PhuturePriest Posted December 3, 2013 Posted December 3, 2013 (edited) What do you all think of this article? http://www.policymic.com/articles/69537/the-invisible-body-image-issue-that-millennial-men-need-to-know To me it makes sense. All you see in pop culture for men are buff, tall, manly guys like Liam Hemsworth and Jean-Claude Van Damme. It only follows that men will begin to think they are supposed to automatically look like that, just as girls do when they see pictures of unrealistically skinny girls. Edited December 3, 2013 by FuturePriest387
CatherineM Posted December 3, 2013 Posted December 3, 2013 Dennis Quaid have a good interview about this topic.
Ed Normile Posted December 3, 2013 Posted December 3, 2013 FP you are just a kid so I can see where you may think that. Being a man is not comparing your self to another, its being confident in what you are. Men can be strong, men can smart, but a real man is not one who has to invent himself to some preconceived ideal or notion. A man is a man, that's all. Now I am not sure of the metro-sexual generation but I never looked at another man or what he was wearing or how big he was, just whether or not he was a threat. ed
PhuturePriest Posted December 3, 2013 Author Posted December 3, 2013 It also amazes me how little coverage this has for men. All you hear about when it comes to body image issues is how girls suffer with it, and I had never heard from the media about men suffering with it until I looked it up on Google.
SaintOfVirtue Posted December 3, 2013 Posted December 3, 2013 I've never felt pressured to "look good" by the media, and I am far from the "Greek Porportions" physically (I'm short and very skinny). I workout to keep fit, not because I'm measuring myself against some tv star. I have used protein powders and creatine formulas at one point, but once again it wasn't because I wanted to "look better" it was because I needed gain weight as a condition of employment and natural "eating healthy" routines were not producing any results. Also, I agree with Ed, whenever I look a guy up and down I'm making a threat assessment of his body language not an appearance comparison.
Maggyie Posted December 3, 2013 Posted December 3, 2013 Hmmmm. I have to say I don't totally buy it. Two words: Leonardo DiCaprio. In half his movies dude has a concave chest. Tom Cruise is buff but 4'9". 110% of women consider Jean Claude Van Damme sexually repellant. I could go on.
PhuturePriest Posted December 3, 2013 Author Posted December 3, 2013 Hmmmm. I have to say I don't totally buy it. Two words: Leonardo DiCaprio. In half his movies dude has a concave chest. Tom Cruise is buff but 4'9". 110% of women consider Jean Claude Van Damme sexually repellant. I could go on. Tom Cruise is 5'7", not 4'9". It's quite a stretch to say more women than actually exist find Jean-Claude Van Damme repellant. Just because he's not your type, it doesn't mean he's not other girls' type. And even then, it's not about what women actually think, it's about what the media portrays women to think. I don't think a girl who isn't the size of a toothpick and has normal things like armpit fat and cellulite is repulsive, but the media portrays men to think that way. If you've ever seen the movie, think of Couples Retreat: The wives have decent-looking husbands with acceptable body weights, but they all go nuts for the ridiculously chiseled yoga instructor. This gives a message that this is the ideal man girls have in mind, even if that's not what women actually think.
Era Might Posted December 3, 2013 Posted December 3, 2013 (edited) FP you are just a kid so I can see where you may think that. Being a man is not comparing your self to another, its being confident in what you are. Men can be strong, men can smart, but a real man is not one who has to invent himself to some preconceived ideal or notion. A man is a man, that's all. Now I am not sure of the metro-sexual generation but I never looked at another man or what he was wearing or how big he was, just whether or not he was a threat. ed I think feeling threatened is a type of body image. Even if it is just feeling threatened about your physical safety, the implication is that you are measuring yourself against their physical capabilities, in the possibility of a fight. Or, another way could be feeling threatened when another man enters your woman's attention...are you good enough to keep her attention? In other words, feeling threatened is by definition comparing yourself to another. And certainly, being a man does not just exist out of thin air...our conceptions of what it means to be men are inherited, from our fathers, from our mothers even, and I guess from media, though how one learns from media varies. In the old days men looked at John Wayne as some kind of icon of manhood...that's an example of male body image. I don't think there's any question that we learn how to be men from seeing other men...the real question is how true we are and how self-aware we are to be able to find ourselves within that influence. Edited December 3, 2013 by Era Might
Era Might Posted December 3, 2013 Posted December 3, 2013 Tom Cruise is 5'7", not 4'9". So I'm taller than Tom Cruise...I could take him.
Spem in alium Posted December 3, 2013 Posted December 3, 2013 Thanks for sharing this FP. I didn't realise how much of an issue body image and stereotyping can be for men (and how detrimental they can be) until my brother turned 16 (or thereabouts). It's sad to think that there are lots of people around who believe images of women (and men) in magazines to be completely real. Boy, are they in for a rude awakening.
GeorgiiMichael Posted December 3, 2013 Posted December 3, 2013 Jean-Claude Van Damme? Really? That's who you use as an example? There are tons of more relevant celebrities that you could have used.
PhuturePriest Posted December 3, 2013 Author Posted December 3, 2013 Thanks for sharing this FP. I didn't realise how much of an issue body image and stereotyping can be for men (and how detrimental they can be) until my brother turned 16 (or thereabouts). It's sad to think that there are lots of people around who believe images of women (and men) in magazines to be completely real. Boy, are they in for a rude awakening. I've definitely always dealt with body image issues. Surprisingly, height isn't one of them (Though it was once). All my life, people have constantly told me how really good-looking I am and talked in detail about my amazing features. I like that people have complimented me, but doing so in the magnitude that they have and still do has three possible consequences: 1. Gives you a really big head if you allow it to (Which it did for a while). 2. Make you set a bar of attractiveness for yourself. You need to never allow yourself to get lower than this bar, or, if you begin exercising more (Or period) and get more attractive features, you have set a new bar of attractiveness, and you can never go back to the other one. The only direction in attractiveness you can allow yourself to go is up. 3. Makes you focus on your exterior to the point where it makes you very insecure about yourself, making you think you have perhaps gained weight when you haven't, or that you haven't gained weight but still think you aren't skinny enough (Even though everyone says you're as skinny as a rail). My new motto is to tell people "Thank you for the compliments. But please do me a favor and be more sparing with them, otherwise my perfect facial features will be ruined by my head growing into the size of Pluto."
PhuturePriest Posted December 3, 2013 Author Posted December 3, 2013 Jean-Claude Van Damme? Really? That's who you use as an example? There are tons of more relevant celebrities that you could have used. My dad raised me on Van Damme movies. Sue me.
Ed Normile Posted December 3, 2013 Posted December 3, 2013 I think feeling threatened is a type of body image. Even if it is just feeling threatened about your physical safety, the implication is that you are measuring yourself against their physical capabilities, in the possibility of a fight. Or, another way could be feeling threatened when another man enters your woman's attention...are you good enough to keep her attention? In other words, feeling threatened is by definition comparing yourself to another. And certainly, being a man does not just exist out of thin air...our conceptions of what it means to be men are inherited, from our fathers, from our mothers even, and I guess from media, though how one learns from media varies. In the old days men looked at John Wayne as some kind of icon of manhood...that's an example of male body image. I don't think there's any question that we learn how to be men from seeing other men...the real question is how true we are and how self-aware we are to be able to find ourselves within that influence. Era, I have never actually felt threatened in my life, only a fool would not assess a stranger to see if they may pose a threat. That's said, when you walk down a dark street do you watch your surroundings and size up a possible adversary ? By the way , what kind of women do you keep company with that you have to worry about another man entering? her attention. Here is some unsolicited advice, if the woman you are in company with causes you to question your confidence, then she is no better for you than you are for yourself. ed
GeorgiiMichael Posted December 3, 2013 Posted December 3, 2013 You're a strange one, Ed. I don't know what to make of you.
Spem in alium Posted December 3, 2013 Posted December 3, 2013 Jean-Claude Van Damme? Really? That's who you use as an example? There are tons of more relevant celebrities that you could have used. This is true. I've definitely always dealt with body image issues. Surprisingly, height isn't one of them (Though it was once). All my life, people have constantly told me how really good-looking I am and talked in detail about my amazing features. I like that people have complimented me, but doing so in the magnitude that they have and still do has three possible consequences: 1. Gives you a really big head if you allow it to (Which it did for a while). 2. Make you set a bar of attractiveness for yourself. You need to never allow yourself to get lower than this bar, or, if you begin exercising more (Or period) and get more attractive features, you have set a new bar of attractiveness, and you can never go back to the other one. The only direction in attractiveness you can allow yourself to go is up. 3. Makes you focus on your exterior to the point where it makes you very insecure about yourself, making you think you have perhaps gained weight when you haven't, or that you haven't gained weight but still think you aren't skinny enough (Even though everyone says you're as skinny as a rail). My new motto is to tell people "Thank you for the compliments. But please do me a favor and be more sparing with them, otherwise my perfect facial features will be ruined by my head growing into the size of Pluto." Hah, love the motto. I can relate, though in my situation it's normally always been the opposite as I'm rarely complimented on my appearance. Height's never been an issue for me either, which may be surprising as I am 5". :)
PhuturePriest Posted December 3, 2013 Author Posted December 3, 2013 This is true. Hah, love the motto. I can relate, though in my situation it's normally always been the opposite as I'm rarely complimented on my appearance. Height's never been an issue for me either, which may be surprising as I am 5". :) Another consequence I forgot to mention is it makes you feel like your worth is dictated by your looks alone. I honestly feel worth more if I start exercising and get in better shape. I think it's a shame people don't compliment you on your looks. I can tell you on this side of the lake being told how amazing you look constantly does not make you feel as amazing as you'd think. You end up insecure, which is only hidden by your big-headedness. However, everyone deserves to be complimented, and I can tell you I would rather be complimented on how much of a good person I am rather than my looks. Good looks may get you on the cover of Maxim Magazine, but holiness gets you to heaven.
Spem in alium Posted December 3, 2013 Posted December 3, 2013 Another consequence I forgot to mention is it makes you feel like your worth is dictated by your looks alone. I honestly feel worth more if I start exercising and get in better shape. I think it's a shame people don't compliment you on your looks. I can tell you on this side of the lake being told how amazing you look constantly does not make you feel as amazing as you'd think. You end up insecure, which is only hidden by your big-headedness. However, everyone deserves to be complimented, and I can tell you I would rather be complimented on how much of a good person I am rather than my looks. Good looks may get you on the cover of Maxim Magazine, but holiness gets you to heaven. That seems to be a common consequence - I know quite a few people who seem to feel that way. It's not so much of a problem for me, though it was once. I don't see myself as physically attractive, so usually I find I tend not to believe people when they compliment me on my appearance. In that regard I'm glad I don't receive such compliments so often. Instead, I try to work on bettering my character, as compliments regarding my personality, achievements or actions mean more to me and make a greater impression on me than remarks upon my looks. Several people I know seem to experience what you have described - they receive compliments on their appearance, but instead of being confident they are quite insecure. Everyone definitely deserves to be complimented, yes :)
PhuturePriest Posted December 3, 2013 Author Posted December 3, 2013 That seems to be a common consequence - I know quite a few people who seem to feel that way. It's not so much of a problem for me, though it was once. I don't see myself as physically attractive, so usually I find I tend not to believe people when they compliment me on my appearance. In that regard I'm glad I don't receive such compliments so often. Instead, I try to work on bettering my character, as compliments regarding my personality, achievements or actions mean more to me and make a greater impression on me than remarks upon my looks. Several people I know seem to experience what you have described - they receive compliments on their appearance, but instead of being confident they are quite insecure. Everyone definitely deserves to be complimented, yes :) We seem to be in perfect agreement. I would love to be complimented on the things you mentioned instead of my looks. Being complimented on your looks only honestly feels belittling -- like that's all you are worth and capable of as a human being. It's almost as if people don't see potential in you to amount to much or have the potential to be a really good person.
Era Might Posted December 3, 2013 Posted December 3, 2013 (edited) Era, I have never actually felt threatened in my life, only a fool would not assess a stranger to see if they may pose a threat. That's said, when you walk down a dark street do you watch your surroundings and size up a possible adversary ? By the way , what kind of women do you keep company with that you have to worry about another man entering? her attention. Here is some unsolicited advice, if the woman you are in company with causes you to question your confidence, then she is no better for you than you are for yourself. ed Feeling threatened means you are insecure. Of course, everyone feels insecure...it's not a woman thing. A woman does not cause me to question my confidence, but that doesn't mean that men do not compare themselves with other men vis a vis their women. Just because you are confident doesn't mean nothing could ever happen to cause your wife to stray (or you to stray). You may think you are a god among men to your woman, but your woman sees your flaws more clearly than you do (and if she cares about you, she accepts them). And male influence happens in other ways...that's what marketing is all about, tapping into what people want. Why does Gillette make commercials with men feeling smooth and clean? Because men like to feel smooth and clean, and when they see another man doing it, they want to be smooth and clean too. It's not only metrosexuals who buy shaving cream. It's remarkable that you have never felt threatened in your life. You are missing out on one of the great human experiences...that's when you really learn who you are. Edited December 3, 2013 by Era Might
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now