Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

BeenaBobba
Posted

Hi everyone,

I know that there was homosexuality in ancient Greece, but to the best of my knowledge, the homosexuality practiced was predominately pedophilial and wasn't really accepted by the population as a whole. But does anyone have evidence of this? I could really use it for a debate I'm having with political Liberals and atheists.

God bless,

Jennifer

Posted

I would also be interested in this because being of Greek decent, a lot of jokes are made about the Greeks so called invention and practice of homosexual sex.

Posted

[quote name='BeenaBobba' date='Jun 2 2004, 02:34 AM'] Hi everyone,

I know that there was homosexuality in ancient Greece, but to the best of my knowledge, the homosexuality practiced was predominately pedophilial and wasn't really accepted by the population as a whole. But does anyone have evidence of this? I could really use it for a debate I'm having with political Liberals and atheists.

God bless,

Jennifer [/quote]
I can't say if the Greeks invented this, but the "practice" was based on an elder man (old) and a youth. This was a passage rite, not scorned at the time at all, that would instill in the youth the "knowledge" of the elder and give "youth" to the elder.

BeenaBobba
Posted

Does anyone have evidence of this from the writings of those who lived back then? I know that there is evidence that pedophilial homosexuality was [i]tolerated[/i] at the [b]very most[/b] (but was never really approved of), but I don't have the quotes or sources at the time. I could really use some. (Hint, hint! ;) )

God bless,

Jennifer

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

I know that there was pedaphilic homosexual activity in ancient Greece and in ancient Rome. Actually, one documentary said that it was custom for the man to give gifts to the children in exchange for "services".

I do think there was a lot of all kinds of sexual activity. I'm sure it wasn't soon after the fall that people began experimenting with these things, and we have proof of pretty bizarre sexual practices. In Pompeii, some of the best preserved images were of sexual acts...I've been there and seen the images...the ancient Romans were a sick-minded people.

1337 k4th0l1x0r
Posted

Keep in mind in your debate that the ancient Greek civilization that had those practices didn't last for more than several hundred years. The same is true for the Roman empire. The Catholic Church, however, is alive and kickin after 2000 years with strong morality and virtues.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote]Keep in mind in your debate that the ancient Greek civilization that had those practices didn't last for more than several hundred years. The same is true for the Roman empire. The Catholic Church, however, is alive and kickin after 2000 years with strong morality and virtues.[/quote]

The Roman Empire lasted about 5 centuries, but keep in mind that Rome itself, as a nation, lasted more than a millenium.

  • 4 years later...
Posted

So has anyone found sources on this yet?

It may be pertinent for California these days? Maybe?

Did Rome or the Greeks give legal status to homosexual 'marriages'?

I've read Tertullian's apologetics, and he described the behaviors of pagans (sexual practices amongst others) and he was sickened by them lke any Christian was, just like christians are sickened by perversed acts today.

Nothing much has changed if you ask me.

Posted

+J.M.J.+
okay, this is a legit resurrection

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1705226' date='Nov 20 2008, 12:25 AM']+J.M.J.+
okay, this is a legit resurrection[/quote]


Peace and love for everyone!
:hippie:

Posted

Do a google on greeks romans homosexuality - seems there is quite a bit of info out there.

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1705492' date='Nov 20 2008, 08:23 AM']Do a google on greeks romans homosexuality - seems there is quite a bit of info out there.[/quote]

Google it?!!
Are you serious? Geez, I never thought of that. <_<


How do you weed out the BS from the facts found in google?



Let me rephrase the question: Does anyone have[u][i] reliable[/i][/u] info that can be refered to on this subject?

Posted

Wikipedia's entry on homosexuality in Ancient Greece seems pretty decent to me, and corresponds with the philosophers and history I've read.

From what I can gather, homosexual relations were common but still somewhat controversial among the Ancient Greeks, and it was almost exclusively a relationship between a man and a teenage boy (pederasty).

There were periods in Ancient Rome where Greek culture became fashionable, and along with that, sometimes pederasty became popular too. There were two Emperors who "married" their boys, but these were both, ah, crazy pervert emperors (Nero and Elagabalus) so I'd find it interesting if anyone used them as examples to follow!

Posted

We talked about this in my Western Civ class, and the main source we used was Plato's Symposium. Basically, the most noble love was homosexual, because it was a love of virtue - naturally, women have no virtue. An older man would take a young man/older boy, however you look at it, and sort of be his mentor. They had physical as well as emotional and intellectual intimacy, and it was indeed widely accepted. Families would be honored to have their boy picked by someone respectable for this sort of relationship.

Posted

The key difference of course is that in these ancient societies homosexual relationships did not have the same status as marriage, no matter how tolerated or even encouraged they were.

Posted

[quote name='Didacus' post='1705496' date='Nov 20 2008, 08:34 AM']Google it?!!
Are you serious? Geez, I never thought of that. <_<


How do you weed out the BS from the facts found in google?



Let me rephrase the question: Does anyone have[u][i] reliable[/i][/u] info that can be refered to on this subject?[/quote]


Time to use some of my librarian skills here.

Try google scholar, that has some good info. If you have a public library card, some libraries have indexes and databases and some electronic journals you can log onto for free. There are plenty of peer reviewed articles there and you don't have to worry about the bs.

www.ask.com is pretty good as well, and use modifiers as well.

Posted (edited)

Not as sure on the Greeks but I do know (or at least, was taught) that among Roman soldiers, homosexuality was common and accepted when men were out on the country, um, guarding Rome or in an encampment or whatever it is that led them out to the Brokeback 7 Hills. My understanding was that it was consensual and between individuals of the same general age. However, I don't know that it was truly accepted as an everyday lifestyle. My basic understanding (which is amateur) of history of most major civilizations was that homosexual behavior was, in general, something that people "turned a blind eye" to rather than accepted as a part of mainstream society. -Katie

Edited by Tinkerlina
Posted

There is also a Journal of Homosexuality that talks about this very subject. It's kinda dated. Its from 2005. There are many other gay reviews and journals about that talk about this subject. It's good to be well rounded and to know the other sides defenses as well, since some people may do some research of their own.


[b]Full Text :COPYRIGHT 1999 Gay & Lesbian Review, Inc.

Jay Weiser has written for The Progressive and The Village Voice.

Roman Homosexuality: Ideologies of Masculinity in Classical Antiquity

by Craig A. Williams

Oxford University Press, 1999. 392 pages, $55.

It was the age of Priapus. The phallic god was the embodiment of the upper-class male psyche from about 200 BC to 200 AD, Rome's heyday. Brooklyn College Classics professor Craig Williams's fascinating book depicts a world organized on sexual principles very different from our own. The Roman ideal, expressed in the bedroom and on the battlefields of the ancient Mediterranean, was to dominate. Freeborn men were expected to have sex with both genders so long as they maintained a penetrative role, and the object of desire was one's own wife or a prostitute or slave of either sex.

Other scholars have noted Roman men's obsession with penetration. In Slaves and Masters in the Roman Empire, K. R. Bradley documented their ready sexual use of slaves of both genders. But many classicists have looked at their sexuality through the lens of our hetero/homosexual dichotomy, purporting to find condemnations of homosexuality in Roman sources. Williams demolishes them all, showing that these scholars have cited attitudes toward male-to-male sex out of context. When Williams examines their treatment of similar acts with women--for example, excessive use of prostitutes--the condemnations are identical. "[H]omosexuality turns out not to have been an important issue for the Romans," Williams says. "Nor, for that matter, was heterosexuality. ... [A] book titled 'Roman Heterosexuality' would illustrate the point equally well." [/b]

cmotherofpirl
Posted

You might benefit from reading the first section of "The gifts of the Jews" by Thomas Cahill. He does an excellent job of setting up what life was like back in the day. I am just about to start his 2nd and 3rd books "The Everlasting Hills" about the times of Jesus, then the 3rd " Sailing the Dark Wine Seas" which specifically addresses Greek culture. You might want to skim those at your local library as well.

Posted

I'm sorry, I can't remember having come across any material that deals with the Greeks and homosexuality in depth.

However, I do remember that the blogger and historian Fabio P. Barbieri had posted on his LiveJournal an article that deals with the homosexuality of Virgil. Here's the link:

[quote]Just thought I'd publish one of my research articles...
...just to show the kind of thing I do in real life.

THE RABBLE OF LATIUM AND THE NOBILITY OF TROY

Virgil, homosexuality and “Latin” values


By Fabio P.Barbieri[/quote]
LINK: [url="http://fpb.livejournal.com/7089.html"]http://fpb.livejournal.com/7089.html[/url]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...