Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Mbti/jung Personality Type Harry Potter Style


Recommended Posts

Posted

I am pretty much a staunch Freudian, so I am very distrustful of C.G. Jung.  :stubborn:

 

Freud was nuts. His efforts to understand other people's psychoses were a displaced attempt to understanding his own inner conflicts. His psychology is an attempt to normalize his own abnormalities. 

Posted

I'm usually classed as INFJ or ISFJ, so I'd be either Neville or Lupin. 

 

I can live with that. :P

 

I don't actually believe the MBTI is a reliable or valid measure of personality, but what the heck. 

Basilisa Marie
Posted

 

I don't actually believe the MBTI is a reliable or valid measure of personality, but what the heck. 

 

I think it actually is, but the problem is that hardly anyone is actually trained in it and most people have no idea how to properly "type" people so like 99% of the quizzes online are wrong. Like, they make S people sound like they're too stupid to ever want to crack open a book, or that E people must always party all the time and never spend any time alone, or that F people are incapable of rational thought.  I have a friend who is actually trained in Myers Briggs, and she says that even after you take one of those quizzes you're supposed to go over the results with someone to make sure that you weren't answering questions a weird way or something, because people could pick the same answer for different reasons. 

 

But for the sake of internet stuff, yeah, it's a fun personality test. :) 

Posted

I think it actually is, but the problem is that hardly anyone is actually trained in it and most people have no idea how to properly "type" people so like 99% of the quizzes online are wrong. Like, they make S people sound like they're too stupid to ever want to crack open a book, or that E people must always party all the time and never spend any time alone, or that F people are incapable of rational thought.  I have a friend who is actually trained in Myers Briggs, and she says that even after you take one of those quizzes you're supposed to go over the results with someone to make sure that you weren't answering questions a weird way or something, because people could pick the same answer for different reasons. 

 

But for the sake of internet stuff, yeah, it's a fun personality test. :)

 

Yeah, psychometric tests shouldn't be taken out of the hands of professionals. But for fun, it's fairly harmless. 

Posted

Just another Luna Lovegood... INFP

Posted

The first time I took it I was Draco Malfoy and now I'm Neville Longbottom.

Posted

So far not a single PM extrovert. Interesting.

Posted

So far not a single PM extrovert. Interesting.

 

This is the internet. Most people in my life don't spend time on online forums. Most of them probably don't even know what forums are.

ContemporaryCaflicCrusader
Posted

The Half Blood Prince has entered.  Muahahaha.  

Posted

I think it actually is, but the problem is that hardly anyone is actually trained in it and most people have no idea how to properly "type" people so like 99% of the quizzes online are wrong. Like, they make S people sound like they're too stupid to ever want to crack open a book, or that E people must always party all the time and never spend any time alone, or that F people are incapable of rational thought.  I have a friend who is actually trained in Myers Briggs, and she says that even after you take one of those quizzes you're supposed to go over the results with someone to make sure that you weren't answering questions a weird way or something, because people could pick the same answer for different reasons. 

 

But for the sake of internet stuff, yeah, it's a fun personality test. :)

 

 

I think they are less valid than just asking a person to choose their own type. I looked at the HP chart and I could pretty much choose a couple of them depending on time, place and situation but maybe that's just because I'm a Gemini (which is about how accurate I think the MB tests are!) :) If they are used like this - for fun, fine, but I hate when companies think they can define a person by them   - shudder.

FutureCarmeliteClaire
Posted

Lupin! :love: :heart:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...