Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Ok my freind shared this photo from "Being Liberal" Facebook page...

 

1466110_10151848415051275_949089121_n.jp

 

 

I know there is so much wrong with this but i cannot explain what.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

1. Jesus never said, "let the government take your money and redistribute it evenly."
2. Santa uses his own funds/resources to give gifts to people and to provide employment.

I'll let someone else take care of the rest.

Posted

1. Jesus never said, "let the government take your money and redistribute it evenly."
2. Santa uses his own funds/resources to give gifts to people and to provide employment.

I'll let someone else take care of the rest.

 

True but there is more to what Jesus said or did not say, our salvation hinges on Jesus' action of full sacrafice. In Acts the apostle seemed to live in a bit of a socialistic manner. Shareing all with all in the community of believers.

Posted

I have to think that Scrooge would be more accurately described as an Objectivist turned Capitalist :)

Posted

Charity with your own money or time is a virtue.  Charity with another person's money/time is theft/slavery.

Posted (edited)

Santa Claus is a hijacked Sinterklaas... who is St. Nicholas.

 

Christian Charity.... based out of the gospels.

 

Socialism isn't necessarily atheistic... it can be Christian as well.

 

Occupy Wall Street, in this connotation, is a RED HERRING.  No relation at all....

Edited by AnneLine
Posted (edited)

True but there is more to what Jesus said or did not say, our salvation hinges on Jesus' action of full sacrafice. In Acts the apostle seemed to live in a bit of a socialistic manner. Shareing all with all in the community of believers.

 

Voluntary communalism such as was practised by the apostles and in hundreds and thousands of religious communities is very distinct from state sanctioned robbery and theft.  The life of such holy persons is only virtuous because they have of their own will surrendered their natural right to possess private property in an act of oblation to God Almighty.

 

Catholics already possess their own tradition of economic philosophy.  Heinrich Pesch, Hilaire Belloc, Popes Leo XIII and Pius XI.  We should look to them.

Edited by An Historian
Posted

The Grinch doesn't actually “redistribute" the gifts, he makes restitution.

 

 Jesus says give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar and give to God what belongs to God. I don't think this is something that a socialist would say.

brandelynmarie
Posted

Poor Charlie Brown...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...