fons_vitae Posted October 4, 2013 Author Posted October 4, 2013 Tuhk Amerigatsi ek. Ayo, amerigatsi em. And, regrettably, from "the America of America" itself, Texas. This no doubt colored my answer, sorry. :)
Anastasia13 Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 Ayo, amerigatsi em. And, regrettably, from "the America of America" itself, Texas. This no doubt colored my answer, sorry. :) I'm impressed.
fons_vitae Posted October 4, 2013 Author Posted October 4, 2013 I'm impressed. (Lol, I admit I just googled the phrase... I assumed "amerigatsi" = American though.)
Nihil Obstat Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 Traditionalist Catholics having a fondness for 1950s America, while sometimes true, does not by a long shot represent traditional Catholicism as a whole. For one thing it completely ignores the fact that many, perhaps even most well known traditionalists are (or were) not American (Lefebvre, Fellay, Bisig, Ranjith, Davies, Waugh, Tolkien, de Castro Mayer, Rifan, Rangel, etc., etc., etc.). It also ignores the very specific traditionalist theology that holds Catholic traditionalism to completely transcend any particular temporal instance.
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 (edited) Yes, but a Catholic really can't. Ah, never mind. I believe the Lord guides the Church, regardless of the impending doom feared by naysayers of any era. /thread Jesus " there will be many false prophets after me." Our Lord doesn't say all though, but many. Edited October 4, 2013 by Tab'le Du'Bah-Rye
Nihil Obstat Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 It also ignores the very specific traditionalist theology that holds Catholic traditionalism to completely transcend any particular temporal instance. I should have gone into more detail here, but essentially it is in opposition to Catholic modernists who, explicitly or implicitly, make their Catholicism a product of modern time, throwing out inconvenient doctrines or practices when they conflict with their culture. The modernist Catholic cannot stand when their faith makes them uncomfortable.
Era Might Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 (edited) It also ignores the very specific traditionalist theology that holds Catholic traditionalism to completely transcend any particular temporal instance. I don't know about that, I'd say what is called Traditionalism is very much a modern creature. I don't think "Traditionalists" of the modern sort would have been much at home in Chaucer's or Michelangelo's Europe, even Aquinas's Europe. Modernity has set the terms for self-conscious Traditionalism because it is a mentality completely in retreat from the course of history, whereas people like Chaucer, Aquinas, Michelangelo, Bartolome de las Casas, were very much engaged in the world they actually inhabited, not in a retreat. It's no surprise that Traditionalists glorify the Council of Trent as they do, that was the period when the West really set its modern course, and Trent was a reaction to that. And modern Traditionalism is also a bookish kind of religion, very much rooted in the free dissemination and engagement of texts, rather than in the popular pieties, ecclesial structures, etc. that would have defined religion for people in the first Millennium. I'd say Traditionalism is attractive to people who think or read too much, and are somewhat alienated from their world...of course, that's a generalization, but I think it's true in a general sense. In general, people look for a refuge in their circumstances, but Traditionalism provides an idealized refuge, something set apart from the world, and it also provides a useful integration for those who are intellectually inclined. Edited October 4, 2013 by Era Might
fons_vitae Posted October 4, 2013 Author Posted October 4, 2013 Traditionalist Catholics having a fondness for 1950s America, while sometimes true, does not by a long shot represent traditional Catholicism as a whole. For one thing it completely ignores the fact that many, perhaps even most well known traditionalists are (or were) not American (Lefebvre, Fellay, Bisig, Ranjith, Davies, Waugh, Tolkien, de Castro Mayer, Rifan, Rangel, etc., etc., etc.). It also ignores the very specific traditionalist theology that holds Catholic traditionalism to completely transcend any particular temporal instance. Good point... I like the Waugh and Tolkien traditionalism (also known as Catholicism), not the denim jumper-wearing variety (more of a simple reaction to modernity) :).
Nihil Obstat Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 Good point... I like the Waugh and Tolkien traditionalism (also known as Catholicism), not the denim jumper-wearing variety (more of a simple reaction to modernity) :). Take care not to generalize an entire group based on one small subset you do not like. I have gone to a traditional Mass community more or less exclusively for several years now, and I have yet to meet that particular stereotype.
Nihil Obstat Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 I don't know about that, I'd say what is called Traditionalism is very much a modern creature. I don't think "Traditionalists" of the modern sort would have been much at home in Chaucer's or Michelangelo's Europe, even Aquinas's Europe. Modernity has set the terms for self-conscious Traditionalism because it is a mentality completely in retreat from the course of history, whereas people like Chaucer, Aquinas, Michelangelo, Bartolome de las Casas, were very much engaged in the world they actually inhabited, not in a retreat. It's no surprise that Traditionalists glorify the Council of Trent as they do, that was the period when the West really set its modern course, and Trent was a reaction to that. And modern Traditionalism is also a bookish kind of religion, very much rooted in the free dissemination and engagement of texts, rather than in the popular pieties, ecclesial structures, etc. that would have defined religion for people in the first Millennium. I'd say Traditionalism is attractive to people who think or read too much, and are somewhat alienated from their world...of course, that's a generalization, but I think it's true in a general sense. In general, people look for a refuge in their circumstances, but Traditionalism provides an idealized refuge, something set apart from the world, and it also provides a useful integration for those who are intellectually inclined. Legitimate traditionalism of today used to simply be called "Catholicism", and it is unfortunate that the people of the Roman Church have forgotten their patrimony to such an extent that we need a separate term to refer to it. I very much disagree with your assessment of modern traditionalism. You, like the previous poster, are referring to a particular subset which does not represent the whole.
Nihil Obstat Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 Interestingly, the stereotype sometimes is that traditionalists are all uneducated Catholic bumpkins who simply do not like all the newfangled learnin' of enlightened modernist Catholicism. But, when convenient, suddenly traditionalists are all arrogant ivory tower eggheads who worship dusty documents and their own intellects. I guess it depends on who precisely needs to be demonized. We should not do that.
Nihil Obstat Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 Good point... I like the Waugh and Tolkien traditionalism (also known as Catholicism), not the denim jumper-wearing variety (more of a simple reaction to modernity) :). By the way, have you read that recently published book "A Bitter Trial", which is a collection of Evelyn Waugh's letters around the time of the liturgical changes? I found it to be a fascinating look at the Church climate at the time, from the perspective of a faithful 'old-world Catholic'. "If you see Cardinal Bea spit in his eye."
Era Might Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 Legitimate traditionalism of today used to simply be called "Catholicism", and it is unfortunate that the people of the Roman Church have forgotten their patrimony to such an extent that we need a separate term to refer to it. I very much disagree with your assessment of modern traditionalism. You, like the previous poster, are referring to a particular subset which does not represent the whole. I'm not sure what "legitimate traditionalism" means. Who legitimates traditionalism? Lots of things used to be called Catholicism, depending on where you lived. Even the idea of "legitimate traditionalism" strikes me as a bookish kind of religion, something that lives in ideas and theories, not in reality. I'm not referring to a subset. Is there one person who you would say represents "legitimate traditionalism" who has built on the world they actually live in? I like Waugh as a writer, "Brideshead Revisited" is one of my favorite books, but it's a very small contribution to a large literary conversation in the 20th century. I don't see any real place for Traditionalism except as a ghetto, because it begins from a retreat, it abhors the course of history, and its grand project is to stitch together a civilization from books. You know what "Catholicism" is? It's what you find in the pages of The Canterbury Tales: cuckolded husbands, lascivious priests, rebellious women, spiritual corruption, oppressive hierarchy, and all kinds of beautiful flashes of holiness, beauty, art, etc. It was the real world Chaucer wrote about. It was the real world people like Michelangelo and More engaged with during the Englightenment. I don't see any of that realness in modern "Traditionalism." It's a movement for people who want to escape their parishes, who want to escape what they see as a deluge of error, waywardness, etc. It's partly what scandalizes many people about Pope Francis. Whatever he is, nobody would accuse him of living in retreat from the world that actually exists.
Era Might Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 You know what "Catholicism" is? It's what you find in the pages of The Canterbury Tales: cuckolded husbands, lascivious priests, rebellious women, spiritual corruption, oppressive hierarchy, and all kinds of beautiful flashes of holiness, beauty, art, etc. It was the real world Chaucer wrote about. It was the real world people like Michelangelo and More engaged with during the Englightenment. I don't see any of that realness in modern "Traditionalism." It's a movement for people who want to escape their parishes, who want to escape what they see as a deluge of error, waywardness, etc. It's partly what scandalizes many people about Pope Francis. Whatever he is, nobody would accuse him of living in retreat from the world that actually exists. Also, just to add that one of the reasons why Brideshead Revisited is so great is because Waugh understood precisely this. The Catholics you find in Brideshead Revisited are just as messed up as the ones you find in The Canterbury Tales. Despite Waugh's sympathies for older aristocratic ways and civilization in England, Brideshead Revisited is a powerful statement of the theme of what Catholicism actually is: a house of dysfunction and grace.
Nihil Obstat Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 I'm not sure what "legitimate traditionalism" means. Who legitimates traditionalism? Lots of things used to be called Catholicism, depending on where you lived. Even the idea of "legitimate traditionalism" strikes me as a bookish kind of religion, something that lives in ideas and theories, not in reality. I'm not referring to a subset. Is there one person who you would say represents "legitimate traditionalism" who has built on the world they actually live in? I like Waugh as a writer, "Brideshead Revisited" is one of my favorite books, but it's a very small contribution to a large literary conversation in the 20th century. I don't see any real place for Traditionalism except as a ghetto, because it begins from a retreat, it abhors the course of history, and its grand project is to stitch together a civilization from books. You know what "Catholicism" is? It's what you find in the pages of The Canterbury Tales: cuckolded husbands, lascivious priests, rebellious women, spiritual corruption, oppressive hierarchy, and all kinds of beautiful flashes of holiness, beauty, art, etc. It was the real world Chaucer wrote about. It was the real world people like Michelangelo and More engaged with during the Englightenment. I don't see any of that realness in modern "Traditionalism." It's a movement for people who want to escape their parishes, who want to escape what they see as a deluge of error, waywardness, etc. It's partly what scandalizes many people about Pope Francis. Whatever he is, nobody would accuse him of living in retreat from the world that actually exists. Do you realize that you do precisely what you have implicitly accused me of? That is, forming your own version of Catholicism and claiming that it is somehow more authentic than the alternatives that you have identified?
Era Might Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 (edited) Do you realize that you do precisely what you have implicitly accused me of? That is, forming your own version of Catholicism and claiming that it is somehow more authentic than the alternatives that you have identified? I don't claim a version of Catholicism. I don't look at Traditionalism as something unknown in Catholic history...but neither do I look at Pope Francis that way. The church has always had struggles for control over the terms of the conversation. I only ask that self-knowledge always be present. I don't have a problem with people who find Traditionalism suiting to their brief lives, but neither do I freak out over people who live in different contexts and are drawn to stuff like liberation theology. Life is a complicated beast. I don't claim to speak FOR Catholicism, but I do claim to speak about it. Edited October 4, 2013 by Era Might
fons_vitae Posted October 4, 2013 Author Posted October 4, 2013 (edited) I think as long as we realize that "old" Catholicism and "new" Catholicism are actually the same thing, we'll pay no heed to the one thing both "radtrad" and progressive agree on: the hermeneutic of rupture. Edited October 4, 2013 by fons_vitae
Nihil Obstat Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 (edited) I don't claim a version of Catholicism. I don't look at Traditionalism as something unknown in Catholic history...but neither do I look at Pope Francis that way. The church has always had struggles for control over the terms of the conversation. I only ask that self-knowledge always be present. I don't have a problem with people who find Traditionalism suiting to their brief lives, but neither do I freak out over people who live in different contexts and are drawn to stuff like liberation theology. Life is a complicated beast. I don't claim to speak FOR Catholicism, but I do claim to speak about it. I said nothing about Pope Francis. I say as little as possible about him, for my own sake. I think as long as we realize that "old" Catholicism and "new" Catholicism are actually the same thing, we'll pay no heed to the one thing both "radtrad" and progressive agree on: the hermeneutic of rupture. I think it is too shallow a view to look at a hermeneutic of rupture or a hermeneutic of continuity as a single unified subject. I think we can and should look at specific subject areas, for instance the propers of the Mass, the ordinary of the Mass (perhaps even subdivide such that the Canon is a separate entity), the Divine Office vs. Liturgy of the Hours, social teaching, sexual morality, ecclesiology, etc., etc.. I think in most areas, and in all areas which we properly consider vital (ETA: vital in the sense that the Church retains Her identity and nature), there is demonstrable continuity. I do think it is also fair to say that there was rupture in some areas at some points in time. Rupture at least in a material sense, such as with the propers of the Roman Rite, or the Divine Office. On the other hand, when I say that there could exist a rupture in a material sense, I mean material in a very limited way. I do not mean that the Church as a whole fell into a state of rupture in a theological sense. I do not mean that at all. But it is simply untrue, to use that same example, that the propers of the classical Roman Rite are 'the same' as the Pauline missae. I forget what my point was. Maybe I did not have one. Anyway, I like talking about the liturgy. Edited October 4, 2013 by Nihil Obstat
fons_vitae Posted October 4, 2013 Author Posted October 4, 2013 But it is simply untrue, to use that same example, that the propers of the classical Roman Rite are 'the same' as the Pauline missae. I forget what my point was. Maybe I did not have one. Anyway, I like talking about the liturgy. Yes, but the liturgy has frequently been revised and altered and snipped throughout the centuries (I know, I know, but back then it was more organic snippery). They just need to continue restoring the sense of the sacred to the current Ordinary Form, and there you go. Or, for goodness' sake, just translate the Extraordinary Form into the vernacular and be done with it. :P I know the propers aren't verbatim the same, but reverence is all I require.
Nihil Obstat Posted October 4, 2013 Posted October 4, 2013 Yes, but the liturgy has frequently been revised and altered and snipped throughout the centuries (I know, I know, but back then it was more organic snippery). They just need to continue restoring the sense of the sacred to the current Ordinary Form, and there you go. Or, for goodness' sake, just translate the Extraordinary Form into the vernacular and be done with it. :P I know the propers aren't verbatim the same, but reverence is all I require. I think it is demonstrable that the (essential) loss of the traditional propers is extremely serious, both from a liturgical patrimony perspective and an artistic, cultural perspective. I am not entirely against reasonable use of the vernacular in liturgy. I do think the Canon should remain in Latin, and the most stable parts of the Ordinary. But the propers are a unique, living element in their own right. What they represent is many centuries of living organic tradition - in countless cases the propers are far older than the tridentine missal itself. Unfortunately the renovation of the propers was not an exercise in organic continuity, and I think for the continuing good of the Roman Rite they need to be restored or revived. This would allow the liturgical reform to be carried out in the way that it was more truly intended. Are you familiar at all with Laszlo Dobszay, the late Hungarian musicologist and (in a certain sense) liturgist?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now