Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Any Rebuttals To This Video?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Suffering is a part of the Christian life, and that is true whether the person is mature or immature, because being a Christian is an extension of the incarnation, and the suffering of the head must be reproduced in the body. Salvation is by sacrifice, i.e., by the sacrifice of Christ, but not in a simple historical sense of an event of the past now remembered through the reading of texts, but by Christ's one sacrifice being made present in the Church, and in each individual member of the Church, both liturgically and in our daily living of the faith.

 

I'm sure whatever you just said will put food in the mouth of a starving baby.

Posted

And, by the way, a breakdown of society has nothing to do with whether one is a Christian or not.

Posted

I'm sure whatever you just said will put food in the mouth of a starving baby.

Where did I say anything about not practicing charity? All I said is that Christians are called to live the passion of Christ in their lives. Christ said that the poor will be with us always, does that mean that He also refused to help the poor? I simply stated a fact, that suffering is a part of the Christian vocation, and you ran with that in order to take a cheap shot by implying that I am for letting a baby starve. Come on, get real.

Posted (edited)

Where did I say anything about not practicing charity? All I said is that Christians are called to live the passion of Christ in their lives. Christ said that the poor will be with us always, does that mean that He also refused to help the poor? I simply stated a fact, that suffering is a part of the Christian vocation, and you ran with that in order to take a cheap shot by implying that I am for letting a baby starve. Come on, get real.

 

I wasn't implying that. My point was about Apteka's fantasy for a catastrophe. I have no problem with the idea of redemptive suffering. I wasn't saying you don't want to feed a starving baby, but that ideas about "redemptive suffering" don't turn social chaos into the kind of social renewal that Apteka imagines. When people are suffering, chances are social breakdown is going to lead to more suffering and going to lead people to acts of despair and survival, not "holistic" Christian virtue. It is good when Christians are able to endure suffering positively, because the Christian then becomes a stable influence...that's different from imagining that one big giant fireball will cure the world of its ills.

Edited by Era Might
CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

FYI: For those who don't know, Daniel Dennett is a well-respected atheist philosopher at Tufts. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Dennett

 

I almost studied under that guy...

 

You studied over him instead?

izjustagirl.jpg

Posted

You studied over him instead?

izjustagirl.jpg

 

:huh:

Posted (edited)

I have Master of Divinity from Berkeley Theological Union,circa. 1980 My experience in this "theological realm" has truely provided the intellec.tual/rational structure that I needed to obtain a balance, an equilibrium, so necessary for healthy individuation.Thnkz to Dr. Maslow

Edited by tomthetwin

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...