muslims, they'll be sure of their beliefs and understand how they relate to the beliefs of others. Edited August 1, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
Guest Posted August 1, 2013 Posted August 1, 2013 Have your children believe in Love...Its a good start...If they have that they will be ok...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now