Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

We already have other TV show threads so I wanted to add this one as well!

 

Does anyone watch? Apparently Downton Abbey is now named the most watched drama on public television since forever.

Posted

I LOVE it... but can't take time to write more now.... but very open to discussing it! 

 

We need to be careful about spoilers, however, because the UK members have seen all... and I gather the Australian members won't get Season 4 for a few more months! 

 

We could discuss thru season 3 with no problems.... and there are always PMs...... :)

Posted

I agree! Spoiler tags will have to be utilizes!

Posted

I *love* Downton! I only started watching in series 4 though - my mum is a fan and insisted on watching. She has earlier seasons on DVD though so that might be what I do tomorrow. :P

 

I'll have to learn how to do the spoiler tags...

Posted

[s.poiler] blah blah blah [/s.poiler]

 

[spoiler]blah blah blah[/spoiler]

Posted

[s.poiler] blah blah blah [/s.poiler]

 

 

THIS is how to do a spoiler?   I've never known!

 

Let's see....

 

[s.poiler]starting with season 4 would really make one get confused.....[/s.poiler]

Posted

Nope, that obviously isn't the right route... but it is the right comment, Emily --- you MUST watch the videos in order or you will really regret it....

Posted (edited)

I do NOT know how to do spoilers (and would like to know) but can I suggest, Crosscut, it might be nice to just give people a chance to get say... .caught up on Season 1 for this week... and seasons 2 and 3 the following week?   We certainly could discuss the opening episode and its content this week.... ?  

 

Because it would be TOO easy for someone to forget to put spoilers around some content.  I found out a significant event ahead of time by accident... and it really made the episodes kind of odd for me in places..... because I knew what was coming....

 

But it is your thread, so you make the decisions.

 

If anyone has Amazon Prime you get free access to all the previous episodes, btw... Seasons 1-3.....

 

ALSO if you want to know a bit more about the time period, check out Youtube for 'Edwardian Farm' (and 'Victorian Farm' for that matter) -- will give you some EXCELLENT background for this series!

Edited by AnneLine
Posted

Never watched it, but everything Maggie Smith makes is worth watching.

Posted

Catherine, I think you would love it.... it reminds me a bit of Gone with the Wind in the sense of over-the-top melodrama and the 'period' being perfectly portrayed... but there are a lot of thinking person's subplots and a LOT of social commentary that I think will be interesting to discuss with phellow phatmassers!

Posted

I do NOT know how to do spoilers (and would like to know) but can I suggest, Crosscut, it might be nice to just give people a chance to get say... .caught up on Season 1 for this week... and seasons 2 and 3 the following week?   We certainly could discuss the opening episode and its content this week.... ?  

 

Because it would be TOO easy for someone to forget to put spoilers around some content.  I found out a significant event ahead of time by accident... and it really made the episodes kind of odd for me in places..... because I knew what was coming....

 

But it is your thread, so you make the decisions.

 

If anyone has Amazon Prime you get free access to all the previous episodes, btw... Seasons 1-3.....

 

ALSO if you want to know a bit more about the time period, check out Youtube for 'Edwardian Farm' (and 'Victorian Farm' for that matter) -- will give you some EXCELLENT background for this series!

 

We dont have to discuss season 4 yet of course because its just starting in the US now.

But im excited to talk to people about it! :)

Posted

Yup...   I'm just saying that there are 6 or 7 episodes to each season... and some people haven't seen any of 'em yet.  We need to give 'em a chance to get caught up!!!!

 

But I would think we can start talking about Season 1 Episode 1 say... by this weekend?  And discuss characters in that episode pretty easily without giving away any secrets.

 

I loved the way they handled the opening scenes.... such a well-done intro to the historical moment, to the characters, to the roles.... just impeccably plotted.

Posted (edited)

Let me try this spoiler thing out then...

 

[spoiler] I made it work! [/spoiler]

 

AnneLine, it works if you take out the '.' from what CrossCut said! Almost missed that myself :hehe:

Edited by EmilyAnn
Posted (edited)

THANK YOU EMILY ANN!!!!!!

 

 

Emily, it's obvious you CAN teach an old Llama new tricks!

 

Tried this.... and the result is....

 

[spoiler]a new baby lamb![/spoiler]

 

YES!  it works!    It must be a gift from Pope Francis!

 

[spoiler]o-POPE-FRANCIS-900.jpg?1

[/spoiler]

Edited by AnneLine
DiscerningCatholic
Posted

I've been reading "Downton Abbey" as "Downtown Abbey" since I first heard about it. :blush:

 

Now I know better. :proud:

 

In other news, I have a great idea for a Catholic TV series... :think:

Posted

Let me try this spoiler thing out then...

 

[spoiler] I made it work! [/spoiler]

 

AnneLine, it works if you take out the '.' from what CrossCut said! Almost missed that myself :hehe:

 

 

THANK YOU EMILY ANN!!!!!!

 

 

Emily, it's obvious you CAN teach an old Llama new tricks!

 

Tried this.... and the result is....

 

[spoiler]a new baby lamb![/spoiler]

 

YES!  it works!    It must be a gift from Pope Francis!

 

[spoiler]o-POPE-FRANCIS-900.jpg?1

[/spoiler]

 

Oops! I forgot to mention you need to take out the periods! Thanks Emily! :)

Posted (edited)

I hardly remember what the other seasons were about...umm lets talk season 1?

 

[spoiler] I think the first season was one of the best. I think one of the big things that interested me was its own personal narrative on the change of time and the beginning of a new era where the large, wealthy, servant run lifestyles were beginning to die out.

There are some little things that I always found humorous...like when Maggie Smith's character comments on the electric lights and how they are hurting her eyes. Just little things like that I can appreciate! It was cool to me to witness how people dealt with (whether their reactions were factual or not) the changing of an era and the entrance of electricity as it was starting to become a norm. 

 

I think the Titanic time stamp at the very beginning was also nice and how they used that to mold together the plot for the season.

 

As far as individual characters go, Lord Grandthom was pretty cool, I didnt really have much of an opinion of him. He sort of took a back seat in my mind compared to some of the other characters. Lady Grandthom was cute although in the beginning, I had such a hard time distinguishing her accent. She is an american actress but the way she spoke was so odd to me! Did anyone else feel that way?

 

Mary. One word: [bleep]. She was a very stuck up, entitled, snob. I didnt like her much but sure her character was suppose to come off that way in order to create some fan entangling drama with Matthew (her seeming opposite).

 

Matthew is great. I have always enjoyed Matthew.

 

Edith in the first season was just as snobby as Mary but in a very whiny way. She was constantly feeling bad for herself and taking it out on Mary. The jealousy she had for her older sister really was the main thing she seemed to focus on and she blamed Mary for anything bad that happened to her.

 

Sibil was my absolute favorite. They had to give us a nice looking, moderately important, female character to latch onto since the first two werent good options in my opinion. Sibil embodied (to me) everything the world was working towards in that time. She was new, fresh, and curious about everything! She was not opposed to change and in fact she embraced it. She was very free spirited and just a fun character to have on the show.

 

Violet (Maggie Smith) is also hilarious. She might seem on the surface like a very snobby lady who is completely stuck in this aristocracy sort of lifestyle, but she has some fun tricks up her sleeve. While she does do and say some pretty stuffy things, there are quite a few times where she is the confidant when things go wrong or dont go according to how their lifestyle dictates. 

 

Lady Crawley is another one of my favorites. She is very similar to Sibil's character. She is an ahead-of-her-time female role and its fun to see her clash with the Granthoms.

 

 

 

Another thing I quite enjoyed was that half of the show centered around the employees in the house! The cooks, the butlers, the footman, the ladies maids etc. I really liked that aspect!

 

 

There are lots of other things I could say but Ill just leave it at that for now and wait for everyone else to chime in. :)[/spoiler]

Edited by CrossCuT

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...