Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Regality Minus A Monarchy


Recommended Posts

Posted

I've read my share of (mostly Catholic) apologies for monarchy, almost always hereditary in nature (since sometimes an elected monarch is dismissed as a republic by any other name).

 

I've tried to wrap my brain around it, but I still can't see what benefits a monarchy would confer that one couldn't find in a hierarchical republic. If you're talking about a more "regal" feel with pageantry, venerable histories and traditional values, a check on pure democracy, or simply "rule by the one," you could have all of that without a formal monarchy (and many monarchies today only retain reserve powers like in Britain, or are figureheads like in Japan).

 

And then, when dynasties change, how do you really determine who's the legitimate monarch? If it's just whoever happens to be in power, that's just as arbitrary as a democratic popularity contest. :-/ (What we really need is a merit-based system.)

 

Any thoughts?

Posted

Muck fonarchy

Posted

Muck fonarchy

 

Looks like someone never got hooked on Phonics when he was a kid.

Posted

...Is this the way the thread ends? lol

Posted (edited)

I don't think monarchy is uniquely Catholic. It was ancient Greece and Rome that gave us the examples of democracy, and the church (obviously) has inherited much of that legacy. Monarchy has a certain history in the West, but I don't think it is somehow essential to traditional Western or Catholic civilization (one might argue it is even a deviation).

Edited by Era Might
Posted

While monarchy can be easily abused, I believe it can also be quite beneficial under a responsible and compassionate monarch. In order for this to happen a ruler must have an intimate relationship with it's people, country, and culture. This is easier said than done considering its in mans nature to abuse power.

Posted

While monarchy can be easily abused, I believe it can also be quite beneficial under a responsible and compassionate monarch. In order for this to happen a ruler must have an intimate relationship with it's people, country, and culture. This is easier said than done considering its in mans nature to abuse power.

Fascism

Not The Philosopher
Posted

The one thing that hereditary monarchy has going for it is that the person who winds up King/Queen might not necessarily want to rule.

Posted

I don't think it is somehow essential to traditional Western or Catholic civilization (one might argue it is even a deviation).

 

I'm inclined to agree... a nice and balanced government is what St. Thomas Aquinas and St. Robert Bellarmine advocated, in any case.
 

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Monarchies are dumb. 

Posted

Except for heaven

 

Agreed... and of course only God is fit for an absolute monarchy.
 

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Except for heaven

 

 

Agreed... and of course only God is fit for an absolute monarchy.
 

 

 

Meh, monarchies are a human construct, and God uses human language to get his point across.  

Posted

The monarchy (μοναρχια) of God the Father within the Holy Trinity is a pre-eternal reality, while created authority is merely a reflection of the divine authority of the Father.

Posted

God gave the Israelites judges but they wanted kings. He told them they'd be sorry, but he gave them kings.

 

We've been sorry ever since :p

 

 

But I do like the idea of a benevolent dictatorship - it works until the benevolent one dies and his not-so-benevolent heirs take over.

Posted

And living under a not-so-benevolent dictatorship... uh, no.

Posted

And living under a not-so-benevolent dictatorship... uh, no.

 

 

Singapore has a benevolent ruler and the people love him, but let's hope the next ruler is equally as good. :)

Posted

Singapore has a benevolent ruler and the people love him, but let's hope the next ruler is equally as good. :)

Some people love him.

Posted

Some people love him.

 

 

Well, that's true, but the people I spoke to said they did - unless they were too afraid of being caned??

 

I loved the sign on the outside of the prison.  It showed a trespasser being shot! :shock: You think it was a warning?? :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...