Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Catechism Of Trent Vs The Catechism Of The Catholic Church


Recommended Posts

Posted

The Church Fathers really did not like ambiguity in doctrinal formulations.

Posted

I agree with Cardinal Ottaviani. :hehe:

 

As a legal scholar considering the future of society, Ottaviani’s fear was that religious freedom would result in religious indifference and then a collapse of religious conviction, which would in turn lead to state hostility toward religious believers and religious institutions. His theological argument against religious freedom, widely held in the Roman universities of the day, rested on the proposition that “error has no rights.” The council’s response to that claim was that persons have rights, whether their religious opinions be erroneous or not, and that, in any event, states lack theological competence.

 

http://www.firstthings.com/onthesquare/2013/05/the-last-laugh-of-alfredo-ottaviani

 

It looks like Cardinal Ottaviani had a charism for prophecy!

Basilisa Marie
Posted

OMG You just HAD to bring up Ottaviani, didn't you Nihil?  :hehe2:   Cardinal Frings was totes more coolio, yo.  

 

 

Vatican II seems like an undoing of Trent, especially in liturgical matters. I mean of the Council Fathers of Trent adopted the Vatican II resolutions, would there have been a division between Catholics and Protestants?

 

 

I think it is certainly fair at least to say that some of the fathers of Vatican II intended for it to be a repudiation of sorts of traditional Catholicism. I believe that attitude must be strongly opposed, of course.

 

Undoing? Repudiation? I guess, depending on how you look on it.  Heck, even Cardinal Frings gave a speech in Genova (right before the council) about the different backgrounds of the first and second Vatican councils. The main point of most of the liturgical changes, and the emphasis on "full, conscious, and active participation of the laity" was that full, conscious, active participation wasn't happening for the most part.  The EF is an incredibly beautiful liturgy, a vital part of our heritage as Catholics, and should be available to those who find more spiritual nourishment from it than the NO.  But there was a reason for the shift, people just weren't getting the right catechesis, people weren't getting properly fed.  

 

But it's not just the liturgy, either. For the first time, the Church had a real developed theology of the laity.  We went from a theology where the activities of the laity were purely extensions of the mission of the bishop to a theology where the laity have a clear, distinct, and valuable role in the Church.  After the Council, we got a clear and updated Code of Canon Law.  

 

It's not like there wasn't good reason for a lot of the shifts.  
 

 

 

As a legal scholar considering the future of society, Ottaviani’s fear was that religious freedom would result in religious indifference and then a collapse of religious conviction, which would in turn lead to state hostility toward religious believers and religious institutions. His theological argument against religious freedom, widely held in the Roman universities of the day, rested on the proposition that “error has no rights.” The council’s response to that claim was that persons have rights, whether their religious opinions be erroneous or not, and that, in any event, states lack theological competence.

 

http://www.firstthings.com/onthesquare/2013/05/the-last-laugh-of-alfredo-ottaviani

 

It looks like Cardinal Ottaviani had a charism for prophecy!

 

 

Yeah, but he's arguing against religious freedom.  Error may not have freedom, but he ignores the fact that people have a right to choose their religion.  Fighting against religious freedom, particularly state-sponsored religious freedom, is only possible when you're in a position of temporal power.  But then, some people were still operating in the mindset that Catholicism only really thrives when it's the state-endorsed religion (which, of course, makes total sense - it had been almost completely true since the time of Constantine).  

 

Anyway.  This post is too long as it is. 

Posted
Now there is Rahner, Congar and Kung
Whose praises are everywhere sung
But one fine domani
Ottaviani
Will have the three of them hung
 
Said Ottaviani to Cardinal Frings
Strange what collegiality brings
How Ruffini opined
Alfrink in mind,
This stuff with falsity rings.
Posted

 

Now there is Rahner, Congar and Kung
Whose praises are everywhere sung
But one fine domani
Ottaviani
Will have the three of them hung
 
Said Ottaviani to Cardinal Frings
Strange what collegiality brings
How Ruffini opined
Alfrink in mind,
This stuff with falsity rings.

 

I didn't know it, but you're a poet.

  • 8 years later...
Posted
On 9/24/2013 at 10:14 PM, Apotheoun said:

The Catechism of the Council of Trent is past its sell-by-date. You need to get up to speed with the re-reading of the Gospel in the light of contemporary culture.  :evil:

problem with contemporary culture is multifold. Many Catholics deny the presence in the Eucharist, allow for abortion, no longer fast on certain days, don't go to confession, etc. Culture is suppose to conform to the Church, not the Church to culture. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...