PhuturePriest Posted January 9, 2014 Posted January 9, 2014 (edited) Interesting question/debate of the day: Is not doing school (As in primary school) a sin? Let's just say you were in high school, and you were like "You know what? Kitten memes." and skipped school. Would that be a mortal or even venial sin? I've heard people say education is like your current vocation, so not doing it would be going against God's will. Also, this was made because the171 wanted to debate/troll a thread. Edited January 9, 2014 by FuturePriest387
arfink Posted January 9, 2014 Posted January 9, 2014 (edited) Interesting question/debate of the day: Is not doing school (As in primary school) a sin? Let's just say you were in high school, and you were like And I was like Edited January 9, 2014 by arfink
ChristinaTherese Posted January 9, 2014 Posted January 9, 2014 Was that supposed to continue, Padre Bel Viso? (Yes, I liked that ClemensBruno called you that.)
PhuturePriest Posted January 9, 2014 Author Posted January 9, 2014 Was that supposed to continue, Padre Bel Viso? (Yes, I liked that ClemensBruno called you that.) Whatever are you talking about?
ChristinaTherese Posted January 9, 2014 Posted January 9, 2014 Whatever are you talking about? Well, apparently nothing anymore.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 9, 2014 Posted January 9, 2014 I think it is primarily the prerogative of the parents (say it ten times fast now) to determine how their child should be educated. I would not say that skipping school is a sin in and of itself*, but it is probably sinful inasmuch as it opposes the parents' legitimate authority. I think it would be a specious argument to say that high school, for instance, constitutes a child's vocation and therefore that skipping school is somehow a denial of a vocation or a rejection of God's will. I think that is silly. *Example: The child leaving school during school hours cannot be intrinsically immoral, since a parent would be entirely within his authority to pull the child from school himself.
PhuturePriest Posted January 9, 2014 Author Posted January 9, 2014 I think it is primarily the prerogative of the parents (say it ten times fast now) to determine how their child should be educated. I would not say that skipping school is a sin in and of itself*, but it is probably sinful inasmuch as it opposes the parents' legitimate authority. I think it would be a specious argument to say that high school, for instance, constitutes a child's vocation and therefore that skipping school is somehow a denial of a vocation or a rejection of God's will. I think that is silly. *Example: The child leaving school during school hours cannot be intrinsically immoral, since a parent would be entirely within his authority to pull the child from school himself. What if the kid in question had a vocation to the priesthood, and was now unable to go to seminary because he screwed himself over by not doing school? Wouldn't skipping school inadvertently be denying your vocation?
CrossCuT Posted January 9, 2014 Posted January 9, 2014 Let's just say you were in high school, and you were like "You know what? Kitten memes." Probably one of the best lines I have read all week. Thank you FP. And no, I dont think its a sin unless it was dog memes.
PhuturePriest Posted January 9, 2014 Author Posted January 9, 2014 Probably one of the best lines I have read all week. Thank you FP. And no, I dont think its a sin unless it was dog memes. I aim to please.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 9, 2014 Posted January 9, 2014 What if the kid in question had a vocation to the priesthood, and was now unable to go to seminary because he screwed himself over by not doing school? Wouldn't skipping school inadvertently be denying your vocation? I think it would be unfair to hold someone to the obligations of his vocation before such a time as he discovers or understands the vocation, or even before it is revealed to him. God may operate outside of time, but we do not. A guy having sex without being married is a sin, but he does not pre-emptively break his vow of chastity if he decides to become a Franciscan priest some years down the road. I will go back to parental authority. He sins inasmuch as he opposes their legitimate authority over him, but he does not deny God's will, if God's will has yet to be made manifest with regards to his vocation.
blazeingstar Posted January 9, 2014 Posted January 9, 2014 The Finnish don't start formal education until age 7/8, and even then they don't start rigorous all-day education until late teens. Most American kindergartners have more expected of them as far as sitting still. I think this would fall under the sin of sloth. To say it would affect a vocation to the point of ruining it is just plain silly, as men become priests at 50 or 60 and surly by then they could of completed highschool.
KnightofChrist Posted January 9, 2014 Posted January 9, 2014 More like sin of... Not when they poop-pee on the carpet.
CatherineM Posted January 9, 2014 Posted January 9, 2014 My son's biological mother took him out of school the second week of first grade because they wanted him tested for learning disabilities. She home schooled him without a single requirement or oversight. He learned basic math and religion. Nothing else. He can barely read and has had no history or literature or science. I think it is a crime she was allowed to do this. I'm a supporter of homeschooling, but to not properly educate a child that you are responsible for isn't what homeschoolers should support.
arfink Posted January 9, 2014 Posted January 9, 2014 My son's biological mother took him out of school the second week of first grade because they wanted him tested for learning disabilities. She home schooled him without a single requirement or oversight. He learned basic math and religion. Nothing else. He can barely read and has had no history or literature or science. I think it is a crime she was allowed to do this. I'm a supporter of homeschooling, but to not properly educate a child that you are responsible for isn't what homeschoolers should support. Yes, I agree. Although, the oversight thing can be a problem, depending on how far the state takes it. In Minnesota they have some oversight, like testing and registration and such, but it's not overbearing at all, so far as I can see. It gives the state a little clout too if a parent is depriving their kids.
Norseman82 Posted January 10, 2014 Posted January 10, 2014 I have a taste for pudding, but I didn't eat my meat!
i<3franciscans Posted January 10, 2014 Posted January 10, 2014 More like sin of... This is slightly terrifying...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now