Byzantine Posted December 17, 2013 Author Posted December 17, 2013 Thanks guys. That gives a lot to think about. Just replying to two of them for now, but I've read all of them and thank you. Actually it's because I am good friends with a Melkiate Catholic who's daughter married a Roman Catholic and is often forced to go to Roman Catholic Mass to meet his obligation. He's the one who expressed frustration that they were inherently different religions even tho they are under the same umbrella. I imagine this would go double for someone in a rite with married priests. Smack him upside the head and tell him to get his act together. So ... does that mean that the boyfriend needs to marry before becoming a priest? Yup. It does make a difference -- if he is willing to chance that a dispensation isn't granted for him to become a priest and is in love with the girl regardless, this says mountains. Now ... if it is more like if I can't get a dispensation then I won't marry so that I can be a priest -- that's another story. I'm sorta confused about the dispensation part. (And yes I understand we're talking a different rite here :) ). In the USA, Eastern Catholics need dispensations from Rome before ordaining a married man to the priesthood. This has developed after a brief but painful history that ended up in the formation of a new Orthodox jurisdiction in the early 20th century.
CrossCuT Posted December 17, 2013 Posted December 17, 2013 Maybe Im a jerk or just a Roman Catholic but it feels to me like he is trying to exploit the dispensation...maybe thats a strong word but do you know what i mean? Maybe in his rite it isnt an exploit but it feels that way to me. "I can be married AND be a priest, do biggy. Ill just get a dispensation." I feel like thats not the right mentality.
NotreDame Posted December 17, 2013 Posted December 17, 2013 In the USA, Eastern Catholics need dispensations from Rome before ordaining a married man to the priesthood. This has developed after a brief but painful history that ended up in the formation of a new Orthodox jurisdiction in the early 20th century. How common is this now? I know my first two ukranian rite parish priests were married, but at least one was ordained over in the old country. None at that parish have been married since. And at my second parish, which was Byzantine, I never even heard of a married byzantine rite priest. It was my impression even the Eastern Rite priests don't get married in the USA anymore.
NotreDame Posted December 17, 2013 Posted December 17, 2013 Actually it's because I am good friends with a Melkiate Catholic who's daughter married a Roman Catholic and is often forced to go to Roman Catholic Mass to meet his obligation. He's the one who expressed frustration that they were inherently different religions even tho they are under the same umbrella. I imagine this would go double for someone in a rite with married priests. It's possible he's being a bit silly and doesn't understand his religion. It's also possible he just goes to Roman rite parishes with really, really bad Sunday Novus Ordo masses (which is probably around 90% of them IMHO.) Think of an eastern rite mass as an EF high mass. Lots of singing, responses are chanted. It's long, reverent, nothing hokey like eucharistic ministers or communion in the hand or Disney-style praise songs - no instruments either, usually. People know each other, actually like each other, get coffee and donuts afterwards, etc. After going to Eastern Rite masses your whole life, rolling into your average OF mass on a sunday would be rough.
blazeingstar Posted December 17, 2013 Posted December 17, 2013 Smack him upside the head and tell him to get his act together. Seriously? He's a Medical doctor and a studied theologian with 9 children he is a great guy. He knows the difference in theology and said it out of protection for his daughter. He showed me how the different traditions while under the guise of "rites" to preserve the Eucharist, and sees the damage marrying outside your rite has caused his family. (He's one of 11). It is not easy to be Catholic in this world even if "Catholic" means the exact same thing to both members of the couple. Hardcore TLM's who marry (if they choose to) OF members often have big struggles even tho they are in the same rite!!!! This is pressure that a new marriage doesn't need and should be approached with the same caution as marrying someone in a different religion as high Anglican Masses are far closer to TLM than the OF is...and can easily cause compromise in an answer outside of the Catholic church. There are so many child-raising issues even in TLM vs OF. Head covering, alter servers, version of scripture, language, music, etc. This is only magnified by being in a different rite. If the children have a priest for a father, you have to realize they very well may never be accepted by Roman Catholics due to both misinformation and that many strongly believe there should be no married priests, period. The woman would be basically giving up her rite.
blazeingstar Posted December 17, 2013 Posted December 17, 2013 It's possible he's being a bit silly and doesn't understand his religion. It's also possible he just goes to Roman rite parishes with really, really bad Sunday Novus Ordo masses (which is probably around 90% of them IMHO.) Think of an eastern rite mass as an EF high mass. Lots of singing, responses are chanted. It's long, reverent, nothing hokey like eucharistic ministers or communion in the hand or Disney-style praise songs - no instruments either, usually. People know each other, actually like each other, get coffee and donuts afterwards, etc. After going to Eastern Rite masses your whole life, rolling into your average OF mass on a sunday would be rough. I've been to Melkiate, Low Latin Mass and High Latin Mass and I worship in the Ordinary form. I would have serious concerns about marrying someone who does not worship in my rite. It could cause a lot of heartbreak. I can't fathom going to Melkiate, Low Latin Mass or High Latin Mass for the rest of my life, I'd be devastated. To me, it is dark, overly solemn, very exclusinary and even though I understand a decent amout of Latin, off putting that it's in a different language. Parishioners tend to be very holy-roller, too, which dosn't help. A person raised in those, on the other hand, would probably struggle with the OF. You're right it would be rough...and to ask my spouse to attend Mass with me on a regular basis would be alot to ask of him. It would be too difficult to do dual parishes once children come. I firmly believe in having a parish home. Yes, many OF masses are bad, but that's really not the fault of OF masses. I've found that TLM are often WAY closed off and elitist and prone to their own abuses. Abuses come from priests and parishoners not following the church and I find the OF "full of abuse" claim as bad and as vicious as Windows VS Mac debate.
MIKolbe Posted December 17, 2013 Posted December 17, 2013 Okay, this might belong in VS, but here goes. Just want to see the reactions. Your daughter, who is in college with a non-money-making major (theology, history, Humanities and Catholic Culture, etc, you get the idea) is introducing boyfriend, who has a similar sort of major. Naturally, you want to know what sort of plans he has to take care of your daughter should this lead toward marriage, so you ask. He explains to you that he's discerning a call to the priesthood and, responding to your quizzical look, says that he's of the Byzantine Rite and with a dispensation his bishop could ordain him a married priest. When asked how likely it is that he would get said dispensation, he replies that he doesn't know. When you ask how many such dispensations have been issued, he again doesn't know. When you ask what he would do if he didn't get said dispensation, he replies that he'd probably teach religion/Latin/history in a (most likely Catholic) high school. AAAAAAAAAAAaaaaaaannnnnnnnnnddddddd react.
HisChild Posted December 17, 2013 Posted December 17, 2013 Well hmmm. I've been to ordinary form Mass, low Latin, high Latin, Byzantine Rite and full Orthodox liturgy. For those I've met and/or know who have also experienced (more than once or twice) other Rites, their attitudes are NOT ambivalent. There's a reason they chose the Rite (or in the case of the Eastern Orthodox, the religion) they did. These two young people are of different Rites? Is she all right with changing Rites? I don't know if this was mentioned before but I'm pretty sure, because she'd be his wife, she would be required to officially change Rites. I was never asked to when I made a Byzantine parish my home 5 yrs ago. I was told could be known as Roman Rite while attending, but could if I felt called to do so. (I'm no longer there as I moved out of the area, so that issue became moot for me.) I know for Orthodox men who aspire to the priesthood, their wives are required to also be fully Orthodox. I have good friends who were raised Eastern Catholic, but now he (the husband) is Orthodox. He's a deacon...and cannot be ordained a priest unless his wife converts. She's still E. Catholic. One other thing you should ask of your daughter is if she's aware of her own potential time commitment to her parish. I do know not know well the priest's wife's role in Eastern Rite churches. But I do know four matushkas/presvyteras... Eastern O. wives. All but one are intimately involved in the parish, ie: choir director, Sunday school director, etc. a priest's vocation is a family affair, at times. Is she all right with that, should she be asked to assume an active role where he serves? Just thoughts...
Basilisa Marie Posted December 17, 2013 Posted December 17, 2013 Maybe Im a jerk or just a Roman Catholic but it feels to me like he is trying to exploit the dispensation...maybe thats a strong word but do you know what i mean? Maybe in his rite it isnt an exploit but it feels that way to me. "I can be married AND be a priest, do biggy. Ill just get a dispensation." I feel like thats not the right mentality. Yeah, that's why I'd like to find out what the normal dispensation reasons are. Are they more there for people who convert from Orthodoxy and want to remain a married priest in the Byzantine Rite? Even Romans give dispensations for Protestant converts who are married pastors and want to be priests (not common at all, but it happens). Dispensations are usually created for extra-ordinary situations, because the norms are there for a reason, and should be followed unless there's a very good reason not to. And to those who say that changing rites isn't changing religion - While it's theologically true that it's the same religion, in one's day to day life there are a lot of differences between Latin parishes and other kinds. When I've visited my local Maronite and Byzantine churches, it almost feels like a different religion, if I'm not paying close attention to what's going on. There seemed to be lots of little cultural differences too, because the Maronite parish served a very strongly Lebonese community. I've been to a Greek Orthodox church, and they had far more in common with the Eastern Rites than the Eastern Rites did with the Latin, at least judging by liturgy and whatnot. My experiences are limited, but I'd guess that they're similar to at least some other areas of the country.
NotreDame Posted December 17, 2013 Posted December 17, 2013 (edited) Yeah, that's why I'd like to find out what the normal dispensation reasons are. Are they more there for people who convert from Orthodoxy and want to remain a married priest in the Byzantine Rite? Even Romans give dispensations for Protestant converts who are married pastors and want to be priests (not common at all, but it happens). Dispensations are usually created for extra-ordinary situations, because the norms are there for a reason, and should be followed unless there's a very good reason not to. There has been a long early tradition of celibacy in the Church, but also an early tradition of married clergy. The Eastern Rites (which in some cases left with the orthodox and re-joined Rome later) in many cases never dropped the tradition of married pastors. Parish priests in these rites could often be married and but only serve as parish priests while celibacy was reserved for monks and the hierarchy (ie. bishops.) And back to the whole "different rites are almost different religions" thing people keep bringing up. As someone that was baptized ukranian, raised in a byzantine Church (because we moved), then attending almost exclusively roman rite (often in Spanish)... I don't see it this way and I think it's a very imprecise way of explaining the gap. I think the divide you are seeing isn't religious so much as it is cultural or experiential. I know there are people from my Ukranian parish that would see going to a roman rite as a huge deal, but they are Ukranian and speak Ukranian as their first language and, from a cultural standpoint, would not feel comfortable. They had a son that got married and changed to Russian Orthodox (I know he became a deacon and think he wanted to become a priest.) His mother wasn't bothered so much by him becoming Orthodox as by the fact that he joined up with the Russians (Catholic Uki's don't like Russians.) So on paper these rites are all the same religion and dogmas. To say otherwise is just false. However, the cultural divides are great and sometimes significant. Edited December 17, 2013 by NotreDame
Byzantine Posted December 17, 2013 Author Posted December 17, 2013 Maybe Im a jerk or just a Roman Catholic but it feels to me like he is trying to exploit the dispensation...maybe thats a strong word but do you know what i mean? Maybe in his rite it isnt an exploit but it feels that way to me. "I can be married AND be a priest, do biggy. Ill just get a dispensation." I feel like thats not the right mentality. Having to get the dispensation is (hopefully) a part of transitioning back to us being able to ordain married men freely, as we can in the old country. As far as I'm aware, this doesn't have anything to do with Orthodox clergy who rejoin communion and seems to only apply to the act of ordination. We have several married priests who were ordained in the old country and immigrated here (at the invitation of one of our bishops, I understand). Last year, two married priests were ordained in the western US, but both were, while not old, older, i.e. the kids of both had already grown up and moved out. We have three that I'm aware of that are awaiting their dispensations before being ordained; one is a cradle ByzCat (with 4 young kids), one switched over from the Latin Rite (two kids born, one on the way), and one has a very interesting story that I'll not post on here (5 kids ranging from college to probably around 6). Let's back up to the OP and assume the conversation everyone wants to happen between guy and girl had happened previously. And mods, can the parts which are an argument over whether or not the Eastern and Western Catholic Churches are in communion or not possibly be moved elsewhere? I get the fact that a girl raised Latin Rite would very likely have some serious reservations about becoming a priest's wife and that this would obviously require some serious thought and prayer. My question in posting the thread was, what would you, the parent, think?
AnneLine Posted December 17, 2013 Posted December 17, 2013 Byz, I like the way you both answered our concerns, and suggested (exceptionally tactfully!) that we get back on the question at hand. (If you want the mods to make that change, report your own thread! ;) I bet they will do it!) Byz, we'll accept your 'stipulation' that the gentleman and his beloved have already had all the required conversations, and that she is doing all the necessary soul-searching, and that he is doing all the checking it twice with his Eparchy (or whatever).... The question for the gentleman from a potential mother-in-law would lbe: will you make my daughter happy? can you support my daughter and/or can the two of you make it work as a couple financially, emotionally, physically? What are your contingencies if you do/don't get the ok to get ordained? If I were the potential mother-in-law, I would be both asking for the answers.... but more importantly, I'd be evaluating what both he and my daughter were saying and how they were working together. I know enough to know that people in love aren't always practical... and that is OK to a point. But I would want to be pretty sure from hisanswers AND the way he was/they were answering them (i.e., 'I don't have the answer to that question... but it is on my radar, and I am in the process of getting it answered'; or 'we have already discussed this and we have x, y, and z determined and we are still praying about m, n...' AND, perhaps most importantly, 'We aren't totally to the point of getting engaged, but wanted you to know about this possibilitly because it is starting to get serious, and we don't want to dump it on you at the last minute...' THOSE would be interesting to me as a potential mother-in-law.... and would go a long way to getting me on his side.... I would want to have some hard facts about, if he was teaching HS, what might the $$$ and benefits would look like, and if he were to be ordained, what would THAT $$$$ and benefits would look like. And insurance. And housing. Bottom line... have the two of you thought this through? So... yup, the guy would need to at least let me know (ideally volunteered BEFORE I asked him!) that he/the two of them had this stuff on the radar. I'm praying for this guy... and ALL the guys & gals that will have, uh, interesting conversations with potential in-laws this Christmas.....
HisChild Posted December 17, 2013 Posted December 17, 2013 Right. Your scenario was presented: I am the parent of a daughter and her beloved might possibly become more than just a boyfriend, although they are not yet engaged. He has no desires for a career with much financial potential. In fact, if given proper dispensation, he could become a priest...or a teacher, if not. Your directive: AAAAAAAAAAAaaaaaaannnnnnnnnnddddddd react. My response isn't so much to seek more from him, but from her. Hence my post and inquiries as to her thoughts of Rite changing and potentially being involved in his ministry. If she's okay with where that might take her, I, as her parent, would rejoice with her.
Anastasia13 Posted December 18, 2013 Posted December 18, 2013 (edited) I thought Byz's kids would be Eastern Catholic. I don't get it. It's amesome he is Eastern Catholic. There is much tradition and history that is not told in Western Christianity. I'd wonder if the guy is really ok with getting a teaching credential or what not. And if my daughter is majoring in philosophy or theology or something, is she getting a credential, going to law school, something like that, and if not, did she take those typing and computer courses I wanted her to take at community college or a practical minor with plans for good internships? (Is the guy going to do similar things? I don't want a lazy brainiac who can't put food on the table fathering kids in the family, (not to be harsh, he's not married yet so I would have stricter standards for my acceptance of his presence, post wedding I'd have less say in the matter and more reason to want him sticking around)) If he gets serious with my daughter though, he better be willing to live without a dispensation before he breaks her heart. You know what, maybe y'all should just become Byzantine. Liturgies are fun in the east. Edited December 18, 2013 by Light and Truth
Anastasia13 Posted December 18, 2013 Posted December 18, 2013 (edited) There has been a long early tradition of celibacy in the Church, but also an early tradition of married clergy. The Eastern Rites (which in some cases left with the orthodox and re-joined Rome later) in many cases never dropped the tradition of married pastors. Parish priests in these rites could often be married and but only serve as parish priests while celibacy was reserved for monks and the hierarchy (ie. bishops.) And back to the whole "different rites are almost different religions" thing people keep bringing up. As someone that was baptized ukranian, raised in a byzantine Church (because we moved), then attending almost exclusively roman rite (often in Spanish)... I don't see it this way and I think it's a very imprecise way of explaining the gap. I think the divide you are seeing isn't religious so much as it is cultural or experiential. I know there are people from my Ukranian parish that would see going to a roman rite as a huge deal, but they are Ukranian and speak Ukranian as their first language and, from a cultural standpoint, would not feel comfortable. They had a son that got married and changed to Russian Orthodox (I know he became a deacon and think he wanted to become a priest.) His mother wasn't bothered so much by him becoming Orthodox as by the fact that he joined up with the Russians (Catholic Uki's don't like Russians.) So on paper these rites are all the same religion and dogmas. To say otherwise is just false. However, the cultural divides are great and sometimes significant. This is so eastern. You get it. I want to extra prop the culture not religion part. Edited December 18, 2013 by Light and Truth
NotreDame Posted December 18, 2013 Posted December 18, 2013 You know what, maybe y'all should just become Byzantine. Liturgies are fun in the east. Ha ha, that's a good way to put it!
Anastasia13 Posted December 18, 2013 Posted December 18, 2013 Ha ha, that's a good way to put it! Liturgy in the East, it's not just an obligation, it's Divine.
AnneLine Posted December 18, 2013 Posted December 18, 2013 (edited) boo... hiss..... (for the humor, not the sentiment) Edited December 18, 2013 by AnneLine
Byzantine Posted December 18, 2013 Author Posted December 18, 2013 Thanks all! Liturgy in the East, it's not just an obligation, it's Divine. I am incensed by this humor >:( :)
Cherie Posted December 18, 2013 Posted December 18, 2013 My question in posting the thread was, what would you, the parent, think? Honestly? My immediate reaction, without thinking on it much (and realizing it's probably extremely judgmental for me to be thinking this) is what Crosscut said: Maybe Im a jerk or just a Roman Catholic but it feels to me like he is trying to exploit the dispensation...maybe thats a strong word but do you know what i mean? Maybe in his rite it isnt an exploit but it feels that way to me. "I can be married AND be a priest, do biggy. Ill just get a dispensation." I feel like thats not the right mentality. I've met a FEW men, some of them seminarians, who had this mentality. "I want to be a priest but I want to be married so ...... instead of properly discerning my calling I'll just pick both! Yay for Eastern Rite married priests!!!" This guy is a little different, I guess, in that he thinks he'll definitely end up in seminary, girl or no, but still... I think as a parent who was ALSO a former religious who went through years of my own discernment, I'd be wary. I tend to be a skeptic at first anyway, though. And I am being RAW in my honesty here. It really is pretty judgmental for me to automatically be skeptical of him, huh? But hey, I'm just being honest in admitting that was my first thought. But ultimately, the discussion lies with my daughter, and I'd need to know a whole lot more about her thoughts on this before I'd proceed in forming my opinion on it.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now