Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Death Penalty


Recommended Posts

Posted

I used to be for the death penalty in extreme circumstances, but now I'm for the death penalty never. I don't really want to debate that though. Has anyone else found themselves switch to the other side of the fence when it comes to a controversial topic? I've consistently been against abortion, euthanasia, and contraception so this is really the only "switch" for me. (Homosexual marriage -- I really can't muster the energy to care, frankly. Beyond "I'm a Catholic and this is what I think." Pretty indifferent.)

 

I feel the exact same way.

I have always been pro-life but I had been pro-death penalty. Eventually I began to feel like that didnt make sense.

 

I switched sides with the idea that if these people (regardless of the evils they have committed) were allowed to live, it would give them more of a chance to ask for forgiveness.

Posted

I'm against it, mainly because innocent people do make it on death row, to me the risks outweigh the "reward"

Posted

I used to be staunchly, outspokenly for it. I thought we needed to put more people on death row and kill them a whole lot faster. Then I had a date with a guy who had done years of research on the death penalty and was a public advocate for its abolition. I listened to him go on and on about it, silently disagreeing and not really wanting to get into it cuz frankly I didn't like him much and didn't want another date. But what he said stuck with me. The main thing that haunted me was his statement that "the state does not have the right to take anybody's life". Having Libertarian tendencies at the time (though not yet being officially Libertarian), that made the difference to me, ultimately.

 

I take this, now, as a lesson that, even if you are debating with someone who is clearly just out to convert you, who is not in the slightest open to changing their mind, go ahead and make your best argument anyway. Something you say may stick with them, haunt them, and ultimately nag them to change.

 

I can see now how hypocritical it is for a person who claims to believe in the limited power of government to be pro-death penalty. Most Republicans claim to be for small government, and yet... The power to give or take life is the ultimate power. It makes me sad to know that my father, who is a die-hard Republican, is so party-loyal that he can't see this inconsistency in his own view.

 

The anti-abortion but pro-death penalty "inconsistency" is really not an inconsistency, though. The unborn have done nothing to "merit" or "earn" death. Criminals have. That view is only inconsistent if you assume that life is everyone's right. But if you assume that it is the right only of the innocent and the non-dangerous, then it is not inconsistent. Espouse that some crimes can warrant death as punishment, and being anti-abortion but pro-death penalty is perfectly consistent.

 

I made a turn on abortion, too, though not at the same time. It took quite a bit longer to come around on the abortion issue (believe it or not). I started to turn toward the pro-life side in my 20s after I realized how many women were using abortion as back-up birth control. But I was for abortion in the case of rape, incest, or other extreme circumstances pretty much all the way up until I entered the Church. It was when I began my conversion to Catholicism that I finally accepted it is more important to embrace life and accept what God has handed you than it is to avoid suffering and poverty.

Posted

I've always been against the death penalty for two reasons. Firstly, the story of Jesus and the woman who had been condemned to death. "Let the one without sin be the first to throw a stone at her," has always seemed crystal-clear to me. Life belongs to God. He is the only one who can take it. Secondly, the death penalty seems to close the door on repentance and the possibility of a new life, and if you believe that even the worst sinners have it in them to make good, then killing them displays a terrible lack of faith in God's goodness and his creation.

Posted

used to be staunchly against capital punishment. Now I pretty much feel that, in theory, it's a plausible and sometimes necessary course of action. But in practice I don't trust the competence of our government to actually handle such an important issue without botching it completely.

 

Also I don't think an execution necessarily precludes repentance. Sometimes the only way to get a sociopath to feel anything is to point a gun at his face (there are studies that demonstrate this if you look). Hell, if someone tells me I only have a few weeks to live I'm getting my **** together right quick. There's something about imminent death that makes a person act.

 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...