Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

So I found this article about how a woman (who may or may not be a mother herself, the article is not specific) who said she will be handing out notes instead of candy to the kids who she believes are too overweight to be trick or treating:

 

8C9532816-2417481-halloween-letter.block

 

 

 

"I just want to send a message to the parents of kids that are really overweight," she said. "I think it's just really irresponsible of parents to send them out looking for free candy just 'cause all the other kids are doing it."

http://www.today.com/moms/swapping-letters-candy-trick-or-treat-8C11493000

 

 

This made me think...when is it acceptable for someone to step in and critique parenting?

So many people have so many ideas of what is good and bad parenting. When is it ok to say "Hey, you shouldnt be doing that" or "Hey, you should really try a little of xyz"

 

Is it ever ok?

Is it only ok with the child's safety and/or health are concerned?

Not The Philosopher
Posted

I'm more bothered by the fact that she's giving candy to some kids and not others. That's gonna make a few kids feel singled out and hurt.

 

If she's so concerned about health, then she just shouldn't give out candy at all.

 

(I'm not a parent)

Posted

I'm more bothered by the fact that she's giving candy to some kids and not others. That's gonna make a few kids feel singled out and hurt.

 

If she's so concerned about health, then she just shouldn't give out candy at all.

 

(I'm not a parent)

 

I think thats a good point.

But when does it cross the line? Is it her place to tell other parents to take better care of their children? As if they dont know?

Maybe some parents need the reminder?

Posted (edited)

Who said Halloween is about being responsible? The whole point of a holiday is to have fun.

Edited by Era Might
KnightofChrist
Posted

The lady is practically begging to have her house egged, and rolled, or have a little flaming bag of dog poo on her front door.

PhuturePriest
Posted

If the parents are beating the child in public, speak up. In this situation, however, this lady is so far out of line I'm honestly baffled by it.

Posted

Using a holiday as a device to berate children = bad.

 

The fact that in many cities children are suffering and even dying because of obesity (which apparently is higher in Michigan than other places) is frightening.

 

This could of been positive, but it was not.

 

What this woman did was cowardly.  She could of organized a "trunk-or-treat" with healthy snacks, limited candy and plenty of room to run around....something more than giving notes to kids.

Posted

I think what this lady did was horrible. The more I thought about it the more I wished I could go to her house and burn every note she hands out to kids. I cant even imagine how the child might feel to be rejected candy while all the other kids around him/her are happily running from house to house. The child wont understand and they will feel hurt and isolated from everyone else.

 

But my question is...obesity IS a big deal...so is it ok for someone to interject and make a comment to a parent about how they are raising their child? Obviously this woman's actions are an example of how NOT to do it..but are there situations when its ok? And if so how do you address it?

Posted

Is it ok for someone to interject a comment?

 

Thats tricky.  I don't think for questionaly obese kids, but I think when you get the morbidly obese kid who can't breathe or move comfortably then its time to step in.  Sometimes it's a medical issue and the parents are aware.  Sometimes it's a medical issue that the parents are in denial of.  Sometimes it's really poor parenting.

 

It is scarry that kids are dying and facing type 2 diabetes.  It is scary that doctors are now faced with blind children becuase of this, having to amputate 7 year old's feet due to diabetes.  Antibiotics are prescribed because of festering "bed sores" on toddlers who's fat flaps aren't properly cleaned.

 

My cousin is an OBGYN and said the hardest women are the obese ones because c-cetion flaps have so much fat that placed wrong they can literally crush internal organs.  In obese teen moms the risk is so great that it often takes 3-4 more physicians to deliver a child.  

 

In some places this has reached crisis mode.  Children don't fit in standard seats, they become unable to walk, speak clearly, or comfortably hold a pencil.

 

So, yes, there is need for people to speak out....parents need to know that being fat is not a way of life....that the child will learn to eat veggies if forced to.  I don't want to see any kid die of health related problems....and I do believe at some point massive, untreated obesity is child abuse.

Posted

it is only ok to jump in if their is fear of physical or mental safety of the child.  if not, its not your child, so keep your dang mouth shut.  its not your child and more than likely you own child has their own issues, so focus on them.  anyone who chastises a child deserves to be slapped across the face.  then when asked why you did it.  say because your worried about my fat kid and I am worried about your ugly looks.  you gave my child a note saying he is fat in hopes of helping him  I decided to try and slap the ugly out of your face to help you.  then ask if they have anymore advice for your child because you certainly have more advice about them.  I imagine after that, this person would never give her advice to a child or parent again.

Posted

Is it ok for someone to interject a comment?

 

Thats tricky.  I don't think for questionaly obese kids, but I think when you get the morbidly obese kid who can't breathe or move comfortably then its time to step in.  Sometimes it's a medical issue and the parents are aware.  Sometimes it's a medical issue that the parents are in denial of.  Sometimes it's really poor parenting.

 

It is scarry that kids are dying and facing type 2 diabetes.  It is scary that doctors are now faced with blind children becuase of this, having to amputate 7 year old's feet due to diabetes.  Antibiotics are prescribed because of festering "bed sores" on toddlers who's fat flaps aren't properly cleaned.

 

My cousin is an OBGYN and said the hardest women are the obese ones because c-cetion flaps have so much fat that placed wrong they can literally crush internal organs.  In obese teen moms the risk is so great that it often takes 3-4 more physicians to deliver a child.  

 

In some places this has reached crisis mode.  Children don't fit in standard seats, they become unable to walk, speak clearly, or comfortably hold a pencil.

 

So, yes, there is need for people to speak out....parents need to know that being fat is not a way of life....that the child will learn to eat veggies if forced to.  I don't want to see any kid die of health related problems....and I do believe at some point massive, untreated obesity is child abuse.

 

 

(not directed at you)

 

this is what I love about society.  we can call kids fat and chastise them for being fat and eating unhealthy but if this kid wants to have sex, get pregnant, have an abortion and then repeat... well who are we to step in any say anything to this child.  although if they are fat, lets make them feel horrible.  if they have an abortion, lets applaud them.  society is so messed up.

Posted

I'm not totally opposed to people chastising Other People's Children. That used to be an ordinary part of American life. Kids used to run wild all day with their shoes off, but it was fine because even if Mom and Dad weren't in sight other grown folk were and you could catch it from them as easily as from mom and dad.

 

but kids don't fast on Halloween.

Posted

it is only ok to jump in if their is fear of physical or mental safety of the child.  if not, its not your child, so keep your dang mouth shut.  its not your child and more than likely you own child has their own issues, so focus on them.  anyone who chastises a child deserves to be slapped across the face.  then when asked why you did it.  say because your worried about my fat kid and I am worried about your ugly looks.  you gave my child a note saying he is fat in hopes of helping him  I decided to try and slap the ugly out of your face to help you.  then ask if they have anymore advice for your child because you certainly have more advice about them.  I imagine after that, this person would never give her advice to a child or parent again.

 

Children usually become obese because the parents are overlooking healthy habits. Unfortunately those habits carry over into their adult life and end up being very detrimental.

I do not support what this woman has done with the notes, but I do want all children to lead happy healthy lives. I have never felt like I needed to say anything to parents in my day to day life because I feel like this situation is probably better addressed at a larger scale.

Posted

Children usually become obese because the parents are overlooking healthy habits. Unfortunately those habits carry over into their adult life and end up being very detrimental.

I do not support what this woman has done with the notes, but I do want all children to lead happy healthy lives. I have never felt like I needed to say anything to parents in my day to day life because I feel like this situation is probably better addressed at a larger scale.

 

 

far more important than kids growing up obese is the fact kids have no self esteem these days because not only do they hear about their weight problems from other kids but now adults feel perfectly fine telling a little kid they are fat.  at no point should an adult ever berate a child for their weight, yet it is happening more and more in society today. 

Posted

far more important than kids growing up obese is the fact kids have no self esteem these days because not only do they hear about their weight problems from other kids but now adults feel perfectly fine telling a little kid they are fat.  at no point should an adult ever berate a child for their weight, yet it is happening more and more in society today. 

 

I dont think anyone is supporting children being berated about their weight.

The whole point of this thread is to get thoughts on when is it acceptable to talk to the parents about it? Im guessing your answer is never?

Posted (edited)

When I read that, my thoughts flew to a girl with arthritis at my high school. She was several years younger than me, about eleven years old when I got to know her. The steroid medication she took for her arthritis made her look very bloated and fat. When my classmate found about her condition, she exclaimed, "I feel so bad for her! She's going to grow up and people are just going to look at her like she's fat and lazy!" Those words have stuck in my head.

 

I read that note and imagined Bethany being sent home with one from some officious neighbour who apparently feels it's her duty (not a paediatrician's or a school nurse's) to police the neighbourhood children's weight. And of course she would have opened and read it herself. What kid wouldn't, when presented with a note from a stranger while all the other kids got sweets? The other kids would probably be curious and demand to see it as well. It's pure humiliation all round.

 

Children can be overweight for many reasons. If there is a medical condition at work, whether physical or psychological, the parents are unlikely to be broadcasting it all round the neighbourhood for the benefit of Ms Healthfood Police. It's absolutely not her business. If it is poor parenting, it's not her business either. Doctors, school nurses, people actually known to the child who have the ability to help tactfully and effectively - it's their responsibility to deal with it, not the responsibility of a stranger who apparently doesn't seem to care if she humiliates young kids in front of all their friends, just so she can get in a snarky jab at their parents.

Edited by beatitude
Posted

I dont think anyone is supporting children being berated about their weight.

The whole point of this thread is to get thoughts on when is it acceptable to talk to the parents about it? Im guessing your answer is never?

 

 

if a parent is causing emotional or physical harm to a child then its ok to step in.  other than that, no its never ok and here is why.  what I deem ok for my child other may deem as harmful to them and vis versa.  whats good for your child is subjective.  some parents believe no tv is good for a child and other think some tv is ok for children.  why should it be ok for one parent in this situation to chastise another parent for their parenting choices just because they believe they knows whats best even though its subjective. 

 

even obesity is subjective.  I am considered an obese man.  I am 6'1 and 250lbs.  so according to the medical world I am obese.  although things like bmi do not account for muscle mass.  even though I am in good shape and have a ton of muscle on my body and workout and lift heavy weights and bodybuild in the loosest sense compared to real bodybuilders, I am considered obese because for my height I do not weigh around 180lbs.  my situation is similar to bodybuilders or pro football players.  obesity does not account for muscle mass.  an athlete who has to be large for his sport(football offensive lineman) can be considered obese but is in great shape and is healthier than some who is thin and considered not obese but who doesn't workout or exercise at all.  so obesity is subjective and for a parent to comment on something that subjective is not right.   

Posted (edited)

I'm not totally opposed to people chastising Other People's Children. That used to be an ordinary part of American life. Kids used to run wild all day with their shoes off, but it was fine because even if Mom and Dad weren't in sight other grown folk were and you could catch it from them as easily as from mom and dad.

 

but kids don't fast on Halloween.

Chastising a childs behavior or stepping in for those sorts of issues where you confront the child is a different topic although not completely unrelated.

My question was more about when, as in this example, a childs health is on the line. Typically you dont go to the child and yell at them for being fat because its not usually their fault. At what point is it acceptable to address the parents on this issue or other related issues?

 

if a parent is causing emotional or physical harm to a child then its ok to step in.  other than that, no its never ok and here is why.  what I deem ok for my child other may deem as harmful to them and vis versa.  whats good for your child is subjective.  some parents believe no tv is good for a child and other think some tv is ok for children.  why should it be ok for one parent in this situation to chastise another parent for their parenting choices just because they believe they knows whats best even though its subjective. 

 

even obesity is subjective.  I am considered an obese man.  I am 6'1 and 250lbs.  so according to the medical world I am obese.  although things like bmi do not account for muscle mass.  even though I am in good shape and have a ton of muscle on my body and workout and lift heavy weights and bodybuild in the loosest sense compared to real bodybuilders, I am considered obese because for my height I do not weigh around 180lbs.  my situation is similar to bodybuilders or pro football players.  obesity does not account for muscle mass.  an athlete who has to be large for his sport(football offensive lineman) can be considered obese but is in great shape and is healthier than some who is thin and considered not obese but who doesn't workout or exercise at all.  so obesity is subjective and for a parent to comment on something that subjective is not right.   

 

Well, how we view someone as obese might be subjective, but the health complications from an poor lifestyle are not subjective. Not all fat people are unhealthy just as not all thin people are healthy. But the undeniable fact is that being overweight usually means there is poor health at play and even if someone doesnt show signs of diabetes or heart disease now doesnt mean that its not in the works for them down the road.

We should encourage healthy lifestyles for everyone, not just overweight people.

 

But to get back on topic, you said its ok to step in if there is physical or emotional harm....wouldnt complications from obesity be physical harm?

Edited by CrossCuT
Posted

You finally make a thread that actually belongs in RSH, and you put it here.

Posted

You finally make a thread that actually belongs in RSH, and you put it here.

  :evil: Am I not fitting into your experiment? 

 

 

I didnt think this topic needed to be hid behind a password for access, its pretty PG.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...